Wanna blog? Start your own hockey blog with My HockeyBuzz. Register for free today!
 
Forums :: Blog World :: Richard Cloutier: Should the Oilers Deal Gagner to the Kings?
Author Message
VANTEL
Joined: 07.03.2010

Feb 19 @ 7:09 PM ET
Yeah VAN put a good nail in their playoff hopes.
- deks1

They really should be selling and get some assets.
Kaptainkesler
Joined: 02.21.2011

Feb 19 @ 7:15 PM ET
Van would need a goalie
- VANTEL

Roloson?
deks1
Edmonton Oilers
Joined: 02.13.2012

Feb 19 @ 7:17 PM ET
Van would need a goalie
- VANTEL


Schnieder
VANTEL
Joined: 07.03.2010

Feb 19 @ 7:19 PM ET
Schnieder
- deks1

yes he would be the main goalie they would need a back up
wingz4life
Detroit Red Wings
Location: Canada Sucks, MI
Joined: 01.31.2006

Feb 19 @ 7:20 PM ET
hemsky to LA with penner
what a duo
VANTEL
Joined: 07.03.2010

Feb 19 @ 7:21 PM ET
Roloson?
- Kaptainkesler

Then Tampa would need a goalie.
Kaptainkesler
Joined: 02.21.2011

Feb 19 @ 7:22 PM ET
Then Tampa would need a goalie.
- VANTEL

for what, fail for Nail?
deks1
Edmonton Oilers
Joined: 02.13.2012

Feb 19 @ 7:22 PM ET
yes he would be the main goalie they would need a back up
- VANTEL


Call up Eddie Lack? I don't think that deal will happen anyways.
VANTEL
Joined: 07.03.2010

Feb 19 @ 7:25 PM ET
Call up Eddie Lack? I don't think that deal will happen anyways.
- deks1

Lack will not be back up this year.
Kaptainkesler
Joined: 02.21.2011

Feb 19 @ 7:27 PM ET
Call up Eddie Lack? I don't think that deal will happen anyways.
- deks1

damn it.. I was gonna get Gillis on the phone. I figure if Nonis and Howson can work in the business why can't I
VANTEL
Joined: 07.03.2010

Feb 19 @ 7:27 PM ET
for what, fail for Nail?
- Kaptainkesler

What happens if Garon gets injured put in Stevie Y?
Kaptainkesler
Joined: 02.21.2011

Feb 19 @ 7:28 PM ET
What happens if Garon gets injured put in Stevie Y?
- VANTEL

Downie. I am certain that guys would shoot the puck at his head
VANTEL
Joined: 07.03.2010

Feb 19 @ 7:29 PM ET
damn it.. I was gonna get Gillis on the phone. I figure if Nonis and Howson can work in the business why can't I
- Kaptainkesler

It was a decent try just missing the back up goalie.
VANTEL
Joined: 07.03.2010

Feb 19 @ 7:29 PM ET
Downie. I am certain that guys would shoot the puck at his head
- Kaptainkesler

We want Downie
trevor79
Edmonton Oilers
Location: grande prairie, AB
Joined: 10.04.2010

Feb 19 @ 7:32 PM ET
I think Cloutier is way over valuing Gagner, He's a good player but by no means would he be worth Schenn, plus. I don't even think I would do Schenn straight up.
- Mystery


Shenns not as good as you think he is either. Healthy scratch the other night. Hrs becoming over rated.
Kaptainkesler
Joined: 02.21.2011

Feb 19 @ 7:35 PM ET
We want Downie
- VANTEL

alright, downie and b Clark for Raymond and a 2nd?
thefullnelson
Edmonton Oilers
Location: Edmonton, AB
Joined: 02.03.2012

Feb 19 @ 7:35 PM ET
My $.02 on Gagner's value:
He is now a good, not great, second line center with ~60% potential to become a great, but not elite, second line center. His compete level and heart are enormous which could easily lead to him overperforming in the playoffs - particularly if there is a great big scary line 1 to draw away an opponent's best defenders. He has nice hands, good hustle, great hockey IQ and plays well on the PP. Little injury history. Next season 45-65 pts seems likely. With good development I see his ceiling ~70 points, though ~80 is possible. At worst he could remain in the 40-50 doldrums - an adequate, but not good, second line center. Seems most likely (~60%) to give a good 5-10 ~60 point seasons.
Amazing combination of pedigree, youth, experience and performance. Drafted # 6 overall. 22 years old. GP 341 G 72 A 138 P 210 -45 174PM 24PPG (http://oilers.nhl.com/club/player.htm?id=8474040)
He's not Gretzky, but he's having no trouble showing that he is a proven and reliable NHL level top 6 player and should continue to be at least as good or better for the next decade plus. He has also shown flashes of genuine brilliance, even though his development was badly mishandled by his team.
IMHO Gagner is very near to breaking through and his timetable to do so (if he's going to) synchs perfectly with The Plan. A lot of people disagree. Let's say we swap him.
Say we get a young, big, strong, can't-miss second-pairing d-man who can clear the net and move the puck - preferably a right-handed shot. This would immediately make Edmonton a more balanced team and translate into more wins next season... which would translate into a worse draft pick next season which might mean that in year 5/5 of The Plan we barely miss for our Cup bid because we just didn't have the organizational depth to overcome injuries (sound familiar?). Then we spend the next 10 years endlessly tweaking our roster trying to recreate that one elusive moment of near-glory (sound familiar?).
You know what happens when you rush a miracle? You get rotten miracles! We will someday need to make a depth-for-quality move to pick up the one perfect player we need to fill X roster hole, and on that day my friends, we will pay large, large, large...
thefullnelson
Edmonton Oilers
Location: Edmonton, AB
Joined: 02.03.2012

Feb 19 @ 7:37 PM ET
while you rambled on there for a bit, this is a good post
- Kaptainkesler

Sorry dude, I like words and get carried away with them. I'll be good.
Kaptainkesler
Joined: 02.21.2011

Feb 19 @ 7:38 PM ET
Sorry dude, I like words and get carried away with them. I'll be good.
- thefullnelson

StayTunedMTC
Los Angeles Kings
Location: LA 2, ANA 1, CGY 1, SJ 0, VAN 0, PHX 0, EDM who cares
Joined: 08.02.2011

Feb 19 @ 7:39 PM ET
Richards has and can play the wing.
- Maxbone

And he sucked at it with the Kings. No need to keep beating a drum if it doesn't make a sound.
Kaptainkesler
Joined: 02.21.2011

Feb 19 @ 7:41 PM ET
And he sucked at it with the Kings. No need to keep beating a drum if it doesn't make a sound.
- StayTunedMTC

yet we continue to read Barry's blog
Kaptainkesler
Joined: 02.21.2011

Feb 19 @ 7:43 PM ET
My $.02 on Gagner's value:
He is now a good, not great, second line center with ~60% potential to become a great, but not elite, second line center. His compete level and heart are enormous which could easily lead to him overperforming in the playoffs - particularly if there is a great big scary line 1 to draw away an opponent's best defenders. He has nice hands, good hustle, great hockey IQ and plays well on the PP. Little injury history. Next season 45-65 pts seems likely. With good development I see his ceiling ~70 points, though ~80 is possible. At worst he could remain in the 40-50 doldrums - an adequate, but not good, second line center. Seems most likely (~60%) to give a good 5-10 ~60 point seasons.
Amazing combination of pedigree, youth, experience and performance. Drafted # 6 overall. 22 years old. GP 341 G 72 A 138 P 210 -45 174PM 24PPG (http://oilers.nhl.com/club/player.htm?id=8474040)
He's not Gretzky, but he's having no trouble showing that he is a proven and reliable NHL level top 6 player and should continue to be at least as good or better for the next decade plus. He has also shown flashes of genuine brilliance, even though his development was badly mishandled by his team.
IMHO Gagner is very near to breaking through and his timetable to do so (if he's going to) synchs perfectly with The Plan. A lot of people disagree. Let's say we swap him.
Say we get a young, big, strong, can't-miss second-pairing d-man who can clear the net and move the puck - preferably a right-handed shot. This would immediately make Edmonton a more balanced team and translate into more wins next season... which would translate into a worse draft pick next season which might mean that in year 5/5 of The Plan we barely miss for our Cup bid because we just didn't have the organizational depth to overcome injuries (sound familiar?). Then we spend the next 10 years endlessly tweaking our roster trying to recreate that one elusive moment of near-glory (sound familiar?).
You know what happens when you rush a miracle? You get rotten miracles! We will someday need to make a depth-for-quality move to pick up the one perfect player we need to fill X roster hole, and on that day my friends, we will pay large, large, large...

- thefullnelson

45-65 points is a big range.
SameOld
Toronto Maple Leafs
Location: Toronto, ON
Joined: 07.25.2010

Feb 19 @ 7:48 PM ET
hahaha good lord Clouts.. In terms of fantasy trade rumours, day in day out you have the worst ideas on this site. Congratulations
SameOld
Toronto Maple Leafs
Location: Toronto, ON
Joined: 07.25.2010

Feb 19 @ 7:49 PM ET
Lots of talk coming out of LA...not Edmonton...yesterday suggesting Hemsky could be dealt for Jack Johnson.

I'm just sayin'

- Maxbone


hahaha oh my goodness
SameOld
Toronto Maple Leafs
Location: Toronto, ON
Joined: 07.25.2010

Feb 19 @ 7:51 PM ET
So you're saying fans of teams other than the Oilers know more about the Oilers than Oilers fans?

Keep in mind the Kings are desperate to find a way to score goals, and upper management jobs could be on the line if they don't make the playoffs this season.

- Maxbone


They certainly know more than a guy who's never played hockey and would have more experience writing about the exciting world of competitive eating..
Page: Previous  1, 2, 3, 4, 5, 6, 7, 8, 9, 10, 11, 12, 13, 14, 15, 16, 17  Next