Guentzel, rust and a 1st for marner

not many options to choose from here on the Rangers in terms of offsetting the cap situation so maybe something like...

To Toronto:
Kreider, Nam, Anderson, 1 of Hajek/Rykov/Reunanen and maybeeee a 2nd or 3rd rd pick

To NY:
Marner, 5th rd pick

Yeah but Bergevin is too busy deciding if he should give Domi for Laine
- Alexzanki

Bergy is still in negotiation with Chevy to see if they can make a deal work without involving Domi. It's not surprising their focal point is Max.

Marner for Hall and Vatanen

Hyman JT Hall
AJ Matthews Nylander
Moore Kerfoot Kapanen
Spezza &whoever

Rielly Vatanen
Muzzin Barrie
Dermott Ceci
- juice22

I like the idea Marner is worth more than Hall just b/c he is younger. Typical Leafs fan... Hall for marner + 1st makes a lot more sense. He'd fit well in our line up based on the need for him to play with a top center. Hall would elevate your team, Marner still has a fews years before he reaches taylors skill level, if ever. He'd line up well with our youth tho, so I'd do it if we got a prospect on top...

I like the idea Marner is worth more than Hall just b/c he is younger. Typical Leafs fan... Hall for marner + 1st makes a lot more sense. He'd fit well in our line up based on the need for him to play with a top center. Hall would elevate your team, Marner still has a fews years before he reaches taylors skill level, if ever. He'd line up well with our youth tho, so I'd do it if we got a prospect on top...
- ShoresideDevil

I like the idea Marner is worth more than Hall just b/c he is younger. Typical Leafs fan... Hall for marner + 1st makes a lot more sense. He'd fit well in our line up based on the need for him to play with a top center. Hall would elevate your team, Marner still has a fews years before he reaches taylors skill level, if ever. He'd line up well with our youth tho, so I'd do it if we got a prospect on top...
- ShoresideDevil

I like the idea Marner is worth more than Hall just b/c he is younger. Typical Leafs fan... Hall for marner + 1st makes a lot more sense. He'd fit well in our line up based on the need for him to play with a top center. Hall would elevate your team, Marner still has a fews years before he reaches taylors skill level, if ever. He'd line up well with our youth tho, so I'd do it if we got a prospect on top...
- ShoresideDevil

the risk reward of trading a 21-year old RFA for a 27-year UFA are too out of balance.

it's too far off to work out a value that both teams would be happy with.

hall will go for a good package of quantity prospects/picks if he is traded as a deadline sell-off.

similar to karlsson, mcdonagh, stone, duchene etc.

Isles send Leddy, Beauvillier, Holmstrom (2019 1st pick) and Wilde.

Toronto gets another Top 4 defender, a 20-goal scorer and two top prospects. Isles get Barzal's LW'er for life

I like the idea Marner is worth more than Hall just b/c he is younger. Typical Leafs fan... Hall for marner + 1st makes a lot more sense. He'd fit well in our line up based on the need for him to play with a top center. Hall would elevate your team, Marner still has a fews years before he reaches taylors skill level, if ever. He'd line up well with our youth tho, so I'd do it if we got a prospect on top...
- ShoresideDevil

I like the idea Marner is worth more than Hall just b/c he is younger. Typical Leafs fan... Hall for marner + 1st makes a lot more sense. He'd fit well in our line up based on the need for him to play with a top center. Hall would elevate your team, Marner still has a fews years before he reaches taylors skill level, if ever. He'd line up well with our youth tho, so I'd do it if we got a prospect on top...
- ShoresideDevil

It's not just because hes younger, its because he could end up being better (if he isnt already) had a 90pt season at 21, Hall was 26 when he did it. Hall is also a UFA, like I said in a different reply if you get him to sign an extension before coming over a prospect would be included also, maybe liljegren?

There's only one answer here.

Save your offer, the leafs aren't interested in trading the player.

Okay, two answers.

Ek is an idiot.

There's only one answer here.

Save your offer, the leafs aren't interested in trading the player.

Okay, two answers.

Ek is an idiot. trolling.
- joel878

fixed

It's not just because hes younger, its because he could end up being better (if he isnt already) had a 90pt season at 21, Hall was 26 when he did it. Hall is also a UFA, like I said in a different reply if you get him to sign an extension before coming over a prospect would be included also, maybe liljegren?
- juice22

hall will be wanting $13M/year.

if both were signed, it seems like a weber for subban deal.

devils would really have to kick something given hall's age and injury history and clear win long-term win on a 1 for 1.

hall will be wanting $13M/year.

if both were signed, it seems like a weber for subban deal.

devils would really have to kick something given hall's age and injury history and clear win long-term win on a 1 for 1.
- Tumbleweed

It wasnt a 1 for 1. Re read the post it was hall and vatanen for Marner. And hall isnt getting 13 per with any team

Ghost, tk, 1st, 2nd

Marchand AND Chara.

Book the parade!

It wasnt a 1 for 1. Re read the post it was hall and vatanen for Marner. And hall isnt getting 13 per with any team
- juice22

It could be Hall and Vats and maybe some cap help as NJ could retain salary.
It's a complicated scenario but not the craziest framework.

It wasnt a 1 for 1. Re read the post it was hall and vatanen for Marner. And hall isnt getting 13 per with any team
- juice22

vatanen is a contract dump

It wasnt a 1 for 1. Re read the post it was hall and vatanen for Marner. And hall isnt getting 13 per with any team
- juice22

1.5M more than panarin for a hart trophy winner? unpossible.

It wasnt a 1 for 1. Re read the post it was hall and vatanen for Marner. And hall isnt getting 13 per with any team
- juice22

Counting on Mitch to sign for seven years at $10.25 mill: (if not, no deal)

Laine, Perreault, prospects David Gustafsson and Eric Comrie and a 2nd:

for Mitch and prospect Rasmus Sandin

The time has come where this has to at least be discussed
- Eklund

Dubas, literally yesterday- "Trading Mitch isn't a path we've ever even considered."

can you throw in a cheesesteak? wit provolone.
- Tumbleweed

:::sigh:::

"wit" means "with fried onions". If you just wanted provolone, you'd just say provolone. If you wanted provolone with fried onions you'd say "provolone wit". "wit provolone" would certainly get you tagged as a tourist.

White Batterson Lajoie

For

Marner Sandin 2nd

Wow, these trade offers are gold.

As in real bad.
- Fakepartofme

I think my favourite part about all of them is that not only are the trades really bad, most think they'd get away with adding only a 2nd round pick and not a 1st.

Mayfield, Leddy, Beau, JHS, 2020 1st, 2021 2nd

For

Marner