Jan Levine: Semi-Finals Round: Vote for five worst trades in Rangers' history First two rounds narrowed list down from 36 to 12

Cam Talbot, Hags and Duclair should be no where on this list.

Cam Talbot, Hags and Duclair should be no where on this list.
- mdw7413

they should have just made better trades for Talbot and Hagelin, but they had to be traded

Cam Talbot, Hags and Duclair should be no where on this list.
- mdw7413

You know my view on this.

they should have just made better trades for Talbot and Hagelin, but they had to be traded
- jimbro83

Hagelin, definitely. Talbot there just wasn't a market for him.

At the NHL Declaration of Principles event. Shattenkirk, Richter, E Karlsson, LaFontaine, Seth Jones etc here.

You know my view on this.
- airjan23

I know Jan, just have to do the results from the poll.

I know Jan, just have to do the results from the poll.
- mdw7413

I took some editor's license but had to go with the voting for at 10 of them

Hagelin, definitely. Talbot there just wasn't a market for him.
- mdw7413

it will just never end, then you get the people who say the Rangers should have traded Lundqvist instead. They are like the Ranger version of 9/11 truthers

Cam Talbot, Hags and Duclair should be no where on this list.
- mdw7413

Talbot and Duclair, I agree.
I voted for the Hags trade (last time around, not this time) because it was terrible. The fact that he needed to be moved due to his pending cap hit does not excuse the fact that they got NOTHING of value for him. Might as well have just released him.

Talbot and Duclair, I agree.
I voted for the Hags trade (last time around, not this time) because it was terrible. The fact that he needed to be moved due to his pending cap hit does not excuse the fact that they got NOTHING of value for him. Might as well have just released him.
- Tonybere

Emerson Etem sucked, I am not really sure what they saw in him. I guess they had followed him and scouted him for years but they traded for a guy who had spent half of the previous season in the AHL and had to pass through waivers to be sent down again.

Just a baaaaaad job, no matter who the architect was, Gorton or Sather

it will just never end, then you get the people who say the Rangers should have traded Lundqvist instead. They are like the Ranger version of 9/11 truthers
- jimbro83

Thats probably the most annoying thing.

I know most on here won't care but ...

BOS acquires Brad Park, Jean Ratelle and Joe Zanussi. NYR acquire Phil Esposito and Carol Vadnais

the day after this trade I stopped being a Ranger fan. I loved Brad Park.

Talbot and Duclair, I agree.
I voted for the Hags trade (last time around, not this time) because it was terrible. The fact that he needed to be moved due to his pending cap hit does not excuse the fact that they got NOTHING of value for him. Might as well have just released him.
- Tonybere

Yeah, I definitely agree with your point Tony. I just have trouble voting for someone who had to be traded.

http://deadspin.com/repor...in-alleged-2m-1800675539?

Haha, maybe I'll start to listen now. His voice made that show unlistenable for me. That and the constant talk about the Knicks.

http://deadspin.com/report-radio-host-craig-carton-arrested-in-alleged-2m-1800675539?


- eichiefs9

personally I usually found Carton to be funny whenever I tuned them in on the way to work

I know most on here won't care but ...



the day after this trade I stopped being a Ranger fan. I loved Brad Park.
- David_Volek

Damn you are old David.

I was a couple months old.

http://deadspin.com/report-radio-host-craig-carton-arrested-in-alleged-2m-1800675539?


- eichiefs9

No clue who that is.

personally I usually found Carton to be funny whenever I tuned them in on the way to work
- jimbro83

I can't stand him. I think he is obnoxious. And sleezy, when women call in and he talks down to them and ask them "what are you wearing?"

I'm no Francesa fan, but he's gotta be dying laughing right now.

I can't stand him. I think he is obnoxious. And sleezy, when women call in and he talks down to them and ask them "what are you wearing?"

I'm no Francesa fan, but he's gotta be dying laughing right now.
- eichiefs9

I used to be a very big Francesca fan, he's just become so impossible to listen to because it's so obvious he doesn't want to talk to people on the phones anymore and he's completely lost his humor

I used to be a very big Francesca fan, he's just become so impossible to listen to because it's so obvious he doesn't want to talk to people on the phones anymore and he's completely lost his humor
- jimbro83

Yeah he is cutting people off before they can even get their comment out.

Randomly chose option 3...hope that helps

Damn you are old David.

I was a couple months old.
- mdw7413

Yes.

Can't stand Carton. Now I might tune in.