Wanna blog? Start your own hockey blog with My HockeyBuzz. Register for free today!
 
Forums :: Blog World :: Zach Jarom: Putting out the Flames and Game Day: Hawks vs McDavids..I mean Oilers
Author Message
wiz1901
Chicago Blackhawks
Location: DraftSite com, IL
Joined: 05.14.2008

Jan 30 @ 11:12 AM ET
Boqvist had concussion issue’s while playing in London.
- LAHawk



...and three in Sweden prior to his selection.

I wanna revisit that 2018 draft again.

A few here had mentioned they tagged the redhead Noah Dobson as a possible "safe" selection for the Hawks; I remember also that others desired forward Oliver Wahlstrom.

I spend far too much of my time trying to attempt to get in the heads of the NHL scouting staffs long range and why they do what they do.

I do not expect I am ever close to understanding, but I do know the past drafts and players influence the future ideas in selecting building blocks.

When you look at the 2018 Draft you see after the one guaranteed stud defender, Rasmus Dahlin teams starting after the forward barrage, Quinn Hughes, Adam Boqvist and Evan Bouchard off the board 7, 8, and 10.

Right now as far as I am concerned these three are busts as all around NHLers at this point. I can praise their skating, and offensive abilities, but they all are subpar defenders, and would want any playing for me.
So why suddenly did they get high billing and chosen so quickly?

and not Dobson?

I think I will guess the fact that in the year after his selection in the year before 2017, Cale Makar had teams looking for rookie ofeenseman that were possible comparable.

To me, that has got to be it.

Everyone knew Dobson had "a good frame and will continue to grown into it and get bigger, and surely he will become less shy playing like a larger guy. Already better than most “Q” defenders at using his mobility, reach, stick, and to have his stick on the right side of the puck carrier. Deceptively fast and always willing to lug the biscuit up ice. Because he is bigger and his stride is so fluid, he catches you off guard with how fast he can accelerate and then surprises again when he executes at top speed. Jumps up from the blue line deep in to the attack zone and has the speed to get himself back up ice." (My player profile.)

But everyone knew he needed more time, was going to have to percolate in Quebec Jr.
and that he had to improve his "head" speed. And he wasn't really a Seabrook type. His game was fairly vanilla in so far as he lacked snarl or bite, and that also put some doubts out there.

Noah Dobson lasted until slot 12.

It had more to do with arrival immediacy and development than fact you had a very good chance to draft a bigger solid balanced all around defenseman.

To me, the biggest guffaw was the tabs reach at slot three to draft Jesperi Kotkaniemi.

If anyone in the Blackhawk organization knew they were passing on a Brady Tkachuk, we should have offered them BOTH of our first rounders and moved up to three.
This was no hindsight ida, as I clamored about it then.

I am pretty sure the Habs could have gotten Jesperi Kotkaniemi with pick eight.
Chunk
Chicago Blackhawks
Location: Why did I move back here again?, IL
Joined: 11.06.2015

Jan 30 @ 12:44 PM ET
Aren't they though, you rarely see a dman drafted and play the very first year in the league, it occasionally happens at 19, but 20 seems to be a very popular number. Considering how frequent concussions are in the NHL, i do think young players who are thinking the game at the NHL level are more prone to getting lit up and in the NHL it happens in a split second. I believe Dach, Boqvist both suffered concussions their rookie year.

Seabrook was 20
Keith was 22
Didn't Montreal rookie suffer one from us this year?

- BetweenTheDots


How many have to do it before they stop being considered exceptions vs just a minority? For the guys that flourished, would keeping them down for another year make them any better prepared? What did their teams see that made them finally say "OK, he's good enough to be up here"? If the Hawks see that same thing in KK, why send him down? I don't see the benefit.

Last three drafts (From 2021) D-men that played within 1 season of getting drafted.

Owen Power
Brandt Clarke (only 9 games)
JJ Moser
Jamie Drysdale
Braden Schneider
Justin Barron (Split time)
I could technically throw I. Phillips in here, but I won't
Tobias Bjornfort
Zac Jones

and then a smattering of guys with 15-30 games.

Sure, it's not a ton, but there are plenty. As long as they player shows they have the tools to play in the NHL, what are the risks that they wouldn't have playing a lower level?


Page: Previous  1, 2, 3, 4, 5