Or feaster called and said ok how about a 2nd for.DEAL!
- Guimania

No, I'm sticking with my guess.

I hate to ask this... and I'm not trolling when I ask the inevitable...

But would Gauthier be making space for one Vinny Lecavalier? it would seem that the Habs have some young assets, particularly on the blue line that might make a deal possible.
- BorjeFan4Ever

Late, and why the wink if you are not trolling?

I am not asking for your approval on believing what I want.

My point is, Cammi was underachieving big time in MTL, and did so last year as well. This team isn't making the playoffs. You get rid of him, you get space, you get a 2nd round pick, AND a guy who scores the same amount as Cammi. Then you get a prospect who could turn into an NHL player. Regardless of what Cammi does, this is a good deal for the Habs.
- hscesq

This is the truth.

He stated this morning he doesn't think it's a bad deal for Mtl.
- habby

I never said it was a bad deal either.

I think it is a wash, with the Flames having the better chances of coming out ahead if Cammy plays like he did 3 years ago.

Camm scores 35 next year and Rene scores 12 and has breakdwon becuase of the media next year. Montreal still wins?
- Guimania

Depends what they do with the cap space and what the pick turn out to be.

is Ryan White dead?

is Andrei Markov dead?

is Scott Gomez dead? *hopes*
- dt99999

I'm on it...I'll be back with news soon

Who's better?
Milbury or Gauthier
Discuss

sorry (genuniely),

seriously - you need to put the hat back on the avatar...something like a jester in response to Gauthier.
- BorjeFan4Ever

Next "hat" will most likely be a brown paper bag.

Camm scores 35 next year and Rene scores 12 and has breakdwon becuase of the media next year. Montreal still wins?
- Guimania

Depends who they sign with the extra 3 Mil.

Depends who the picks turn out being.

Depends if Holland or Ramo ever make it.

If you want to look long-term, gotta include all aspects of the trade.

Depends what they do with the cap space and what the pick turn out to be.
- hscesq

They sign Price and Subban to new contracts with the space.

Late, and why the wink if you are not trolling?
- Guimania

'cause its been discussed/debated/argued so many times before... but mainly because Gauthier's behavour seems radical and desperate... and something like Vinny would be just about crazy enough to fit...

They sign Price and Subban to new contracts with the space.
- Guimania

They can do that without the space.

I hate to ask this... and I'm not trolling when I ask the inevitable...

But would Gauthier be making space for one Vinny Lecavalier? it would seem that the Habs have some young assets, particularly on the blue line that might make a deal possible.
- BorjeFan4Ever

he'll need to shed a bunch more space for that.

Marinara is just upset because the self-centered Italian guy is gone from the team. Basically, PG admitted that if he could, he would trade Marinara for Calgary's second line journalist who makes only half as many meataballs.
- kev1586

this comment is filled with racism...





and so true

I am not asking for your approval on believing what I want.

My point is, Cammi was underachieving big time in MTL, and did so last year as well. This team isn't making the playoffs. You get rid of him, you get space, you get a 2nd round pick, AND a guy who scores the same amount as Cammi. Then you get a prospect who could turn into an NHL player. Regardless of what Cammi does, this is a good deal for the Habs.
- hscesq

You get a guy who can potentially score the same amount as Cammy (if Cammy were to stay on the Habs). And be just as inconsistent.

I just think it is a wash. No real winners, no real losers.

People who think otherwise are really not looking at the trade objectively.

Well you had to say Richard the french way anyways so ya take that...
- mr.peanut

(frank) off...

Who's better?
Milbury or Gauthier
Discuss
- MTL1

I want him fired but Gauthier has yet to trade away the likes of Luongo, Spezza, Chara for crap. I know I'm missing some, and that Gauthier is crap and needs to be fired, but still.

interesting...

http://sports.yahoo.com/b...kmePNyXU18VZ_BPWHKp97vLYF

edit: I fully expect someone to reply with "no" but feel free to do it.

I never said it was a bad deal either.

I think it is a wash, with the Flames having the better chances of coming out ahead if Cammy plays like he did 3 years ago.
- JDJ

My bet, he is injured before the playoffs.

They can do that without the space.
- hscesq

But they don't, they use up all the space.

I never said it was a bad deal either.

I think it is a wash, with the Flames having the better chances of coming out ahead if Cammy plays like he did 3 years ago.
- JDJ

I think the risk/reward is higher for the flames. If Mtl made more trades like this one I think they'd be in much better shape.

Depends what they do with the cap space and what the pick turn out to be.
- hscesq

They are not going to sign anyone.

Or... overpay for a 2nd line player and end up in the exact same place.

You get a guy who can potentially score the same amount as Cammy (if Cammy were to stay on the Habs). And be just as inconsistent.

I just think it is a wash. No real winners, no real losers.

People who think otherwise are really not looking at the trade objectively.
- JDJ

I don't think it has anything to do with objectivity.

I'm sending t-dot your way.
- dt99999

i'm sending crim to intercept

I want him fired but Gauthier has yet to trade away the likes of Luongo, Spezza, Chara for crap. I know I'm missing some, and that Gauthier is crap and needs to be fired, but still.
- kev1586

still chuckle when i think that he had luongo then traded him only to use a first overall pick on dipietro.