Now, now don’t be putting names in my mouth
- Makita

Marwood hates everything Canucks. lol

Speaking of redrafts, I'm curious where people rank Boqvist, Bouchard, Dobson after +1 season.

I dont think many had any of those guys before Hughes. I liked Bouchard and I'm pretty sure Pres had Boqvist ahead of him but cant remember anyone else.

Hughes: 32 Games 5G 28A -2 NCAA
Boqvist: 52 Games 20G 39A +15 OHL
Bouchard: 7 Games 1 G -5 NHL
43 Games 13 G 36A +30 OHL
Dobson: 44 Games 15G 35A +8 QMJHL
- belcherbd

I had Dobson and Bouchard ahead of him.

Also, add Sabres and Colorado to the list of 4 of 5 top 10 picks. That puts 3 teams plus Canucks in similar positions.

Hopefully this summer.
- Reubenkincade

Good to hear, I’ll be away all Sept, but home most of the other times

Speaking of redrafts, I'm curious where people rank Boqvist, Bouchard, Dobson after +1 season.

I dont think many had any of those guys before Hughes. I liked Bouchard and I'm pretty sure Pres had Boqvist ahead of him but cant remember anyone else.

Hughes: 32 Games 5G 28A -2 NCAA
Boqvist: 52 Games 20G 39A +15 OHL
Bouchard: 7 Games 1 G -5 NHL
43 Games 13 G 36A +30 OHL
Dobson: 44 Games 15G 35A +8 QMJHL
- belcherbd

Hughes had at 3ov , top flight offensive defender with speed to burn
Boqvist. Had at 5ov, boom or bust, huge shot, wanted him but glad Hughes fell.
Dobson. Had at 10ov, wil be a solid number 3/4
Bouchard, I think, is a Cam Barker bust.

Good to hear, I’ll be away all Sept, but home most of the other times
- Makita

Sounds good. I expect too be pretty busy up here for next few years, so gotta get away when I can.

Speaking of redrafts, I'm curious where people rank Boqvist, Bouchard, Dobson after +1 season.

I dont think many had any of those guys before Hughes. I liked Bouchard and I'm pretty sure Pres had Boqvist ahead of him but cant remember anyone else.

Hughes: 32 Games 5G 28A -2 NCAA
Boqvist: 52 Games 20G 39A +15 OHL
Bouchard: 7 Games 1 G -5 NHL
43 Games 13 G 36A +30 OHL
Dobson: 44 Games 15G 35A +8 QMJHL
- belcherbd

I think they all need to be evaluated on the same playing field, too many different variables between junior and NCAA.
Another year after they all had a chance in the NHL would be a better indication for redraft.

I had Dobson and Bouchard ahead of him.

Also, add Sabres and Colorado to the list of 4 of 5 top 10 picks. That puts 3 teams plus Canucks in similar positions.
- Reubenkincade

You had Dobson and Bouchard ahead of Hughes or Boqvist?

Buf got Eichel, Risto and Reinhardt.
Avs got MacKinnon, Rantanen, Jost

I think they all need to be evaluated on the same playing field, too many different variables between junior and NCAA.
Another year after they all had a chance in the NHL would be a better indication for redraft.
- Makita

For sure, but it there were a lot of stong opinions last year and if anything I think its still pretty murky but looks like all still are on track to be difference makers.

Hughes had at 3ov , top flight offensive defender with speed to burn
Boqvist. Had at 5ov, boom or bust, huge shot, wanted him but glad Hughes fell.
Dobson. Had at 10ov, wil be a solid number 3/4
Bouchard, I think, is a Cam Barker bust.
- New world order

Fair enough. You still feel that way?

I think im higher on Boqvist but otherwise the same, I still like Bouchard and have concerns about Hughes size and lack of shot. Dobson still seems vanilla to me.

Speaking of redrafts, I'm curious where people rank Boqvist, Bouchard, Dobson after +1 season.

I dont think many had any of those guys before Hughes. I liked Bouchard and I'm pretty sure Pres had Boqvist ahead of him but cant remember anyone else.

Hughes: 32 Games 5G 28A -2 NCAA
Boqvist: 52 Games 20G 39A +15 OHL
Bouchard: 7 Games 1 G -5 NHL
43 Games 13 G 36A +30 OHL
Dobson: 44 Games 15G 35A +8 QMJHL
- belcherbd

1 + 2) = Hughes/Dobson: basically even, wanted 1 of them unless Zadina fell)


3+4) Boqvist/Bouchard: I was down on both, I don’t believe I had either in my overall top 10

You had Dobson and Bouchard ahead of Hughes or Boqvist?

Buf got Eichel, Risto and Reinhardt.
Avs got MacKinnon, Rantanen, Jost
- belcherbd

Buff also got Dahlin Mittlestadt and Nylander as well
Colorado got Landeskog and Makar.

Uhmm.... I don't think Hughes would go 2 in a redraft maybe 3, tchunk is pretty dynamite and I'd rather him then Hughes. Elias might go 1 but nico is one hell of a player.
- New world order

Think you guys are missing the point. We got lucky. The players we picked would go higher in a redraft. That is luck

I see the G-A-S interest level on Lockwood is at 0

You had Dobson and Bouchard ahead of Hughes or Boqvist?

Buf got Eichel, Risto and Reinhardt.
Avs got MacKinnon, Rantanen, Jost
- belcherbd

Both those teams include 1 or 2ov picks... not fair to compare the Canucks...

Fair enough. You still feel that way?

I think im higher on Boqvist but otherwise the same, I still like Bouchard and have concerns about Hughes size and lack of shot. Dobson still seems vanilla to me.
- belcherbd

Dobson looks like a hamhuis now. He'll be solid but isn't great at anything.
I still have concerns about Bouchard being able to skate.
Still like Hughes and boqvist best

1 + 2) = Hughes/Dobson: basically even, wanted 1 of them unless Zadina fell)


3+4) Boqvist/Bouchard: I was down on both, I don’t believe I had either in my overall top 10
- Nucker101

Do you still feel that way?

Buff also got Dahlin Mittlestadt and Nylander as well
Colorado got Landeskog and Makar.
- Reubenkincade

Okay, but my ask was for other teams who had picked top 10, at least 4 out of 5 years and not gotten at least 2 good players.

OEL and Turris (debatable how well he compares to Boeser) is the best example so far.

Hopefully this summer.
- Reubenkincade

Both those teams include 1 or 2ov picks... not fair to compare the Canucks...
- New world order

Hard to find comparables with a more narrow scope, but you're welcome to find a more fair comparison.

Okay, but my ask was for other teams who had picked top 10, at least 4 out of 5 years and not gotten at least 2 good players.

OEL and Turris (debatable how well he compares to Boeser) is the best example so far.
- belcherbd

Totally forgot about the, at least 2 good players part, lol

Dobson looks like a hamhuis now. He'll be solid but isn't great at anything.
I still have concerns about Bouchard being able to skate.
Still like Hughes and boqvist best
- New world order

Funny, we got that exact same position from Pres4U...hmmm something suspicious here.

I see the G-A-S interest level on Lockwood is at 0
- VANTEL

Personally, I am more interested in Canucks signing #6 & 8 on Pronmans chl/euro and NCAA free-agent list
Kaski and Brazzeau.
One is a right shot defenseman from Finland and another is a high scoring winger from the CHL.

Hard to find comparables with a more narrow scope, but you're welcome to find a more fair comparison.
- belcherbd

Find a team with 4 out of 5 picks between 5 and 10 who have more then 2 that have shown to be all star caliber.

There are no comparable teams! The Canucks are that great!

Funny, we got that exact same position from Pres4U...hmmm something suspicious here.
- Reubenkincade

Still hate boqvist like he stole your milk money?

Do you still feel that way?
- New world order

I haven’t really watched the other 3 play this year so I guess so