He was so horrible I keep him right out of my mind
- kasperrko

Rolston, Reasoner or Sim?

I'd take Sim out of those 3. He never tried to be anything but a grinder and always tried. Reasoner is just having a horrible year. Not really sure why.

Rolston, Reasoner or Sim?
- mighty13duck

Oh boy that is a tough one. I would go with right now REasoner. Rolston at least has some points. and Sim at least took stupid penalties

Agree wth Both. Out of those three I would take Sim. that shows how bad Reasoner and Rolston are.

Bill Muckalt. Marty McInnis, robert Nillson, Vladmir Orszagh

Bill Muckalt. Marty McInnis, robert Nillson, Vladmir Orszagh
- kasperrko

What was wrong with McInnis? He averaged close to 40 pts a year while he was an Islander. Not too shabby.

What was wrong with McInnis? He averaged close to 40 pts a year while he was an Islander. Not too shabby.
- BringBackBalky

True but he just looked funny to me and they hyped him up alot when we first got him right out of the Olympics. I thought Scott LAchance was the better of the two

True but he just looked funny to me and they hyped him up alot when we first got him right out of the Olympics. I thought Scott LAchance was the better of the two
- kasperrko

I think your just picking names for the sake of picking them. Which is fine because the list is pretty long.

Kvasha never quit on his team or the organization. He never cried until he was traded. He was lazy and uninspired, but at least he didn't pout and quit like Muller did.
- Jethro09

Fair enough.......but which is worse? Its kind of the same thing.......the end result is unprofessional play.

Bill Muckalt. Marty McInnis, robert Nillson, Vladmir Orszagh
- kasperrko

I just got an email from the Islanders. The following players will be inducted into the Islanders HOF next season..

Niklas Andersson Brent Severyn Dan Plante Doug Houda Paul Kruse Tom Chorske Vladimir Chebaturkin

Fair enough.......but which is worse? Its kind of the same thing.......the end result is unprofessional play.
- kindlyrick

Kirk Muller had an elitist attitude about him which fed his BS. He felt he was too good to be soiling himself wearing an Isles' sweater. I don't think Kvasha ever felt that he was too good to be playing for the lowly Isles.

I just got an email from the Islanders. The following players will be inducted into the Islanders HOF next season..

Niklas Andersson Brent Severyn Dan Plante Doug Houda Paul Kruse Tom Chorske Vladimir Chebaturkin
- Vukota

I'm in for that game. Hottest ticket in town! Dozens of people will be there!

But a huge fan fav while he was on the Island.

XxNYIxX
- XxNYIxX

What fans? Besides his first two seasons I hinestly don't know anyone who thought he was a great Islander? Not trying to be a douche but I honestly don't?

I just got an email from the Islanders. The following players will be inducted into the Islanders HOF next season..

Niklas Andersson Brent Severyn Dan Plante Doug Houda Paul Kruse Tom Chorske Vladimir Chebaturkin
- Vukota

Finally Dan Plante gets his recognition, and good for good ole Doug Houda he did score a big goal against Buffalo one year. I think it was his only goal but that itself should get him in.

Finally Dan Plante gets his recognition, and good for good ole Doug Houda he did score a big goal against Buffalo one year. I think it was his only goal but that itself should get him in.
- kasperrko

Rick DiPietro

What fans? Besides his first two seasons I hinestly don't know anyone who thought he was a great Islander? Not trying to be a douche but I honestly don't?
- Cptmjl

Best thing about Flatley wasn the Flats and Heels show.I thik he is getting in for that not his actual play

Turgeon would be my pick but I don't think he was an Islander long enough... Stevie Thomas??
- brodydog29

Steve Thomas!!! One of my favorite Islanders of all time!!! Guy did it all and could kick some serious ass!

Rick DiPietro
- UIF

Oh boy you went there. Ok knowing this organization he will be in the Hall of Fame I can actually see that happening. I sure hope not as he has done crap for us but I can see that. I would protest that ceremony to no end

What fans? Besides his first two seasons I hinestly don't know anyone who thought he was a great Islander? Not trying to be a douche but I honestly don't?
- Cptmjl

What makes a great Islander?

Personally I was a fan of Flats so I have no issues with it.

Steve Thomas!!! One of my favorite Islanders of all time!!! Guy did it all and could kick some serious ass!
- Cptmjl

I loved Benoit Hogue his speed great hands and could finish on a breakaway. Calling Grabner give this guy a call would ya

More like Jason Blake........more looks but cant finish. There's a reason both Vancouver and Florida gave up on a first rounder like Grabner. Yes he's fast......but he CANNOT finish. A breakaway and a penalty shot........isles win that game if he buries those.
- kindlyrick

If he score twenty to thirty goals a year and continues to play well on the PK and keep the other teams PP Dmen on their heals thats fine with me.

Steve Thomas!!! One of my favorite Islanders of all time!!! Guy did it all and could kick some serious ass!
- Cptmjl

And one of the best announced names at the Coliseum when he'd score:

StEEeeeeeEEVE THOMAS!

Who was the worst guy to play for the Isles??? Kvasha?
- brodydog29

Rolston has got Kavasha beat

Who was the worst guy to play for the Isles??? Kvasha?
- brodydog29

Rolston has got Kavasha beat

I just got an email from the Islanders. The following players will be inducted into the Islanders HOF next season..

Niklas Andersson Brent Severyn Dan Plante Doug Houda Paul Kruse Tom Chorske Vladimir Chebaturkin
- Vukota

Paul Kruse ruled. I used to drink beers with him at Mulcahey's after saturday home games.