He is vastly underappreciated for how good he was during those two years because defense was treated like an optional skate
- Stripes77

You’ll NEVER convince him that the US goalie with the most career wins all-time was anything other than average
He just doesn’t like him

Maybe Miller wouldn’t take a pic with him back in the day??? 😂😂😂

Just trying to be like you
What was it u kept calling me the other day?
Was it “beady lite” or something like that?

Gotta LOVE your HYPOCRISY
- jdfitz77

you literally spend 6 months attacking him for how he acts, and them become a poorer version of weak takes


you say you never bring up politics, then bring trump up out of right field


you talk down on others in post, like my franco harris post, and then when the valid respond comes out, crickets


you make a freaking huge racist statement, and spend 72 hours denying it instead of saying you made a mistake


if you want to attack those on a regular basis, at some point enough is enough and you are going to get called out on every stupid thing you type


just like for a month, cried how the bills did nothing to fix the pass rush in the offseason

myself and others said wait til the draft, well guess what they addressed it



everyone is on edge lately, between covid and the sabres sucking, but constantly attacking others puts the big bull's eye right on your ass



I hope for this site's sake you take this with at least a grain of salt


but I expect an insult like you have been doing non stop to half the board over the last few months

you literally spend 6 months attacking him for how he acts, and them become a poorer version of weak takes


you say you never bring up politics, then bring trump up out of right field


you talk down on others in post, like my franco harris post, and then when the valid respond comes out, crickets


you make a freaking huge racist statement, and spend 72 hours denying it instead of saying you made a mistake


if you want to attack those on a regular basis, at some point enough is enough and you are going to get called out on every stupid thing you type


just like for a month, cried how the bills did nothing to fix the pass rush in the offseason

myself and others said wait til the draft, well guess what they addressed it



everyone is on edge lately, between covid and the sabres sucking, but constantly attacking others puts the big bull's eye right on your ass



I hope for this site's sake you take this with at least a grain of salt


but I expect an insult like you have been doing non stop to half the board over the last few months
- homiedclown

You’ll NEVER convince him that the US goalie with the most career wins all-time was anything other than average
He just doesn’t like him

Maybe Miller wouldn’t take a pic with him back in the day??? 😂😂😂
- jdfitz77

being a 15th rank goalie for most of your seasons and having longevity in your career does not make you a hall of famer

would you consider frederik anderson a hall of famer if he plays like this for another 6 years


miller 2.64 gaa .914 save percentage
anderson 2.64 gaa .915 save percentage


he has a great year and was average the rest of his career

He is vastly underappreciated for how good he was during those two years because defense was treated like an optional skate
- Stripes77

was he that much better then biron those seasons?

being a 15th rank goalie for most of your seasons and having longevity in your career does not make you a hall of famer

would you consider frederik anderson a hall of famer if he plays like this for another 6 years


miller 2.64 gaa .914 save percentage
anderson 2.64 gaa .915 save percentage


he has a great year and was average the rest of his career
- homiedclown

You’re never gonna change your mind about him,
so why should i argue with you about it?

You’re just being Sbroads with Risto here

was he that much better then biron those seasons?
- homiedclown

Lindy Ruff thought so based on games played,
& who he always started in the playoffs

I will throw some goalie out there in his era


you tell me where he ranks


maf
luongo
rinne
price
quick
rask
lundqvist



I mean barasso, vanbiesbrouck, moog, ozzy and vernon are not in hall of fame, with similar numbers and many have much more hardware



usa hall of fame yes, hockey hall of fame probably not
- homiedclown

You're missing the point hes American if he was Canadian he most likely be an after thought

You're missing the point hes American if he was Canadian he most likely be an after thought
- gerbe75pts

that means nothing

You’re never gonna change your mind about him,
so why should i argue with you about it?

You’re just being Sbroads with Risto here
- jdfitz77

miller 2.64 gaa .914 save percentage
anderson 2.64 gaa .915 save percentage


is anderson hall of famer?

miller 2.64 gaa .914 save percentage
anderson 2.64 gaa .915 save percentage


is anderson hall of famer?
- homiedclown

No, Andersen is not

BUT AGAIN....
You’re never gonna change your mind about Miller,
so why should i argue with you about it?

You're missing the point hes American if he was Canadian he most likely be an after thought
- gerbe75pts

Miller is first ballot Hall of Good

Not HOF. I don't want to start the Osgood debate again but if he gets in then I'll lobby for Miller to get it in. I don't think either should though

No, Andersen is not

BUT AGAIN....
You’re never gonna change your mind about Miller,
so why should i argue with you about it?
- jdfitz77

he's average stat wise, glimpses of greatness and 1 hell of a season

ask any non sabres fans

nothing wrong

he had a nice career, played well, paid well
never had much competition behind him once biron got moved


I watched edwards and sauve and they would consistently be in the top third of goalie rankings

one year edwards got the bulk of the games, next year sauve did

sauve had back to back shutouts in the playoffs one year


if your under 40, the only decent goalies you have seen for the sabres was hasek, miller and to a lesser extent biron


I saw edwards, sauve, barasso, puppa and the only thing miller had over them was number of games played

on the ice pull a name out of the hat because other then barasso's rookie year or miller's vezina year

it's all the same

Miller is first ballot Hall of Good

Not HOF. I don't want to start the Osgood debate again but if he gets in then I'll lobby for Miller to get it in. I don't think either should though
- jcragcrumple

I don’t really care either way....
But there’s other guys in the HOF who have gotten in based off “career numbers” bc they played well for a long time

I don’t really care either way....
But there’s other guys in the HOF who have gotten in based off “career numbers” bc they played well for a long time
- jdfitz77

Marleau is going to be the poster boy for that. He's Sam Reinhart if Sam Reinhart played for 400 years

I don’t really care either way....
But there’s other guys in the HOF who have gotten in based off “career numbers” bc they played well for a long time
- jdfitz77

barasso, vanbiesbrouck, moog, ozzy and vernon are not in hall of fame, with similar numbers and many have much more hardware

he's average stat wise, glimpses of greatness and 1 hell of a season

ask any non sabres fans

nothing wrong

he had a nice career, played well
never had much competition behind him once biron got moved


I watched edwards and sauve and they would consistently be in the top third of goalie rankings

one year edwards got the bulk of the games, next year sauve did

sauve had back to back shutouts in the playoffs one year


if your under 40, the only decent goalies you have seen for the sabres was hasek, miller and to a lesser extent biron


I saw edwards, sauve, barasso, puppa and the only thing miller had over them was number of games played

on the ice pull a name out of the hat because other then barasso's rookie year or miller's vezina year

it's all the same
- homiedclown

How are u not getting that i don’t care about this debate???

You don’t like Miller.... FINE
I’m not here making an argument that he should or shouldn’t be in the HOF

And I’m not wasting my time debating it with you
The end

I don’t really care either way....
But there’s other guys in the HOF who have gotten in based off “career numbers” bc they played well for a long time
- jdfitz77

how many of these is miller better then?


maf
luongo
rinne
price
quick
rask
lundqvist

How are u not getting that i don’t care about this debate???

You don’t like Miller.... FINE
I’m not here making an argument that he should or shouldn’t be in the HOF

And I’m not wasting my time debating it with you
The end
- jdfitz77

typical conversation with you

unable to have one


just ignore me if you cant even have a conversation

I don’t really care either way....
But there’s other guys in the HOF who have gotten in based off “career numbers” bc they played well for a long time
- jdfitz77

name 1 goalie

just 1

how many of these is miller better then?


maf
luongo
rinne
price
quick
rask
lundqvist
- homiedclown

I'd put him ahead of those two and post-pad-size reduction Lundqvist.

Price was always overrated by the Canadian media imo and I never cared for MAF.

barasso, vanbiesbrouck, moog, ozzy and vernon are not in hall of fame, with similar numbers and many have much more hardware
- homiedclown

Why are you so intent on arguing this with me?

I'd put him ahead of those two and post-pad-size reduction Lundqvist.

Price was always overrated by the Canadian media imo and I never cared for MAF.
- jcragcrumple

fair enough

I doubt if you add miller to that list half get in the hall of fame, which it would take for miller to get a shot

typical conversation with you

unable to have one


just ignore me if you cant even have a conversation
- homiedclown

Just bc u wanna argue doesn’t mean I’m obliged to do so also
Sorry if u can’t handle that

Why are you so intent on arguing this with me?
- jdfitz77

don't mention my name in posts with miller, if you don't want to have the conversation

you threw it out 4 times


back it up or for the site STFU