do you prefer the left or the right?
- homiedclown

Drums or flats?

do you prefer the left or the right?
- homiedclown

I really have no say in which direction my cock hangs.

This I have to think about more but I tend to agree with. I think Matthews fills the net better then jack but Jack is a more complete player.. But Man Matthew can score some goals...
- hehateme

jack is a morph of matthews and mcdavid IMO


mattews is by far the best goal scorer
mcdavid has the best vision and speed


eichel is probably the second best skater, shooter and has the second best ice vision of the 3


I think jack has grown more this season, the others may have peaked already in their game



it's splitting hairs when ranking the 3 and today I know how I would rank them

of course that could change and the jack I see this year, has shrunk the gap quite a bit



if the sabres make the playoffs and advance, I would probably change the ranking in my head next season, as I am an open minded person

I never understood chicken and waffles
- homiedclown

I agree

Drums or flats?
- hehateme

drums


but I tell you what, my friend petie, can put a flat in his mouth and pull out the bone in under 5 seconds

This I have to think about more but I tend to agree with. I think Matthews fills the net better then jack but Jack is a more complete player.. But Man Matthew can score some goals...
- hehateme

Matthews will be in the same convo as Ovechkin when he finishes his career minus the physical game Ovi plays with. But I can tell you that I have never seen Matthews set anyone up like I saw Eichel set up Skinner twice on Sunday. I have seen Eichel score highlight reel goals like a matthews.

jack is a morph of matthews and mcdavid IMO


mattews is by far the best goal scorer
mcdavid has the best vision and speed


eichel is probably the second best skater, shooter and has the second best ice vision of the 3


I think jack has grown more this season the the others may have peaked already in their game



it's splitting hairs when ranking the 3 and today I know how I would rank them

of course that could change and the jack I see this year, has shrunk the gap quite a bit



if the sabres make the playoffs and advance, I would probably change the ranking in my head next season, as I am an open minded person
- homiedclown

... Wouldn't that make him second best by your own criteria?

I want in on this. I'll take one year of Olli over any number years of clink, clank, skunk, MathMcJesus, PastaMitch, JT, OT, PT, or any other T's for that matter. If it Larsson though, I'm gonna need two years of Olli.

... Wouldn't that make him second best by your own criteria?
- BareMetal

nope

nice try

I want in on this. I'll take one year of Olli over any number years of clink, clank, skunk, MathMcJesus, PastaMitch, JT, OT, PT, or any other T's for that matter. If it Larsson though, I'm gonna need two years of Olli.
- SDSabre

jack is a morph of matthews and mcdavid IMO


mattews is by far the best goal scorer
mcdavid has the best vision and speed


eichel is probably the second best skater, shooter and has the second best ice vision of the 3


I think jack has grown more this season, the others may have peaked already in their game






it's splitting hairs when ranking the 3 and today I know how I would rank them

of course that could change and the jack I see this year, has shrunk the gap quite a bit



if the sabres make the playoffs and advance, I would probably change the ranking in my head next season, as I am an open minded person
- homiedclown

I have no issues with that line of thinking at all.

I have nothing to add to this conversation.

I have nothing to add to this conversation.
- buffalofan19

Come on its easy, just start with Sam sucks and watch the magic happen......

I have no issues with that line of thinking at all.
- hehateme

Agreed. My one quick take on this: pretty sure jack will put up more than 2 points in a 7 game playoff series. Pretty sure.

Agreed. My one quick take on this: pretty sure jack will put up more than 2 points in a 7 game playoff series. Pretty sure.
- TheHank

Don't you put that bad juju on Jack...

I have nothing to add to this conversation.
- buffalofan19

I repeat:

4 points separate super hockey god McDavid from Jack "debatably better than Mitch Marner" Eichel

Canadian media bias is real

Come on its easy, just start with Sam sucks and watch the magic happen......
- hehateme

You had me at sam

Matthews missing half the season to this point and the Leafs have won more games in their Franchise history to this point.

Take Eichel of this years team for half of the games and we are 6 points out of a playoff spot.

after saying all of this

once matthews signs for 13 or so million per year

jack will be the best value of the 3 in a cap era


but of course that logic would also include a skunk having value right now

Matthews missing half the season to this point and the Leafs have won more games in their Franchise history to this point.

Take Eichel of this years team for half of the games and we are 6 points out of a playoff spot.
- Pegullaville

part of that is the leafs had JT fall into their lap


it scares me what Jack could become with a decent second line center


ror was brought here 3 years too early

after saying all of this

once matthews signs for 13 or so million per year

jack will be the best value of the 3 in a cap era


but of course that logic would also include a skunk having value right now
- homiedclown

If Jack plays like this the rest of the life of his contract, Oh hell yeah it will be the best value out of the three....

Matthews missing half the season to this point and the Leafs have won more games in their Franchise history to this point.

Take Eichel of this years team for half of the games and we are 6 points out of a playoff spot.
- Pegullaville

Probably more than that... we have one line... take jack away there is nobody filling in that spot.

part of that is the leafs had JT fall into their lap


it scares me what Jack could become with a decent second line center


ror was brought here 3 years too early
- homiedclown

I have lost my passion for this argument.

part of that is the leafs had JT fall into their lap


it scares me what Jack could become with a decent second line center


ror was brought here 3 years too early
- homiedclown

yes, YES YES!!

after saying all of this

once matthews signs for 13 or so million per year

jack will be the best value of the 3 in a cap era


but of course that logic would also include a skunk having value right now
- homiedclown

3.65M is overpayment

Reinhart should take league minimum and (frank)ing like it