serious question, how can Myers even sniff the top 20?

he was lost on the ice more often then not in his last season and a half

this is not a fantasy keeper league, it's who are the ten best d men in the nhl right now
- homiedclown

Disagree. From 1 year ago to the beginning of this year, he was excellent. He didn't start off well, I agree, but I'd take Myers on my team before Phaneuf. He cares more about hair gel and hitting midgets than being a winner.

paper or plastic?
- mhp

trying to get hits

Staal has played like 5 games this years, i cant put him on that list. I think Timmonen's best days are behind him. Lidtrsom is a once a generation guy, unreal.
- Homer

agreed

explain the bolded ones please on how they are better then phaneuf
- matt1337

Streit is a no brainer, hes one of the most underrated players in the league because hes committed to the islanders, for some reason.

How am i supposed to explain it though, just players from the hockey i watch that i feel are better or interchangeable.

He was having a bad year in 2010....I completely agreed with not having him on the team.
No one is saying he's the best dman in the league.....he's simply not overated...just overpaid.
- Fakepartofme

in its simplest terms, he is a good player, but when Buffalo plays TO I'm not like "oh crap, they have Phanuef"

Streit is a no brainer, hes one of the most underrated players in the league because hes committed to the islanders, for some reason.

How am i supposed to explain it though, just players from the hockey i watch that i feel are better or interchangeable.
- robz228

I disagree, he all O and PP, not much in his own zone

Streit is a no brainer, hes one of the most underrated players in the league because hes committed to the islanders, for some reason.

How am i supposed to explain it though, just players from the hockey i watch that i feel are better or interchangeable.
- robz228

I was toying between streit and byf for the tenth player

Lol so many of you last night wanted to leafs fans to leave your blog and stop trolling, do you really think that putting a picture of phaneuf with the title overrated is going to accomplish that? I hope we smash you guys on friday.

Streit is a no brainer, hes one of the most underrated players in the league because hes committed to the islanders, for some reason.

How am i supposed to explain it though, just players from the hockey i watch that i feel are better or interchangeable.
- robz228

And I'm taking Staal and Hedman (hedman is already great) on the P word

Disagree. From 1 year ago to the beginning of this year, he was excellent. He didn't start off well, I agree, but I'd take Myers on my team before Phaneuf. He cares more about hair gel and hitting midgets than being a winner.
- PassionBucket16

What hair gel, and what midgets?
I didn't know you checked him out

in its simplest terms, he is a good player, but when Buffalo plays TO I'm not like "oh crap, they have Phanuef"
- Homer

I think "Didn't Crosby own him in World Junior camp when 87 was only sixteen years old?"

Hedman
Chara
Staal
Karlsson
Letang
Keith
Hjalmarsson
Lidstrom
Suter
Weber
Doughty
Streit
Bieksa
Edler
Seabrook

Purposely leaving Myers off to avoid incoming troll comments, it really wasnt hard to name 15 off the top of my head that i'd rather have or are basically interchangeable for Phaneuf
- robz228

That took a while.....off the top of your head eh? Sure.
I agree with the bolded.

Why isnt Ryan Miller on this list?

Why isnt Ryan Miller on this list?
- jbold

agreed

Why isnt Ryan Miller on this list?
- jbold

said the same thing

What hair gel, and what midgets?
I didn't know you checked him out
- Jadass12

Leaf fan going to the "you're gay" card. Wow. Classy.

Based on what are they claiming these guys are overrated? Is there some master list of player rankings that they're comparing against or are they just pulling names out of their @ss? The only way I think you can rate a player is against his salary.

The list is a joke anyways.


Phaneuf,Komisarek,Gomez, Heatley are among names in that top 15..

When yet, almost everyone poops on them and have nothing good to say about them.

Pronger and Iggy over-rated? right...


Anyone look at the under-rated list? apparently Datsyuk and Giroux are under-rated.

Leaf fan going to the "you're gay" card. Wow. Classy.
- PassionBucket16

Why do you care about the guys hair?

explain the bolded ones please on how they are better then phaneuf
- matt1337

I agree also the fat boy because he sucks this year

Leaf fan going to the "you're gay" card. Wow. Classy.
- PassionBucket16

It's a joke relax, it just sounds like you have something against Phaneuf with your comment about his hair and midgets.

said the same thing
- wingz4life

If you're making that call for this season only, I'd agree. Otherwise disagree.

Based on what are they claiming these guys are overrated? Is there some master list of player rankings that they're comparing against or are they just pulling names out of their @ss? The only way I think you can rate a player is against his salary.
- AlexF

Playing hockey against them?

"And by the way? Anyone who wants to tell Dion that in person should fly to Ottawa in about two weeks," Burke added.


he's 6th among D men in points.

Disagree. From 1 year ago to the beginning of this year, he was excellent. He didn't start off well, I agree, but I'd take Myers on my team before Phaneuf. He cares more about hair gel and hitting midgets than being a winner.
- PassionBucket16

didn't know sauer at 6'3 213lbs was a midget? or nolan at 6'1 214lbs? or kopitar at 6'3 225lbs?