To NYI: Marner

To Leafs: Dobson, Wahlstrom, 2 first round picks
- bruinzfan77

If the Islanders were going to give up what amounts to four first round picks I'm sure they'd just offer sheet him and pay the four first round picks and keep Dobson and Wahlstrom

boeser sucks
- BluesFan44isa_JOKE

Ya a guy that scored 30 sucks. Lol

Give your head a shake

- Alexzanki

well played

I can't wait for Ek to pick a winner from all these fantastic proposals.

It could be anybody.

Well, anybody who made a proposal in the first two pages, because lazy-assed Ek isn't going to read past the first two pages.

Top pairing defenceman coming back or GTFO.

Ya a guy that scored 30 sucks. Lol

Give your head a shake
- legendguy

Boeser doesn't suck.

But he doesn't address a need for the Leafs. If Marner gets traded it would have to be for a dman coming back. On that alone I would say no to the trade.

14 pages of complete stupidity
- .HOHO.

c'mon now... that's harsh...

some (very few) were border line okay

c'mon now... that's harsh...

some (very few) were border line okay


- BorjeFan4Ever

Someone must have built a wall at that border

No.


This just proves you have an incompetent GM


-Matthews deal at ONLY 5 years

-Buckled to Kneelander's demands

-No long term plan on D

-Zero help for Red Light Freddy


and now soiling the relationship with Marner



As a division rival it's quite enthusing to watch
- Komisaurus Rex

Nylander was asking for 8.5 and Dubas got him down to 6.9, so no he didn’t buckle.

Matthews is the best 5 on 5 goal scorer in the NHL and got paid accordingly.

Defense looks to be good this year but I agree not great next year maybe. There are some youngsters coming though

Leafs were 4th in goal differential last year so Freddy obviously must’ve had a pretty good year

This said I really do like to hear what jealous fans of other teams like to say though

What is this?
- walshyleafsfan

Proof that people who don't know the Leafs salary CAP/prospect situation, shouldn't be commenting on them.

Whoever gets the best player wins the trade, you can't offer mountains of garbage for an elite player. Unless it's a top pairing Dman age 24 or under, it's a non-starter.

Whoever gets the best player wins the trade, you can't offer mountains of garbage for an elite player. Unless it's a top pairing Dman age 24 or under, it's a non-starter.
- BestRapperAlive

I would trade Nylander for a pile of hot garbage and sign marner

If the Islanders were going to give up what amounts to four first round picks I'm sure they'd just offer sheet him and pay the four first round picks and keep Dobson and Wahlstrom
- eichiefs9

This removes the risk of the Leafs matching is all.

You are all fired as general managers of your respective teams.

Ya a guy that scored 30 sucks. Lol

Give your head a shake
- legendguy

get back to me in january.

Boeser doesn't suck.

But he doesn't address a need for the Leafs. If Marner gets traded it would have to be for a dman coming back. On that alone I would say no to the trade.
- Kinger34

If they trade Marner they need a forward coming back. I suggested Tanev also coming back. Despite being injured he played fantastically with Reilly and would be a better partner than Ceci