Imagine drafting a guy who was mediocre at best but big and he develeoped to be mediocre at best and big. Who could have projected that?
- Takemedrunkimhome

probably a somewhat competent scouting department

Got me thinking...Vinny HoF? Yay or nay. For what I'd like the Hall to be it's nay, for the Kevin Lowe gets in Hall it's a yay by a landslide
- Takemedrunkimhome

Nay for me. Aside from 2006 he had a pretty regular career.

Damphouse should get in before Lecavalier!

#thebetterVinnie
- bluewaffle

Eras, comparison to peers and all that

A product of his environment, only got in because of the company he kept
- bluewaffle

it was fun to see the old boys club apologists jump through hoops to prove he's a hall of famer.

Nay for me. Aside from 2006 he had a pretty regular career.
- AdamFrench

07/08 was solid too. More than regular career, not what I think the Hall should be...but Kevin Lowe, amongst many, makes me think yay

07/08 was solid too. More than regular career, not what I think the Hall should be...but Kevin Lowe, amongst many, makes me think yay
- Takemedrunkimhome

On the radio, Pierre McGuire let slip a little bit the criteria he goes for and "winning" showed up a lot. He included juniors/WJC's/international tournaments etc. so you never know.

On the radio, Pierre McGuire let slip a little bit the criteria he goes for and "winning" showed up a lot. He included juniors/WJC's/international tournaments etc. so you never know.
- AdamFrench

well, it's the hockey hof, not the nhl hof. no?

well, it's the hockey hof, not the nhl hof. no?
- fidopro

The point being "winning." Poor Kopitar, he never even sniffed winning with Slovenia.

Eras, comparison to peers and all that
- Takemedrunkimhome

Close enough in generation... they were in the league at the same time for 5 seasons.... regardless, my point still holds true


Damphousse > Lecavalier

it was fun to see the old boys club apologists jump through hoops to prove he's a hall of famer.
- mr.peanut

It was.... they should just put Billy Carroll in the hall, get it over with

It was.... they should just put Billy Carroll in the hall, get it over with
- bluewaffle

Like i said the day of... Nick Kronwall now has a hof worthy career

How about Pierre Turgeon?

1327 points in 1294 games played

Like i said they day of... Nick Kronwall now has a hof worthy career
- mr.peanut

He should get in just so we can see a montage of him lighting people up.

How about Pierre Turgeon?

1327 points in 1294 games played
- stinger67

No winning

Like i said the day of... Nick Kronwall now has a hof worthy career
- mr.peanut

That's a good example for sure Nut 👍

He should get in just so we can see a montage of him lighting people up.
- AdamFrench

His name became a verb, that poop matters

How about Pierre Turgeon?

1327 points in 1294 games played
- stinger67

Unless he changed his name to Vincent Turgeon, he doesn't belong in this conversation!!

Besides, everyone knows Sylvain was the better Turgeon

How about Pierre Turgeon?

1327 points in 1294 games played
- stinger67

But was he gretzky's caddy?

Ciccarelli waited a long time because of where he scored most of his goals

But was he gretzky's caddy?

Ciccarelli waited a long time because of where he scored most of his goals
- mr.peanut

Loved that guy!!

Unless he changed his name to Vincent Turgeon, he doesn't belong in this conversation!!

Besides, everyone knows Sylvain was the better Turgeon
- bluewaffle

Lefebvre?

Lefebvre?
- AdamFrench

Sylvain Lefebvre was the better Turgeon brother?

Sylvain Lefebvre was the better Turgeon brother?
- bluewaffle

- Pat1993

- Pat1993

Tom Cruise is my favorite Baldwin brother!

- kicksave856