Wanna blog? Start your own hockey blog with My HockeyBuzz. Register for free today!
 
Forums :: Blog World :: Trevor Shackles: Thursday Think Tank: Melnyk Selling?
Author Message
david22
Ottawa Senators
Joined: 04.15.2008

Jun 7 @ 12:14 PM ET
What's a better fit? Stone at 26, Hoffman at 28, with the Sens heading into (probably) a lengthy rebuild, or a 22-year old Sam Reinhart, a first round pick, pick #32 and a prospect?

Say it takes them 4 years to get back to contention - with no first next year - those guys are at or over 30. Reinhart would be 25, and that first round pick would be 22

- jcragcrumple


The no first next year kind of hurts this. It's harder to trade away those assets in order to rebuild knowing you'll give away such a good pick.

I actually think Rienhart get's an unfair amount of hate, but I dont't think this trade works.

The pick next year is interesting. But I think the addition of Stone and Hoffman will make that pick worth less than the Sens would want.
jcragcrumple
Buffalo Sabres
Location: Reluctant bridge jumper; 6th round OHL draft pick, YT
Joined: 04.04.2016

Jun 7 @ 12:16 PM ET
Okay, I will try to play along. Assuming those will be the lines:
??? Eichel Okposo
Nylander O'Reilly Reinhart
Rodrigues Mittelstadt Pominville
Moulson Larsson Baptiste

I would just stand pat and sign JVR (slight overpay because UFA but good player). Or a Vanek as stop gap. Reinhart + 1st would not get you Stone + Hoffman. Maybe Reinhart straight up for Hoffman would interest the Sens but then you still have an issue of an empty spot in the top 6.

If we would go Reinhart + 1st road for Hoffman + Stone we also would like a Mittelstadt or Nylander included, and I think that is a no go for the Sabres?

- DutchSenators


Nylander and pick #32 this year.

You have a deal.
Atomic Wedgie
Toronto Maple Leafs
Location: The centre of the hockey universe
Joined: 07.31.2006

Jun 7 @ 12:16 PM ET
Help a brother out here:

What's the current status of the proposed new arena in the Lebreton Flats area?

Thanks in advance.
spatso
Ottawa Senators
Location: jensen beach, FL
Joined: 02.19.2007

Jun 7 @ 12:22 PM ET
Help a brother out here:

What's the current status of the proposed new arena in the Lebreton Flats area?

Thanks in advance.

- Atomic Wedgie


Sens have approval to build subject to final design and financing.
david22
Ottawa Senators
Joined: 04.15.2008

Jun 7 @ 12:34 PM ET
Sens have approval to build subject to final design and financing.
- spatso


In another move of utilizing the Sens assets to maximize revenue, Melnuk was seen standing with a cup outside the nearest Queensway exit after the last event.
DutchSenators
Location: Ho Chi Minh City, Vietnam
Joined: 06.07.2015

Jun 7 @ 12:35 PM ET
Nylander and pick #32 this year.

You have a deal.

- jcragcrumple


You mean Reinhart, Nylander and #32 for Hoffman and Stone?
grim
Toronto Maple Leafs
Location: Ottawa, ON
Joined: 09.23.2006

Jun 7 @ 12:36 PM ET
I can buy the sale rumours, but making Alfie President of Hockey Ops would be a bad start. Unless Alfie is a incredibly quick learner, he is not qualified.
First thing first, get some new ownership.

- JACMAN


I agree with this 100%. My personal hatred for the guy aside, he was a tremendous on ice captain for this team and big part of the Sens identity. Melnyk aside, he claimed he wasn't interested in putting the hours and work in required to learn the business. Nor does he have anything close to the cash required to be a meaningful owner. If a 1% stake puts him in the "ownership group", whatever, call yourself an owner...

I sat beside him at some Ottawa Sting appreciation night about a month ago - disinterested, not particularly engaging, dare I say aloof.... Now I am sure he wasn't trying very hard that night, but as a Leaf fan, say PLEASE put him in charge...

Who do you think this guy is? Brendan Shanahan?

jaz258
Ottawa Senators
Location: Ottawa
Joined: 02.04.2008

Jun 7 @ 12:37 PM ET
There is no truth to the rumour that Melnyk has missed payroll. Utter nonsense.

There is no valid or credible mention of it anywhere on the internet other than a couple of goofballs posting vague mentions of it on twitter. Believing this story is like believing anything Donald Trump has to say.

Investors will be there for the Lebreton development, because Melnyk owns the rights to it as his group was the one selected. Anything being bandied about is just noise.

As for the validity of anything coming out of TSN, I would say look at their hyping of a Karlsson trade at the trade deadline. Nothing there. Dreger's insights come from his connections to a relative in the Leafs organization so if he were commenting on them, I would tend to believe it. As far as I have heard, he has no inside connections in the Ottawa Senators organization. Let's not forget that Karlsson has said he doesn't want to go. They will offer a contract and he will either sign or decline.

When I see a credible report that he is being aggressively shopped, then I will lend it some credence.
jcragcrumple
Buffalo Sabres
Location: Reluctant bridge jumper; 6th round OHL draft pick, YT
Joined: 04.04.2016

Jun 7 @ 1:33 PM ET
You mean Reinhart, Nylander and #32 for Hoffman and Stone?
- DutchSenators


2019 first, Reinhart, Nylander, 2018 pick #32

For

Stone and Hoffman
grim
Toronto Maple Leafs
Location: Ottawa, ON
Joined: 09.23.2006

Jun 7 @ 1:33 PM ET
There is no valid or credible mention of it anywhere on the internet other than a couple of goofballs posting vague mentions of it on twitter. Believing this story is like believing anything Donald Trump has to say.
- jaz258


HockeyBuzz described perfectly! Kudos!
GoodOldHockeyGame
Ottawa Senators
Location: Kanata, ON
Joined: 01.20.2007

Jun 7 @ 1:33 PM ET


are you giving Karlsson with that trash can Ryan to get your own pick back.

the 2019 Ott pick is worth so much with how much of a dumpster fire this team has been since they have made that trrade

- DDM-Coga
you really are nothing but a troll
Tumbleweed
Toronto Maple Leafs
Location: avid reader of the daily douche news
Joined: 03.14.2014

Jun 7 @ 1:47 PM ET
In another move of utilizing the Sens assets to maximize revenue, Melnuk was seen standing with a cup outside the nearest Queensway exit after the last event.
- david22

DDM-Coga
Colorado Avalanche
Location: If Chabot is not in the NHL, Ill revoke my account - AlfiesSald, AB
Joined: 07.24.2009

Jun 7 @ 1:49 PM ET
you really are nothing but a troll
- GoodOldHockeyGame


calling out bad hockey takes and trades is being a troll?

Karlsson for the 16th overall pick...anyone that says thats a bad trade is trolling, dont troll me Sens fans
Tumbleweed
Toronto Maple Leafs
Location: avid reader of the daily douche news
Joined: 03.14.2014

Jun 7 @ 1:50 PM ET
There is no truth to the rumour that Melnyk has missed payroll. Utter nonsense.

There is no valid or credible mention of it anywhere on the internet other than a couple of goofballs posting vague mentions of it on twitter. Believing this story is like believing anything Donald Trump has to say.

Investors will be there for the Lebreton development, because Melnyk owns the rights to it as his group was the one selected. Anything being bandied about is just noise.

As for the validity of anything coming out of TSN, I would say look at their hyping of a Karlsson trade at the trade deadline. Nothing there. Dreger's insights come from his connections to a relative in the Leafs organization so if he were commenting on them, I would tend to believe it. As far as I have heard, he has no inside connections in the Ottawa Senators organization. Let's not forget that Karlsson has said he doesn't want to go. They will offer a contract and he will either sign or decline.

When I see a credible report that he is being aggressively shopped, then I will lend it some credence.

- jaz258


The proof will be in the pudding when stone signs an offer sheet with a 7m signing bonus that the sens don't match.
Maverick1818
Ottawa Senators
Location: PEI
Joined: 02.06.2015

Jun 7 @ 2:07 PM ET
I've said on here multiple times but, Ottawa would be absolutely stupid to trade Hoffman. He is our best goal scorer on a good contract, our fastest skater and has amazing chemistry with Duchene.

If Ottawa trades Hoffman, we might as well trade Duchene too, because Duchene has openly said he wants to play on the same line as Hoffman

I should also add that I think if Karlsson isn't retained and/or Hoffman is traded.... PD should be fired on the spot
DutchSenators
Location: Ho Chi Minh City, Vietnam
Joined: 06.07.2015

Jun 7 @ 2:09 PM ET
2019 first, Reinhart, Nylander, 2018 pick #32

For

Stone and Hoffman

- jcragcrumple


I'd probably do that if we can't resign Karlsson.
david22
Ottawa Senators
Joined: 04.15.2008

Jun 7 @ 3:03 PM ET
The vultures are really circling, how many sens players are mentioned in other teams blogs, articles right now?
jaz258
Ottawa Senators
Location: Ottawa
Joined: 02.04.2008

Jun 7 @ 3:23 PM ET
The proof will be in the pudding when stone signs an offer sheet with a 7m signing bonus that the sens don't match.
- Tumbleweed


so I guess we play the waiting game then.....

I hate the waiting game, let's play Hungry Hungry Hippo's instead... (Simpson, Homer)
DutchSenators
Location: Ho Chi Minh City, Vietnam
Joined: 06.07.2015

Jun 7 @ 3:46 PM ET
The proof will be in the pudding when stone signs an offer sheet with a 7m signing bonus that the sens don't match.
- Tumbleweed


Well, then we get 4 1sts if it is 7 years or more. Would be great.
Tumbleweed
Toronto Maple Leafs
Location: avid reader of the daily douche news
Joined: 03.14.2014

Jun 7 @ 3:51 PM ET
so I guess we play the waiting game then.....

I hate the waiting game, let's play Hungry Hungry Hippo's instead... (Simpson, Homer)

- jaz258



Tumbleweed
Toronto Maple Leafs
Location: avid reader of the daily douche news
Joined: 03.14.2014

Jun 7 @ 3:55 PM ET
Well, then we get 4 1sts if it is 7 years or more. Would be great.
- DutchSenators


lol. nobody would be that dumb.

1 or 5 years.

1 year @ $8M is really the ticket. sens can't trade him for a year if they match.
david22
Ottawa Senators
Joined: 04.15.2008

Jun 7 @ 3:56 PM ET
lol. nobody would be that dumb.

1 or 5 years.

1 year @ $8M is really the ticket. sens can't trade him for a year if they match.

- Tumbleweed


Why would Stone ever do that?
DutchSenators
Location: Ho Chi Minh City, Vietnam
Joined: 06.07.2015

Jun 7 @ 3:56 PM ET
lol. nobody would be that dumb.

1 or 5 years.

1 year @ $8M is really the ticket. sens can't trade him for a year if they match.

- Tumbleweed


Stone is not that dumb to sign for 5 years now. Then he is 31 when he runs out of his contract. Better to go short or 7 years +
david22
Ottawa Senators
Joined: 04.15.2008

Jun 7 @ 4:03 PM ET
Stone is not that dumb to sign for 5 years now. Then he is 31 when he runs out of his contract. Better to go short or 7 years +
- DutchSenators


I don't see why he'd sign a short term offer sheet either. Too risky if he gets hurt.

. If he signs an offer sheet it'll be for lots of money long germ. [/img]
Tumbleweed
Toronto Maple Leafs
Location: avid reader of the daily douche news
Joined: 03.14.2014

Jun 7 @ 4:04 PM ET
Why would Stone ever do that?
- david22


why would he re-sign with this:

Page: Previous  1, 2, 3  Next