Very doubtful. Schenn never even put up 30 in any minor league.

He really has no offensive skill while Myers has a ton of it.
- gretzky

and yet myers could never outscore schenn in the same season. He had to stick around and play as a 19 year old to do that.

not that I think Schenn will put up 40. 30 to 35 he will probably top out at. I think. Which isnt too bad. Because anyone who watched him play over the last few years saw that hes developed a lot of patience with the puck and skates pretty well. Only an idiot wouldnt see that.

Did you know oscar klefbom has never scored more than 2 points in any league? Thats because hes actually an offensive liability. If his team is about to score he will break up the play.

and yet myers could never outscore schenn in the same season. He had to stick around and play as a 19 year old to do that.

not that I think Schenn will put up 40. 30 to 35 he will probably top out at. I think. Which isnt too bad. Because anyone who watched him play over the last few years saw that hes developed a lot of patience with the puck and skates pretty well. Only an idiot wouldnt see that.

Did you know oscar klefbom has never scored more than 2 points in any league? Thats because hes actually an offensive liability. If his team is about to score he will break up the play.
- prock

30 points would be what i expect out of schenn

Myers is capable of putting up 50+ points consitently throughout his career while being as good as schenn defensively.

30 points would be what i expect out of schenn

Myers is capable of putting up 50+ points consitently throughout his career while being as good as schenn defensively.
- sens rock

well he isnt as good defensively though. Not at this point. I have my doubts ever. I'm not saying Schenn is "miles better" as others have said. But definitely better.

well he isnt as good defensively though. Not at this point. I have my doubts ever. I'm not saying Schenn is "miles better" as others have said. But definitely better.
- prock

well schenn being an defensive defenseman is obviously more effective defensively. but i think myers is equal in positioning and reading the play. and his reach is far and above schenn. his defensive shortcomings come from him being involved offensively not from being bad in his own end.

well schenn being an defensive defenseman is obviously more effective defensively. but i think myers is equal in positioning and reading the play. and his reach is far and above schenn. his defensive shortcomings come from him being involved offensively not from being bad in his own end.
- sens rock

I think youre wrong.

well schenn being an defensive defenseman is obviously more effective defensively. but i think myers is equal in positioning and reading the play. and his reach is far and above schenn. his defensive shortcomings come from him being involved offensively not from being bad in his own end.
- sens rock

not true...

and yet myers could never outscore schenn in the same season. He had to stick around and play as a 19 year old to do that.

not that I think Schenn will put up 40. 30 to 35 he will probably top out at. I think. Which isnt too bad. Because anyone who watched him play over the last few years saw that hes developed a lot of patience with the puck and skates pretty well. Only an idiot wouldnt see that.

Did you know oscar klefbom has never scored more than 2 points in any league? Thats because hes actually an offensive liability. If his team is about to score he will break up the play.
- prock

making stuff up now? that's not true at all.

Schenn is on a whole different level when it comes to punishing people physically for daring to skate near him though. He's also a better shot blocker. They are probably on a similar level in terms of reading plays and being in position but Schenn gets the edge because of what I mentioned above. Myers is still the better overall dman but he isn't as good defensively.

Luke Schenn NHL career +/-= -17
Tyler Myers NHL career +/-= +13

Case closed leafers.

Luke Schenn NHL career +/-= -17
Tyler Myers NHL career +/-= +13

Case closed leafers.
- gretzky

Meaningless....


Check blocked shots and hits. Schenn is lightyears ahead.

Luke Schenn NHL career +/-= -17
Tyler Myers NHL career +/-= +13

Case closed leafers.
- gretzky

Gretzky was the greatest defensive forward ever.

1984-85 +98

Meaningless....


Check blocked shots and hits. Schenn is lightyears ahead.
- burn

Myers is lightyears ahead in +/- and points. Meaningless as well?

Sorry Leaf fans I know you don't want to hear it but Schenn=Regher 2.0 and Myers=Chara 2.0 in the future.

Chara 2.0.>>Regher 2.0

Sorry Leaf fans I know you don't want to hear it but Schenn=Regher 2.0 and Myers=Chara 2.0 in the future.

Chara 2.0.>>Regher 2.0
- gretzky

Zzzzz

Zzzzz
- Schenn-Sational!

It's true. One dimensional checking defensemen are less highly regarded than monster sized agile puck movers who can play excellent defensively as well as rack up 50+ points.

Just a fact

Anyone who isn't a Leaf fan would trade Schenn for Myers in a heartbeat.

Sorry Leaf fans I know you don't want to hear it but Schenn=Regher 2.0 and Myers=Chara 2.0 in the future.

Chara 2.0.>>Regher 2.0
- gretzky

It could turn out like that but Myers will have to start playing a lot more physical for that to be true. He'll probably end up better than Schenn but basically saying he'll be a Chara clone just because he's tall is silly.

It's true. One dimensional checking defensemen are less highly regarded than monster sized agile puck movers who can play excellent defensively as well as rack up 50+ points.

Just a fact

Anyone who isn't a Leaf fan would trade Schenn for Myers in a heartbeat.
- gretzky

Most Leafs fans would too.

It's true. One dimensional checking defensemen are less highly regarded than monster sized agile puck movers who can play excellent defensively as well as rack up 50+ points.

Just a fact

Anyone who isn't a Leaf fan would trade Schenn for Myers in a heartbeat.
- gretzky

Only one of those 2 can do that,and it ain't myers.

Luke Schenn NHL career +/-= -17
Tyler Myers NHL career +/-= +13

Case closed leafers.
- gretzky

campbell is lightyears ahead of lidstrom with this reasoning

campbell is lightyears ahead of lidstrom with this reasoning
- nightmare3020

But Lidstrom is still a +51 in his last 3 seasons (same as Campbell actually)

Schenn is -17.

HUGE difference.

Mike Green is a +69 over the last three seasons. He must be amazing defensively.

But Lidstrom is still a +51 in his last 3 seasons (same as Campbell actually)

Schenn is -17.

HUGE difference.
- gretzky

look, youre making stupid comments again. You should just stop.

It's true. One dimensional checking defensemen are less highly regarded than monster sized agile puck movers who can play excellent defensively as well as rack up 50+ points.

Just a fact

Anyone who isn't a Leaf fan would trade Schenn for Myers in a heartbeat.
- gretzky

We're talking about Schenn and Myers here. You've described neither.

Mike Green is a +69 over the last three seasons. He must be amazing defensively.
- daeth

Phillips is the worst defensive player in the league.

Schenn actually added more weight this summer. Guys a tank.
- Schenn-Sational!

But Myers added more weight to his bank account.

The market has spoken.