I would offer Carle 4 years 18mill

I couldn't pay him more then Mez
- Scottie Upshall

Mez 190 points in 502 games.
Carle 186 points in 431 games.

He will be worth more than Mez in UFA.

Just to be sure, is that sarcasm?
- MJL

Yes. He is worth $5mm

please fill in the blanks

weber-$ per year 8
suter-$ per year 6.5
carle-$ per year 4.5

id love to see what everyone thinks
- mydoglicks

I would offer Carle 4 years 18mill
- Scottie Upshall

I would love him to take that deal. Hometown discount and what not.

I think he gets offered much more in UFA.

[quote=Scottie Upshall ]


so carle will in turn eat up prongers money if he cannot return

I would offer Carle 4 years 18mill
- Scottie Upshall

He wouldn't sign it. 12 minutes ago, you said Carle shouldn't get more then 4M.

please fill in the blanks

weber-$ per year
suter-$ per year
carle-$ per year

id love to see what everyone thinks
- mydoglicks

It's hard, because a Weber or Suter-especially Weber-could get a front loaded deal with a small hit.

But I think Weber could get $7-8mm, Suter between $6-7mm and Carle between $5-6mm

So the leafs and the flyers both shot the rumor down

Yes. He is worth $5mm
- Jsaquella

That's what I thought.

He wouldn't sign it. 12 minutes ago, you said Carle shouldn't get more then 4M.
- MJL

He ran a hard bargain
I added 500k

so carle will in turn eat up prongers money if he cannot return
- mydoglicks

If Carle stays, he will get a raise. He's not getting less than Coburn, IMO, probably more.

I couldn't pay him more then Mez
- Scottie Upshall

Meszaros signed his deal 3 Seasons ago. Salaries inflate. And Carle is a better player.

He ran a hard bargain
I added 500k
- Scottie Upshall

Shrewd. You really must be in 2nd place in your fantasy league.

Shrewd. You really must be in 2nd place in your fantasy league.
- Duran76

Mez 4
Carle 4.5
Coburn 3.6
Sutter 6.5
Kimmo 6.3
That's my Defense

If Carle stays, he will get a raise. He's not getting less than Coburn, IMO, probably more.
- Jsaquella

Carle deserves Paul Martin money...

Mez 4
Carle 4.5
Coburn 3.6
Sutter 6.5
Kimmo 6.3
That's my Defense
- Scottie Upshall

No it's not. Were back to doing some research. Coburn is already resigned to a deal paying 4.5M

Carle deserves Paul Martin money...
- isaiah520

Might want to re-check Carle to other guys around the NHL.

No it's not. Were back to doing some research. Coburn is already resigned to a deal paying 4.5M
- MJL

Carle has been as good as or actually better than Paul Martin

No it's not. Were back to doing some research. Coburn is already resigned to a deal paying 4.5M
- MJL

And he's only putting out 5 guys. His fantasy league must only have 2 teams.

Carle has been as good as or actually better than Paul Martin
- puckhead17

I would take Carle over Paul Martin. I really thought that once he got a better offensive team, he would be a top point producer from the back end.

And he's only putting out 5 guys. His fantasy league must only have 2 teams.
- tangent_man

His D is so good, they only need 5.

I would take Carle over Paul Martin. I really thought that once he got a better offensive team, he would be a top point producer from the back end.
- MJL

When you really look at it, Paul Martin hasn't done very much

like he's still playing for "Uncle Lou" in the swamp

so on an average....

weber-7.5
suter- 6.5
carle-5.5

so now whos is the best value?

weber will cost the most in a trade and thats the only way to get him cuz of his rfa status

suter will cost a nhl'er, prospect and a high draft pick

carle wont cost us any bodies unless we have to dump to fit him