Option A: Nylander + 2nd round pick 2019 for Skjei + Kreider

Option B: Nylander for McAvoy

Option C: Nylander + 1st 2019 for Provorov and 2nd 2019

Option D: Nylander + 2nd 2019 for Heiskanen + Carrick

Option E: Nylander + Sandin + Johnsson for Slavin + Svechnikov

get your votes in, gentlemen
- plantheparade

Nylander for McAvoy. Every single time.

The leafs issue wouldn't be such a problem if Marner wasn't thought to be 9 to 10 mill
player. Why is he over rated as far as his money. Dont even know if he is better than nylander.

The leafs issue wouldn't be such a problem if Marner wasn't thought to be 9 to 10 mill
player. Why is he over rated as far as his money. Dont even know if he is better than nylander.
- msillen

Marner's left pinky toe alone is better than Nylander.

Option C is not good enough for you?
- 21peter

Option (frank) you was the funnier option.

C or D would work but neither team is going to make that deal. Also, the Leafs need a RHD and Provorov and Heiskanen are both LHD and therefore less than ideal.

The leafs issue wouldn't be such a problem if Marner wasn't thought to be 9 to 10 mill
player. Why is he over rated as far as his money. Dont even know if he is better than nylander.
- msillen

that last part is laughable.

Nylander's situation was made worse by the signing of Tavares and Matthews being so good.
Wish he could've played all season long as Buston Glassthews.

Marner's left pinky toe alone is better than Nylander.
- plantheparade

a typical left-wing statement

Marner's left pinky toe alone is better than Nylander.
- plantheparade

Well that is a ridicules comment. Marner is not worth 10 million which is what I see and hear. Your comment doesn't prove nothing its a baseless comment. Nylander =Marner so far

Option (frank) you was the funnier option.

C or D would work but neither team is going to make that deal. Also, the Leafs need a RHD and Provorov and Heiskanen are both LHD and therefore less than ideal.
- Unholy_Goalie

holy

didn't know you had it in you...

Well that is a ridicules comment. Marner is not worth 10 million which is what I see and hear. Your comment doesn't prove nothing its a baseless comment. Nylander =Marner so far
- msillen

Marner is better than Jack Eichel.
And Eichel makes 10million.
So there's that.

Well that is a ridicules comment. Marner is not worth 10 million which is what I see and hear. Your comment doesn't prove nothing its a baseless comment. Nylander =Marner so far
- msillen

Right now, Nylander is basically Jeff Skinner in terms of production after two full seasons in the league... How much would you pay Jeff Skinner?

Marner is better than Jack Eichel.
And Eichel makes 10million.
So there's that.
- plantheparade

Ah that is a big no, you fans are over rating your players again. Marner is not worth 10 mill. Yeah marner is worth 4 mill more than pasternak. Sure buddy

Marner is better than Jack Eichel.
And Eichel makes 10million.
So there's that.
- plantheparade

Yup you got my vote

Liljegren is a RHD, Sandin is an LHD.

We need more RHD right now. Prospect or not.
- PatC80

Igor Ozhiganov and Holl for me are also pretty good young guys that I would still consider prospects. I agree if it's a blue chip, but otherwise go for it now. This team is winning without their first line right now, and with the proper addition on the blue line could possibly make a run.

Ah that is a big no, you fans are over rating your players again. Marner is not worth 10 mill. Yeah marner is worth 4 mill more than pasternak. Sure buddy
- msillen

And Jack is a better player so I guess you over rate your players and under rate other teams players.

Halak + Ryder + 2nd round pick
- Aaron_85

Gold Jerry, Gold

Well that is a ridicules comment. Marner is not worth 10 million which is what I see and hear. Your comment doesn't prove nothing its a baseless comment. Nylander =Marner so far
- msillen

Marner could very realistically be 82 or more points. Plus he shows up in the playoffs and actually goes into the corner, something WN doesn't really do much. If Marner puts up these numbers he will get close to 10. Probably 8.5 - 9.5.

Right now, Nylander is basically Jeff Skinner in terms of production after two full seasons in the league... How much would you pay Jeff Skinner?
- PatC80

Different players imo....one is a play maker and the other a pure goal scorer....Skinner has multiple 30+ goal seasons and is on pace for another....more of a proven player but Nylander only has two years so that’s not his fault

Yup you got my vote
- BreathLeafs2015

I see you have the same issue. The only player on the leafs that might be better is Matthews that's it. I guess you don't know their are other teams

Also Dont forget with the Marner and Eichle comparisons - Jack hates to loose, or so Garth keeps saying.

What would Nylander and Gardiner get you from Carolina? May as well move both of them and clear the decks

Marner could very realistically be 82 or more points. Plus he shows up in the playoffs and actually goes into the corner, something WN doesn't really do much. If Marner puts up these numbers he will get close to 10. Probably 8.5 - 9.5.
- aminnes

You know why? Because he is better at controlled zone entries than anyone else on the Leafs.

Also Dont forget with the Marner and Eichle comparisons - Jack hates to loose, or so Garth keeps saying.
- 5Hole Mgee

What does Garth have to do with a serious conversation. The only player on the leafs that is better Jack is Matthews. Don't over rate Marner. 8 million maybe, 10 million is a laugh.

You know why? Because he is better at controlled zone entries than anyone else on the Leafs.
- markmark

Because he was invisible against Boston in the playoffs. Marner, after getting elbows to the head in the corner, sets up goals. Controlled zone entry = 8 million over 8 years...

Because he was invisible against Boston in the playoffs. Marner, after getting elbows to the head in the corner, sets up goals. Controlled zone entry = 8 million over 8 years...
- aminnes

Jack is better at controlled entry

Because he was invisible against Boston in the playoffs. Marner, after getting elbows to the head in the corner, sets up goals. Controlled zone entry = 8 million over 8 years...
- aminnes

Should we start up the dump Matthews train then?

Nobody is debating how good Marner is. Nylander "not battling in the corners" is because he and Matthews together control the puck and the play VERY well.