According to NHL players, the best player in the game isnt even on this list...



- robin_steele264

Eberle

Most exciting Players

Mario
Orr
Eddie Shack
Bob Hound Kelly
Domi

- BingoLady

Russian-factor
- peddy-93

Maybe because it's a comp of players 25 and under...are they 25 and under?

[quote=Leafland]

I loved Clark but don't even think he was the best Leaf of all time

Sundin
Clark
Sittler
Gilmore
Salming

This is a re-post because people seem to be ignoring this part of my last post. I am curious to know what people think when this is brought up.

Also, with this whole "then vs now" thing, why has nobody mentioned Selanne? He's 41, he played in the 90's with Gretzky, isn't THAT big (6 foot 200lbs), and still put up 66 points last season.

Brodeur.

In terms of #'s it's not even a question. I know people sue the "devil's defense" argument, but they haven't had the best defense for his entire career. He made some pretty acrobatic saves over the years (even in this past years playoffs). So while he's a butterfly icon he still has some athleticism and knows how to use it when he needs too.
- Domaju

again, i agree, Brodeur for many reasons, but Roy is right behind him.

I loved Clark but don't even think he was the best Leaf of all time

Sundin
Clark
Sittler
Gilmore
Salming
- maverickJ

Sittler's best days were in Philly...

Brodeur.

In terms of #'s it's not even a question. I know people sue the "devil's defense" argument, but they haven't had the best defense for his entire career. He made some pretty acrobatic saves over the years (even in this past years playoffs). So while he's a butterfly icon he still has some athleticism and knows how to use it when he needs too.
- Domaju

Hasek.


In terms of #'s its not even close.

Not Richard.

I've been over this too many times.

Add Hainsworth. No other player forced rule changes as great as he did.
- Atomic Wedgie

Uhmm, Jacques Plante?

The Rocket was awesome...I'll never forget the day of the big riot...
- Flyfreaky

Lol Habs fans are crazy

Most exciting Players

Mario
Orr
Lafleur
Messier
Yzerman
Ovechkin?
- BingoLady

I never found Messier exciting. For me, Lafleur was the most exciting player I ever watched live.

Here's a good debate.

Whos better Brodeur vs Roy?
- peddy-93

I can't give a fair answer .... I really hate Roy

So brodeur

Maybe because it's a comp of players 25 and under...are they 25 and under?
- celata29

Yes they are doing 25 and under and over 25.

Brodeur.

In terms of #'s it's not even a question. I know people sue the "devil's defense" argument, but they haven't had the best defense for his entire career. He made some pretty acrobatic saves over the years (even in this past years playoffs). So while he's a butterfly icon he still has some athleticism and knows how to use it when he needs too.
- Domaju

I would pick Brodeur too, frankly because he's my favourite goalie dating back to when i was like 8 years old, but also having almost every single goalie record doesnt lie either.

Sittler's best days were in Philly...
- Flyfreaky

Lies

This is a re-post because people seem to be ignoring this part of my last post. I am curious to know what people think when this is brought up.

Also, with this whole "then vs now" thing, why has nobody mentioned Selanne? He's 41, he played in the 90's with Gretzky, isn't THAT big (6 foot 200lbs), and still put up 66 points last season.
- Domaju

teemu burried what, 76 goals a rookie.

thats when he played in the gretzky era.

if u see another player come in as arookie and score 76 goals, we have gone back to the 80's.

thats what i mean by dif style of hockey. that will never happen again, ever.

i actually really didn't know that.
- celata29

That's because it isn't true.

He had an argument with his wife. He went ballistic, and slammed a door, breaking the frame.

His wife called 911 and then hung up. So police had to show up.

Yes, he was arrested. They later dismissed all charges.

Lol Habs fans are crazy
- maverickJ

The craziest.

Sittler's best days were in Philly...
- Flyfreaky

Take that back you son of a female dog.

That's because it isn't true.

He had an argument with his wife. He went ballistic, and slammed a door, breaking the frame.

His wife called 911 and then hung up. So police had to show up.

Yes, he was arrested. They later dismissed all charges.
- Atomic Wedgie

Facts? WTF?

Sittler's best days were in Philly...
- Flyfreaky

and Dougie as a Hab breaking the glass

again, i agree, Brodeur for many reasons, but Roy is right behind him.
- big_dion

Oh yes. Roy is a very close 2nd.

This is a re-post because people seem to be ignoring this part of my last post. I am curious to know what people think when this is brought up.

Also, with this whole "then vs now" thing, why has nobody mentioned Selanne? He's 41, he played in the 90's with Gretzky, isn't THAT big (6 foot 200lbs), and still put up 66 points last season.
- Domaju

Great measuring stick. Argument in favor of Gretzky and Lemieux being timeless and still being able to dominate in todays NHL

I would pick Brodeur too, frankly because he's my favourite goalie dating back to when i was like 8 years old, but also having almost every single goalie record doesnt lie either.
- peddy-93

Id take Roy way over Marty.

Marty is overatted.... put up great team stats.

Amazing longevity.


Not the best ever.

Maybe because it's a comp of players 25 and under...are they 25 and under?
- celata29

No, its cuz they're russian.