So you are THAT d-bag?

PS... NICE JOB AT DODGING MY POINT!!!!
- MillerTime1130

well i was going to think maybe you were talking about the NYI but then again they arent exactly doing so well, so........

A cup in 67? Give me a break dude. That argument is retarded. Nobody on this board was even alive then.
- The-O-G

im not even a leaf fan, im just saying he keeps bringing up the past, but doesnt want to accept it when it is used against him

well i was going to think maybe you were talking about the NYI but then again they arent exactly doing so well, so........
- dmarsden2988

Dip, duck, dodge, dive, dodge, duck.....

MacCarther would be a joke of a 2nd liner on any of those teams I listed..

well i was going to think maybe you were talking about the NYI but then again they arent exactly doing so well, so........
- dmarsden2988

Shots fired at the Islanders.....

well i was going to think maybe you were talking about the NYI but then again they arent exactly doing so well, so........
- dmarsden2988

Well when I look at a keyboard, me thinks that is what he meant as the letter J is diagonally down to the left by one key from the I while the R is pretty much clear on the other side....

Hilarious! You think MacCarther is a top 6 NHL forward on any other legit team???

Boston... Chicago... Detroit.. Florida.. LA.. Nash... NJ... NYR.. Ott.. Philly.. Pitt.. SJ.. STL... Van would all laugh at him...
- MillerTime1130

lol really? you think Ottawa is a "legit" team but you dont think the leafs are? get your head out of your a$$

but before you posted the all time record between the leafs and sabres

sorry i forgot you can only say things that help your cause, carry on

a cup is a cup, and the leafs have won the cup

if you dont like it well then your cheering the right team, a team without a cup, so you must be happy
- dmarsden2988

I have been reading this nonsense about Buffalo and Toronto all afternoon.
f
First off Buffalo wasn't even in the NHL last time Tornonto won the cup.
In case you don't know that was back in 1967. 45 fricken years ago.
I really don't think that throwing up the "scoreboard" as an arugment against Buffalo fan is legit.
I find it extremely frustrating day after day to read over and over how Leaf fan is never wrong, Leaf fan who slams everyone else, but can't take their own medicine back.
Your miminal success this year is marginal at best. Good for you, but you should never be casting stones in your glass house.
I applaud your dedication, but you have absolutely nothing to brag about when it comes to your local hockey heros.
It baffles the brain how a team can redefine suckage year after year like the Leafs have and still maintaine such a dedicated following.
Again good for you for sticking with it, but honestly you are the only ones who care about your piece of poop team. Stop trying to shove them down us normal peoples throats!

lol really? you think Ottawa is a "legit" team but you dont think the leafs are? get your head out of your a$$
- matt1337

Sabre's fan...Not happening....

Dip, duck, dodge, dive, dodge, duck.....

MacCarther would be a joke of a 2nd liner on any of those teams I listed..
- MillerTime1130

pretty sure florida, nashville and maybe the kings, ottowa and st louis may like the production he can bring

i get your a sabres fan and feel you must hate the leafs, but seriously dude your coming off as a total fool

Dip, duck, dodge, dive, dodge, duck.....

MacCarther would be a joke of a 2nd liner on any of those teams I listed..
- MillerTime1130

I love Milwaukee

pretty sure florida, nashville and maybe the kings, ottowa and st louis may like the production he can bring

i get your a sabres fan and feel you must hate the leafs, but seriously dude your coming off as a total fool
- dmarsden2988

*you're
*Ottawa

Just an FYI for the grammar nazi....

I have been reading this nonsense about Buffalo and Toronto all afternoon.
f
First off Buffalo wasn't even in the NHL last time Tornonto won the cup.
In case you don't know that was back in 1967. 45 fricken years ago.
I really don't think that throwing up the "scoreboard" as an arugment against Buffalo fan is legit.
I find it extremely frustrating day after day to read over and over how Leaf fan is never wrong, Leaf fan who slams everyone else, but can't take their own medicine back.
Your miminal success this year is marginal at best. Good for you, but you should never be casting stones in your glass house.
I applaud your dedication, but you have absolutely nothing to brag about when it comes to your local hockey heros.
It baffles the brain how a team can redefine suckage year after year like the Leafs have and still maintaine such a dedicated following.
Again good for you for sticking with it, but honestly you are the only ones who care about your piece of poop team. Stop trying to shove them down us normal peoples throats!
- Sam67

look what team i support

i am a devils fan, i dont even like the leafs

but for a guy to bring up history and then disregard it when it doesnt help his cause then yes history matters no matter when it was

Sabre's fan...Not happening....
- Fruitcakenipple

like wow thats terrible

Carle, Schenn, JVR, a 1st and 2nd, for Ovi and Schultz. Hal Gil would be a lost cause. Flyers need a 50+ goal scorer, Ovi and Giroux> Sedins

im not even a leaf fan, im just saying he keeps bringing up the past, but doesnt want to accept it when it is used against him
- dmarsden2988

Ya I know but the past as in the last decade is a lot different than the past of half a century ago.

The whole argument is ridiculous, i'm just trying to give a non-biased opinion.

IMO the fans are getting a little too ridiculous on here, your team doesn't always make the best decisions 100% of the time, it would be a lot more civil on here if people could just accept that fact. Then we could maybe move on to some legitimate hockey conversations. Instead everyone's ego's get in the way and it leads to a bunch of useless name-calling.

*you're
*Ottawa

Just an FYI for the grammar nazi....
- MillerTime1130

the team you meant still didnt make sense

Dip, duck, dodge, dive, dodge, duck.....

MacCarther would be a joke of a 2nd liner on any of those teams I listed..
- MillerTime1130

Just looking at some players that I think teams would at least consider having Macarthur slotted in to replace existing top 6 players;

Florida...
Mikael Samuelsson, Marcel Goc, Sean Bergenheim

LA...
Jarret Stoll, Dustin Penner, Justin Williams

Nashville...
Sergei Kostitsyn Mike Fisher Martin Erat
Colin Wilson David Legwand Patric Hornqvist

Pitts...
Dustin Jeffrey Matt Cooke

OTT...
Jim O'Brien, Kyle Turris, Nick Foligno


And now I give up...you really have no clue what you are talking about now. I dont want to go through every team you listed one by one but you are out to lunch. Even Vancouver could use him to replace Mason Raymond and get better production.

Just looking at some players that I think teams would at least consider having Macarthur slotted in to replace existing top 6 players;

Florida...
Mikael Samuelsson, Marcel Goc, Sean Bergenheim

LA...
Jarret Stoll, Dustin Penner, Justin Williams

Nashville...
Sergei Kostitsyn Mike Fisher Martin Erat
Colin Wilson David Legwand Patric Hornqvist

Pitts...
Dustin Jeffrey Matt Cooke

OTT...
Jim O'Brien, Kyle Turris, Nick Foligno


And now I give up...you really have no clue what you are talking about now. I dont want to go through every team you listed one by one but you are out to lunch. Even Vancouver could use him to replace Mason Raymond and getter better production.


- PrairieLeafFan

Top six is generous, he's not a first liner, he's a second-third liner based on the team/situation. That being said everyone is comparing him to the 2 prospects Buffalo got for him, both which haven't got a legimate shot yet. There is no way to determine who won this trade.

Top six is generous, he's not a first liner, he's a second-third liner based on the team/situation. That being said everyone is comparing him to the 2 prospects Buffalo got for him, both which haven't got a legimate shot yet. There is no way to determine who won this trade.
- The-O-G

As of today.........the Leafs won the trade. In 5 years time, that may be different.

As of today.........the Leafs won the trade. In 5 years time, that may be different.
- faceto27

Ummm... the Leafs didn't make a trade for Mac...back to crayons and water paints for you!

It is the kind of trade that rarely happens but is often rumored for the obvious reasons we have discussed before.

Then it won't

Ummm... the Leafs didn't make a trade for Mac...back to crayons and water paints for you!
- PrairieLeafFan

Ummm... the Leafs didn't make a trade for Mac...back to crayons and water paints for you!
- PrairieLeafFan

Are you telling me these guys are arguing over a trade that never happened?

So much for trying to put some sense into 2 ridiculous people arguing about non-existent things.

Are you telling me these guys are arguing over a trade that never happened?

So much for trying to put some sense into 2 ridiculous people arguing about non-existent things.
- The-O-G

Are you telling me these guys are arguing over a trade that never happened?

So much for trying to put some sense into 2 ridiculous people arguing about non-existent things.
- The-O-G

leafs signed Mac after the Sabre's turned down his arbitration settelment and released him...


Not sure about how a trade got involved..