No he's not. McD can't make average players that play on his line better like Crosby has done for several years with many different average players? The answer is NO as he needs Draisaitl or RNH on his line to pad his stats. If stats alone make a player the best then its MCD, but what has his team ever won and how are the Oilers doing this season?
- islansjet
From a production and electrifying skill + speed standpoint, it's now McDavid. I still think Crosby does quite a few things better but overall when you compare players it's usually on production/stats and sometimes individual awards, both of which McDavid excels over Crosby in now.
Having said all of that if the playoffs were starting tomorrow and I had to chose one of the players for my team, it would be Crosby.
If I had to chose one to build a franchise now and for the future I'd go with the guy 10 years younger.