Not as comparable as you think. Larsson was 4 years younger when traded than Tanev is now, he didn't/doesn't have a history of injuries like Tanev does and I don't think there's a team as desperate as Edmonton was for a RHD in the league right now (maybe ever).

Teams like Detroit, Tampa and Philadelphia are probably your best bets.
- MaximumBone

I did mention a few posts later that I don't expect a payout like Hall for Tanev, but his possession stats show that he is better as a shutdown Dman than Larsson or just about anyone else for that matter. That should cover at least in part the age gap. Like I say though, I don't expect the world for Tanev, but I do expect something worth getting excited about in return, such as an elite prospect or a mid 1st round pick+

Benning taking a lot of heat right now for his interview with TSN over in Paris:

Benning #TSN1410: I tell our guys we want European skill with North American heart. We want skilled players, defensemen that can move puck

AGAIN, what does Tanev's injury history look like?
- As_I_See_It

A whole lot better than your posting history.

Benning taking a lot of heat right now for his interview with TSN over in Paris:
- WhiteLie

Tanev and Virtanen for Drouin or Tanev and say Subban for Drouin and Callahan
Tanev for Kasperi Kapenen and a 1st
Tanev and Virtanen for Nylander. To me this makrs a bucket of sense for both sides.

Really, sorry if that was offensive, it was an observation of all the leaf fans declaring what they think someone is worth.
- Makita

Don't apologize. ban him

Benning taking a lot of heat right now for his interview with TSN over in Paris:
- WhiteLie

I am really starting to get a feeling that Makar has passed Liljegren on his D rankings and he will be selected at 5. I like it, high risk pick. Benning will be praised or fired

Wjat about Tanev for coutourier? Dun dun dun

I am really starting to get a feeling that Makar has passed Liljegren on his D rankings and he will be selected at 5. I like it, high risk pick. Benning will be praised or fired
- CanuckDon

Makar and Heiskanen have both passed Liljegren on most credible lists/rankings. At this point, Liljegren would be the reach if they choose D at 5.

I'd be happy with any of Makar/Heiskanen/Mittelstadt/Necas

I am really starting to get a feeling that Makar has passed Liljegren on his D rankings and he will be selected at 5. I like it, high risk pick. Benning will be praised or fired
- CanuckDon

For the love of mankind pick the safest player

Tanev and Virtanen for Drouin or Tanev and say Subban for Drouin and Callahan
Tanev for Kasperi Kapenen and a 1st
Tanev and Virtanen for Nylander. To me this makrs a bucket of sense for both sides.
- Jkuzzi

Beats the proposals by simpleton Toronto fans I saw earlier in the week which were

Tanev
5th overall pick
Juolevi
32 overall pick

For

Drouin
Callahan

I am really starting to get a feeling that Makar has passed Liljegren on his D rankings and he will be selected at 5. I like it, high risk pick. Benning will be praised or fired
- CanuckDon

Tough choice between European skill and North American heart

Makar and Heiskanen have both passed Liljegren on most credible lists/rankings. At this point, Liljegren would be the reach if they choose D at 5.

I'd be happy with any of Makar/Heiskanen/Mittelstadt/Necas
- Nucker101

Glass
Vilardi
Heiskanen
Mittlestadt

If we get one of these players at 5, I will be happy, but prefer Glass/Heiskanen

I did mention a few posts later that I don't expect a payout like Hall for Tanev, but his possession stats show that he is better as a shutdown Dman than Larsson or just about anyone else for that matter. That should cover at least in part the age gap. Like I say though, I don't expect the world for Tanev, but I do expect something worth getting excited about in return, such as an elite prospect or a mid 1st round pick+
- NorthNuck

Depending on the prospect and the plus on the 1st, I think I can agree with that. Certainly not a Nylander as keeps being brought up, though.

Tanev and Virtanen for Drouin or Tanev and say Subban for Drouin and Callahan
Tanev for Kasperi Kapenen and a 1st
Tanev and Virtanen for Nylander. To me this makrs a bucket of sense for both sides.
- Jkuzzi

Not sure that Toronto would agree.

Makar and Heiskanen have both passed Liljegren on most credible lists/rankings. At this point, Liljegren would be the reach if they choose D at 5.

I'd be happy with any of Makar/Heiskanen/Mittelstadt/Necas
- Nucker101

I tend to agree...although I don't rate Necas as high as you. I'd be pleased with any of Makar, Heiskanen, Glass, Mittle, .......even Vilardi I suppose. lot's of good options

Depending on the prospect and the plus on the 1st, I think I can agree with that. Certainly not a Nylander as keeps being brought up, though.
- MaximumBone

Yup. After seeing them play together at the worlds last year I'd have no issue giving up a first to play Tanev with Rielly. His injury history is a bit worrying, but he's one of the top pure shut-down D in the league.

Tough choice between European skill and North American heart
- WhiteLie

heartless Europeans

I tend to agree...although I don't rate Necas as high as you. I'd be pleased with any of Makar, Heiskanen, Glass, Mittle, .......even Vilardi I suppose. lot's of good options
- CanuckDon

Vilardi I'd be happy with 5, but I'd be mildly surprised if he doesn't go at 3 or 4. Glass I like as well. I haven't watched much of these guys lately so come up with a definite list yet so like most people, it's just a cluster of 3-5 prospects for me.

Looking forward to our team in 2019

Dahlen Goldobin Boeser Baertschi Granlund Erickson Cassels Horvat Sutter up front
Stecher Subban Makar Tanev Biega Juolevi

What a joke.
Expecting a lot of 15-2 losses coming if they continue down this road of soft skilled players.

Depending on the prospect and the plus on the 1st, I think I can agree with that. Certainly not a Nylander as keeps being brought up, though.
- MaximumBone

I really like Tanev but his injury history is concerning

Not sure that Toronto would agree.
- MaximumBone

Nope.

Absolutely unwilling to trade Nylander unless it's for a young stud D. Not many rookies get over 60 points, and he (and Matthews) would surely have even more if Hyman could hit the broadside of a barndoor with a shot...

Nope.

Absolutely unwilling to trade Nylander unless it's for a young stud D. Not many rookies get over 60 points, and he (and Matthews) would surely have even more if Hyman could hit the broadside of a barndoor with a shot...
- lumlums

The Leafs won't trade Nylander and I can't blame them. I am sure he is a huge hit in the showers

Nope.

Absolutely unwilling to trade Nylander unless it's for a young stud D. Not many rookies get over 60 points, and he (and Matthews) would surely have even more if Hyman could hit the broadside of a barndoor with a shot...
- lumlums

Hi lums