Id rather Dion over Komi.
- robin_steele264

That is long list of players I would rather have over Komi....a very long list.

i would have had bryzgalov or Mike Green

10 best d men right now
in no order
Karlsson
Weber
Chara
Yandle
Phaneuf
Byfuglien
Lindstrom
Keith
Seabrook
Letang

he is in the top ten for goals, helpers and points for d men right now

the all around game, is debatable

if he made 4 mil per year he would be an under rated d man
- homiedclown

off the top of my head id rather have Chara, Karlesson, Burns, Doughty, Myers, Keith, Weber...........thats off the top of my head, soem of those are probably debatable and I probably forgot some guys......but remember he didnt even make Team Canada in 2010

I read that in your last post.
- robin_steele264

I'm behind on reading through the pages...dont be angry.

10 best d men right now
in no order
Karlsson
Weber
Chara
Yandle
Phaneuf
Byfuglien
Lindstrom
Keith
Seabrook
Letang
- homiedclown

hard to argue this list

name them

I will make up my list as well, in no particular order of course
- homiedclown

No particular order.

Duncan Keith
Brent Seabrook
Zdeno Chara
Nik Lidstrom
Drew Doughty
Shea Weber
Kris Letang
Keith Yandle
Kimmo Timmonen
Erik Karlsson
Marc Staal
Tyler Myers

off the top of my head id rather have Chara, Karlesson, Burns, Doughty, Myers, Keith, Weber...........thats off the top of my head, soem of those are probably debatable and I probably forgot some guys......but remember he didnt even make Team Canada in 2010
- Homer

6th in points
- Fakepartofme

thats great, but a defensemens job isnt all about points

Name them.
- Fakepartofme

Hedman
Chara
Staal
Karlsson
Letang
Keith
Hjalmarsson
Lidstrom
Suter
Weber
Doughty
Streit
Bieksa
Edler
Seabrook

Purposely leaving Myers off to avoid incoming troll comments, it really wasnt hard to name 15 off the top of my head that i'd rather have or are basically interchangeable for Phaneuf

I'm behind on reading through the pages...dont be angry.
- Fakepartofme

too late my head just exploded.

- homiedclown

Right now, today...no....but when he's on, yes, IMO

off the top of my head id rather have Chara, Karlesson, Burns, Doughty, Myers, Keith, Weber...........thats off the top of my head, soem of those are probably debatable and I probably forgot some guys......but remember he didnt even make Team Canada in 2010
- Homer

hes only stepped his game back up recently

Hedman
Chara
Staal
Karlsson
Letang
Keith
Hjalmarsson
Lidstrom
Suter
Weber
Doughty
Streit
Bieksa
Edler
Seabrook

Purposely leaving Myers off to avoid incoming troll comments, it really wasnt hard to name 15 off the top of my head that i'd rather have or are basically interchangeable for Phaneuf
- robz228

You forgot Kaberle

Hedman
Chara
Staal
Karlsson
Letang
Keith
Hjalmarsson
Lidstrom
Suter
Weber
Doughty
Streit
Bieksa
Edler
Seabrook

Purposely leaving Myers off to avoid incoming troll comments, it really wasnt hard to name 15 off the top of my head that i'd rather have or are basically interchangeable for Phaneuf
- robz228

I'll give you Suter and Beiska

No particular order.

Duncan Keith
Brent Seabrook
Zdeno Chara
Nik Lidstrom
Drew Doughty
Shea Weber
Kris Letang
Keith Yandle
Kimmo Timmonen
Erik Karlsson
Marc Staal
Tyler Myers
- PassionBucket16

serious question, how can Myers even sniff the top 20?

he was lost on the ice more often then not in his last season and a half

this is not a fantasy keeper league, it's who are the ten best d men in the nhl right now

- homiedclown

The question is who I'd take. I just don't rate Phaneuf.

I'll give you Suter and Beiska
- Homer

after reading the others, i blatantly forgot Mike Green, too

Hedman
Chara
Staal
Karlsson
Letang
Keith
Hjalmarsson
Lidstrom
Suter
Weber
Doughty
Streit
Bieksa
Edler
Seabrook

Purposely leaving Myers off to avoid incoming troll comments, it really wasnt hard to name 15 off the top of my head that i'd rather have or are basically interchangeable for Phaneuf
- robz228

explain the bolded ones please on how they are better then phaneuf

off the top of my head id rather have Chara, Karlesson, Burns, Doughty, Myers, Keith, Weber...........thats off the top of my head, soem of those are probably debatable and I probably forgot some guys......but remember he didnt even make Team Canada in 2010
- Homer

He was having a bad year in 2010....I completely agreed with not having him on the team.
No one is saying he's the best dman in the league.....he's simply not overated...just overpaid.

Hedman
Chara
Staal
Karlsson
Letang
Keith
Hjalmarsson
Lidstrom
Suter
Weber
Doughty
Streit
Bieksa
Edler
Seabrook

Purposely leaving Myers off to avoid incoming troll comments, it really wasnt hard to name 15 off the top of my head that i'd rather have or are basically interchangeable for Phaneuf
- robz228

you named many that I was toying with and left off the list

what I found out was it was easy to come up with 6 better then him, and about 15 d men that are all around great players and it's a fine line between 7 and say 22

and myers is not on the cut nor should he be right now

I'll give you Suter and Beiska
- Homer

Id put Alex Pietrangelo on there...

No particular order.

Duncan Keith
Brent Seabrook
Zdeno Chara
Nik Lidstrom
Drew Doughty
Shea Weber
Kris Letang
Keith Yandle
Kimmo Timmonen
Erik Karlsson
Marc Staal
Tyler Myers
- PassionBucket16

Staal has played like 5 games this years, i cant put him on that list. I think Timmonen's best days are behind him. Lidtrsom is a once a generation guy, unreal.

I don't really care who's overrated, they either do their job or they don't.

It would certainly be interesting to know who and how many "overrated" players responded to this BS survey.

A special thanks goes out to those 163 anonymous players who have now lit a fire under Dion's a$$.

Here comes a 20G / 40A / 100PIM / +10 / 175 BKS / 30 PPP / 250 SOG season for Dion baby!!!... WOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOO!