I'd rather have all of them, and pursue a free agent defenseman, rather than trade them for one.
- Jsaquella

i would sacrifice JVR...Just dont think he plays with fire inside most of the time...

I'd rather have all of them, and pursue a free agent defenseman, rather than trade them for one.
- Jsaquella

Agree.

I'd rather have all of them, and pursue a free agent defenseman, rather than trade them for one.
- Jsaquella

I still don't know why Nashville would trade either of their top 2 defensemen without getting something back in return that will help them just as much for the playoffs. JVR and Schenn don't replace what Weber can bring this year in the playoffs.

If the Flyers reached out to me for Weber, I definitely would.
- 77rams

If the Flyers reached out to me to get Weber I say lookie here bro Ill hook ya up but ya gotta do for me..... Quid Pro Quo my friend Buts thats me tho

They could somewhat replace what JvR and Schenn are doing now, not sure about long term. There's some skill in ADK now, but I don't see a Pronger or Schenn.
- Jsaquella

Matt Read is having a fantastic season but he has to repeat what he's doing now in order for me to be a believer. It's great riding the wave right now but next season at his age, he could either get better or flop. It took this kid a long time to get an NHL team's attention.

In order to get a franchise player like webber your going to have to give one up....and i dont mean the 6 game beast JVR...You all know deep down inside its gonna take giroux...if im the flyers i turn around and say no thank you.....

Who would actually do Giroux for Webber?
- Philly1980

1.5 game beast

i would sacrifice JVR...Just dont think he plays with fire inside most of the time...
- Philly1980

I'd need a big return. Far too much talent to simply trade him for less than something really significant.

I think he's still learning what it takes to dominate, espcially based on his developmental path.

I'd rather have all of them, and pursue a free agent defenseman, rather than trade them for one.
- Jsaquella

can you get anyone through free agency like Weber though? Suter may be available..but at a massive cost if he goes UFA. Massive enough to hinder your cap in the future if not cripple it. He goes UFA and the bidding will be ridiculous.

i would sacrifice JVR...Just dont think he plays with fire inside most of the time...
- Philly1980

I would think about one or the other, but not both.

i would sacrifice JVR...Just dont think he plays with fire inside most of the time...
- Philly1980

i call him "The Wet Napkin"

I still don't know why Nashville would trade either of their top 2 defensemen without getting something back in return that will help them just as much for the playoffs. JVR and Schenn don't replace what Weber can bring this year in the playoffs.
- funmaster18

true I try to stay realistic as well, these pipe dreams dont make for much fun... Ill save that for the off season

Matt Read is having a fantastic season but he has to repeat what he's doing now in order for me to be a believer. It's great riding the wave right now but next season at his age, he could either get better or flop. It took this kid a long time to get an NHL team's attention.
- Schenn2shine

That's not untrue. But at the same time, I sure as Hell don't want to lose him.

true I try to stay realistic as well, these pipe dreams dont make for much fun... Ill save that for the off season
- bigmookalookie

Me too. If something goes down for either player before the year is out, it will have to blow the socks off of Nashville. They have all the power until the season is over.

I'd need a big return. Far too much talent to simply trade him for less than something really significant.

I think he's still learning what it takes to dominate, espcially based on his developmental path.
- Jsaquella

L Schenn and Torontos first GID homer

i call him "The Wet Napkin"
- Crimsoninja

harsh words man, If he heard them now that would make his conky worse

i call him "The Wet Napkin"
- Crimsoninja

harsh words man, If he heard them now that would make his conky worse
- bigmookalookie

i have a jvr jersey actually but i'll be burning it soon

closest the guy will ever get to playing with "that fire" for the rest of his career

i call him "The Wet Napkin"
- Crimsoninja

More like the invisible man most nights and not the hulk we saw against boston

i call him "The Wet Napkin"
- Crimsoninja

I call him "Jeff Carter".

- Philly1980

id ship him off for Turris striaghtup actually

i have a jvr jersey actually but i'll be burning it soon

closest the guy will ever get to playing with "that fire" for the rest of his career
- Crimsoninja

can i come? i'll bring the glen

More like the invisible man most nights and not the hulk we saw against boston
- Philly1980

Of course you are ignoring the fact that he's battling an injury that will require surgery...

I call him "Jeff Carter".
- Lexington Flyer

Yeah he does remind me a lot about that douchebag carter....never liked carter...dont care no matter how good hell ever be...

That's not untrue. But at the same time, I sure as Hell don't want to lose him.
- Jsaquella

I wouldn't simply give up any of our young talent and expect them not to suffer the Sophomore Jinx next season with added responsibility because we traded other youth away.

can i come? i'll bring the glen
- OrangeBlack27

ok thanks