So one single series is all it takes to condemn a players entire career in Ottawa? The entire team was poop in that series.....FFS, Chris Philips scores the cup clinching goal on his own net.
Spezza was a great player for Ottawa, and NOBODY will ever convince me otherwise.
- sensarmy_11
Actually, yes - you only get so many chances to win a championship, and they don't give out awards for playing well against non-playoff teams in January. Some players elevate their games when they get close to the Stanley Cup, some don't. If you want to see what that looks like, Alfredsson absolutely did in 2007, and Karlsson absolutely did in 2016. In fact, your point that the entire team was crap in the 2007 Stanley Cup Finals is nonsense... they lost by 1 goal in 3 of those games, and held leads in more than 1/2 of the games. What would have been nice is some G-D production from their supposed star talent in Spezza/Heatley. Alfredsson/Fisher outscored Spezza/Heatley 6:1 in that series... in fact Spezza/Heatley had fewer points than Kelly/Schaefer.
Spezza was an immensely talented player, but had serious defensive issues, a relatively occasional work ethic, wasn't able to play at his best when it mattered, and had no business whatsoever wearing a "C". That falls short of my definition of great, and I would hope that they do better with their #3/5 picks in the coming draft.