Wanna blog? Start your own hockey blog with My HockeyBuzz. Register for free today!

Current Hurricanes lineup vs. last year’s playoff lineup: Defense/Goalies

July 28, 2020, 5:50 PM ET [3 Comments]
Ben Shelley
Carolina Hurricanes Blogger • RSSArchiveCONTACT
Follow me on Twitter: @BenShelley_20
Follow HockeyBuzz Hurricanes on Twitter: @HB_Canes

Following up on an article from last week, where I compared the Carolina Hurricanes’ current forward lineup to the one they iced during the playoffs last year, this article will look at how the Hurricanes’ defense and goaltending compares to last season.

Here’s what Carolina’s pairings looked like last year in the first round against the Washington Capitals:

Slavin - Hamilton
Pesce - Faulk
de Haan - van Riemsdyk


Scratches: Fleury

Here’s a potential lineup for the qualifying round:

Slavin - Vatanen
Skjei - Edmundson
Gardiner - Fleury


Scratches: van Riemsdyk
Injuries: Hamilton, Pesce

Obviously, with Hamilton and Pesce in the lineup, this wouldn’t even be close in terms of picking the better lineup. But as of now, the Hurricanes are missing two of their top three defensemen and while they have more depth on defense than probably any team in the league, it’s still a huge blow to the team. It’s likely that four of the six defensemen starting for the Hurricanes will be players who weren’t with the team for last year’s series against the Capitals.

Not including injured players, the major losses from last season’s defense group are Justin Faulk and Calvin de Haan. In turn, the Hurricanes have added Joel Edmundson, Jake Gardiner, Brady Skjei and Sami Vatanen, which, when you break it down, is actually quite significant. That’s amplified when we consider that Edmundson, Skjei and Vatanen are likely to make up three players of Carolina’s top-four defense group.

Despite this, the top-four, as it stands in the projection, isn’t as strong as last year. Vatanen isn’t a better top-pairing defenseman than Hamilton, Edmundson isn’t as strong defensively as Pesce and Skjei doesn’t provide as much offensive upside as Faulk. Even the bottom pairing is a bit iffy, as Haydn Fleury has a lack of NHL playoff experience and Jake Gardiner is a wild card every time he has the puck.

Meanwhile in net, Petr Mrazek returned as a starter and Carolina substituted Curtis McElhinney for James Reimer as a backup. McElhinney was good last season for the Hurricanes and Reimer’s been pretty decent this year as well, making the situation in goal pretty similar to last season.

With Hamilton and Pesce in the lineup, there’s obviously not a doubt that Carolina’s defense is better now than last year. However, factoring in the injuries, the Hurricanes are actually likely weaker defensively than they were last season and are in a pretty similar situation in net.

***NOTE: We've launched a HockeyBuzz Hurricanes Twitter account! For anyone interested, you can follow @HB_Canes for updates on articles, Hurricanes news, etc. We're starting right from scratch, so any followers would be appreciated!***

Here’s today’s poll question (results and discussion will be posted in a future article):

Factoring in the injuries to Hamilton/Pesce, Carolina's defense is:
Weaker than last season
Stronger than last season
No different


Reviewing last week's polls (July 27): Hurricanes Edition
SHORT READ: Jack Drury reportedly heading to Sweden for 2020-21 season
SHORT READ: Dougie Hamilton reportedly injured, could miss weeks
Current Hurricanes lineup vs. last year’s playoff lineup: Forwards
Which of Carolina’s defensemen will be scratched in the qualifying round?
Reviewing this week's polls (July 18): Hurricanes Edition
This time around, Hurricanes face pressure to perform in the playoffs
Will Morgan Geekie have a spot in Carolina’s playoff lineup?
Will the Hurricanes use Ryan Suzuki in the playoffs?
Reviewing last week's polls (July 6): Hurricanes Edition
Hurricanes will likely rely heavily on Hamilton and Slavin against Rangers
SHORT READ: Rick Dudley leaving the Hurricanes
Join the Discussion: » 3 Comments » Post New Comment
More from Ben Shelley
» Hurricanes advance: Notes from Game 3 vs. Rangers
» Game 3 Preview: Hurricanes vs. Rangers
» Notes from Game 2 vs. Rangers
» Game 2 Preview: Hurricanes vs. Rangers
» Notes from Game 1 vs. Rangers