Pretty much every Stanley Cup winner has had an above average goalie. Leafs d isn't perfect but if you do watch a lot of the shots come from non dangerous spots. Confidence in your goaltender is huge. Right now leaf goaltenders aren't capable of doing this for the team. Despite this Leafs are still winning games. I personally think you put a high end .910% goalie on this team and they'd look much more dominate.
- bmoney411
Binnington career: .917 SV% / 2019 Cup Playoffs: .914 SV%
Holtby career: .916 SV% / 2018 Cup Playoffs: .922 SV%
Fleury career: .913 SV% / 2017 Cup Playoffs: .924 SV%
Murray career: .914 SV% / 2016 Cup Playoffs: .923 SV%
Crawford career: .918 SV% / 2015 Cup Playoffs: .924 SV%
Quick career: .913 SV% / 2014 Cup Playoffs: .911 SV%
Andersen career: .916 SV% / 2019 Cup Playoffs: .922 SV%
Career Playoff SV%: .914 SV%
As we can see, all those numbers are within Andersen's range. Even at his average, he can get the job done if the team in front of him is good enough. Pretty sure the past 20 Cup winning goalies playoff SV% average is .913 SV%. So well within Andersen's range as well.
In the past 5 years, among the 6 goalies who have had a better regular season SV% than Andersen (Bishop, Lehner, Crawford, Vasilevskiy, Gibson and Rask) only one has a Cup as a starter overall so having a great goalie doesn't guarantee a Cup.
A lot of people look at SV% without realizing that a lot of Cup winners allow much fewer shots than the Leafs. Past 20 Cup winners averaged between 9th/10th in shots allowed. Leafs are 20th in shots allowed. The Red Wings and the Devils and even the Blackhawks were 1st in shots against per game some seasons. That's why Osgood and Niemi have Cups.
The Leafs having a goalie with a .910 SV% doesn't solve their problem. It only masks it. Andersen was .917 SV% last year and they still lost in the playoffs. Why? The team in front of him couldn't play playoff hockey. Having a goalie stand on his head every night is not the way this team should be expecting to win games or Cups.