This is an awful trade for the Sabres. Stewart and Greening might both be disappointing players, but Stewart is the better player as he actually produces points. Erhoff is a very steady d-man and is by far the best player in the deal, by a mile. Neil is not worth anything close to a 2nd rounder at the moment, particularly for a rebuilding team. Buffalo's second is most likely going to be a pick in the early 30s. People love throwing Prince and Pag to "add" to the deal, but they are both middle tier prospects. Nothing Buffalo doesn't already have. One want's out allegedly and one had a hot game or two against Montreal in the playoffs.
- Gord_Wilson_2.0
Agreed, ridiculous ripoff for Buffalo.
this is what I mean about not having enough to get a deal done. We don't have enough in the prospect pool to entice Buffalo into giving up Ehrhoff, without selling one of our blue-chippers, and he isn't worth that.
We only have five groups of assets to trade right now:
1) Spezza
2) Nearly untouchable youth/prospects teams would ask for: Zib, Lazar, Ceci
3) Mid-tier prospects: Pageau, Prince, Stone, Hoffman, Puempel, Claesson
4) Crappy roster players: Greening, Neil, Phillips
5) Roster players we have no reason to trade and likely won't: Turris, Karlsson, MacArthur, Ryan, etc.