You lost me, it's the only thing I can see now.
- JRR1285

One of the best '3rd line's in hockey:
Poo-Brass-Zuke

Surprised you don’t have Don Maloney on there. He was your guy!
- Slimtj100

I did have him for a minute

- TPC

For real though, that Graves, Lindros, Bure line.

You lost me, it's the only thing I can see now.
- JRR1285

I hate to nitpick, but you all listed 3 top pairings instead of a best 1st, a best 2nd and a best 3rd.
Ok, maybe not Staal. But McD and G were never our #2 pair.

Play by the rules!!!

My favorite Tikkanen memory is when he hit the camera in the Playoffs against Florida. Nobody knew it went in except him.


- JRR1285

Agreed on this one. I remember him laying against the crossbar being like "i tell you that's in" and just waiting for them to confirm it

I hate to nitpick, but you all listed 3 top pairings instead of a best 1st, a best 2nd and a best 3rd.
Ok, maybe not Staal. But McD and G were never our #2 pair.

Play by the rules!!!
- Tonybere

but they SHOULD have been, maybe we'd have the Cup

Nobody is using Gretzky????

granted it was three years but he is one of maybe 4-5 Rangers that averaged 1+ pts/game for his time here.... and he kinda had a cool nickname which would imply he should be on any of these rosters.

but they SHOULD have been, maybe we'd have the Cup
- jimbro83

Perhaps.
Exactly who was here that was going to play above them?

Nobody is using Gretzky????

granted it was three years but he is one of maybe 4-5 Rangers that averaged 1+ pts/game for his time here.... and he kinda had a cool nickname which would imply he should be on any of these rosters.
- MiloslavHorava

Agreed.

Nobody is using Gretzky????

granted it was three years but he is one of maybe 4-5 Rangers that averaged 1+ pts/game for his time here.... and he kinda had a cool nickname which would imply he should be on any of these rosters.
- MiloslavHorava

lol
Maybe it's like back in the 80's when you did a pool at the start of the season, but no one was allowed to pick him.

- TPC

Might as well put Muckler on that list.

Nobody is using Gretzky????

granted it was three years but he is one of maybe 4-5 Rangers that averaged 1+ pts/game for his time here.... and he kinda had a cool nickname which would imply he should be on any of these rosters.
- MiloslavHorava

I thought about him, but didn't

feel free to make your own and not be Siskel and Ebert to everyone else's though

I thought about him, but didn't

feel free to make your own and not be Siskel and Ebert to everyone else's though
- jimbro83

mine:

1987 to present

Graves-Messier-Jagr
Nash-Stepan-Gartner
Tikkanen-Dubinsky-Callahan
Avery-Boyle-Prust

Leetch-Beukeboom
McDonagh-Girardi
Staal-Patrick

Lundqvist
Richter

1971 to 1987:

Hadfield-Ratelle-Gilbert
Vickers-Esposito-Hedberg
Larouche-Rogers-Pavelich
Erixon-Tkachuk-Johnstone

Park-Greschner
Beck-Routsalainen
Seiling-Maloney

Giacomin
Vanbiesbrouck
- jimbro83

I'm with JR on swapping Step with Puddin' Head. What a team that would have been. No way that roster would fit under the current cap.

I'm with JR on swapping Step with Puddin' Head. What a team that would have been. No way that roster would fit under the current cap.
- Fenrir

Graves-Messier-Jagr
Gaborik-Gretzky-Bure
Nash-Lindros-Gartner
Tikkanen-Nylander-Prust

Leetch-Beukeboom
McDonagh-Girardi
Samuelsson-Zubov

Lundqvist
Richter

For real though, that Graves, Lindros, Bure line.
- JRR1285

Maybe I am not as dumb as i look

Graves-Messier-Jagr
Gaborik-Gretzky-Bure
Nash-Lindros-Gartner
Tikkanen-Nylander-Prust

Leetch-Beukeboom
McDonagh-Girardi
Samuelsson-Zubov

Lundqvist
Richter
- JRR1285

I actually did think about Samuelson a bit, I just didn't think Zubov was here long enough

I actually did think about Samuelson a bit, I just didn't think Zubov was here long enough
- jimbro83

I know a lot of people hate him but he was/is one of my favorite Rangers ever.

Zubov never should have left but he left a big impression on me during his short time here.

I know a lot of people hate him but he was/is one of my favorite Rangers ever.

Zubov never should have left but he left a big impression on me during his short time here.
- JRR1285

Zubov was traded for one of your favorite Rangers ever

Graves-Messier-Jagr
Gaborik-Gretzky-Bure
Nash-Lindros-Gartner
Tikkanen-Nylander-Prust

Leetch-Beukeboom
McDonagh-Girardi
Samuelsson-Zubov

Lundqvist
Richter
- JRR1285

Forgot about Ulfie.

Zubov was traded for one of your favorite Rangers ever
- jimbro83

Yeah, funny how that went. I would have rather kept him looking back but Ulf was a decent consolation prize.