Look, I'm about as big of a Shea Weber fan as they come, but one of the 6 best defensemen in Habs' history? Maybe if he'd spent his entire career there, then yeah, and same for Subban. No way should they be above Markov, Chelios, Desjardins, and maybe ever Brisebois. - jmatchett383
I take Weber over Desjardins all day long. Desjardins doesn't make the top 6...and he didn't play his whole career there either..or Chelios.
I take Weber over Desjardins all day long. Desjardins doesn't make the top 6...and he didn't play his whole career there either..or Chelios. - Pie
No, but Desjardins and Chelios were both part of Cup-winning team, and Desjardins has some huge goals in the Finals.
If I'm given 25-year-old Weber over 25-year-old Desjardins, yeah, I'll take Weber. But if I look at their careers based solely on their Montreal days to date, I think those 2 were better than Weber has been, again, to date.
No, but Desjardins and Chelios were both part of Cup-winning team, and Desjardins has some huge goals in the Finals.
If I'm given 25-year-old Weber over 25-year-old Desjardins, yeah, I'll take Weber. But if I look at their careers based solely on their Montreal days to date, I think those 2 were better than Weber has been, again, to date. - jmatchett383
Get the (frank) out of here ok. (frank)ing useless. If I'm given 25 yr old blah blah blah (frank) get out
Location: The Slovakian Jagr, QC Joined: 02.25.2007
Apr 12 @ 9:59 AM ET
No, but Desjardins and Chelios were both part of Cup-winning team, and Desjardins has some huge goals in the Finals.
If I'm given 25-year-old Weber over 25-year-old Desjardins, yeah, I'll take Weber. But if I look at their careers based solely on their Montreal days to date, I think those 2 were better than Weber has been, again, to date. - jmatchett383
