Or “stupid” because he called you that today in a post which I flagged btw.
- nyisles7

Both were brutal. Garth had more stable owners and Milbury probably would not have minded a couple of years of Malkin being owner. Garth rubbed me the wrong way more than Milbury.
- ses111

I agree Ses, I think Milbury had no money to work with. Especially in comparison to the last four years that Garth has had. I don’t think Milbury was great but I think Garth was worse.

Both were brutal. Garth had more stable owners and Milbury probably would not have minded a couple of years of Malkin being owner. Garth rubbed me the wrong way more than Milbury.
- ses111

I vote for Milbury as slightly worse. It's ok to lose a trade, but Milbury lost nearly EVERY trade.

- JimmyP

Bring it Biotch

I vote for Milbury as slightly worse. It's ok to lose a trade, but Milbury lost nearly EVERY trade.
- JohnScammo

Bring it Biotch
- nyisles7

Do you really think I'm upset you flagged BD?

I agree Ses, I think Milbury had no money to work with. Especially in comparison to the last four years that Garth has had. I don’t think Milbury was great but I think Garth was worse.
- nyisles7

Milbury had no money during the first 5 years. But Wang opened his wallet and told him to spend. So he spent $90 million on Alexei Yashin........and traded Chara, the 2nd overall pick (Spezza) and Bill Mukalt for the privilege.

Do you really think I'm upset you flagged BD?
- JimmyP

Of course not

Debateable. They are both complete opposites but equally as bad in their own right IMO.
- Cptmjl

As bad as Snow was, Milbury was 10 times worse. Milbury’s track record on trades alone makes him a bottom 3 GM of all time. Snow May have failed at a lot of things but he had a better track record drafting and making deals when he actually did.

That’s being said, simply because Snow was better than Milbury does not mean that he was a good GM. He was just a less smelly turd than Milbury was.

- nyisles7

Other than the Mike Peca and Jason Blake trades, name one other that Milbury won.

I agree Ses, I think Milbury had no money to work with. Especially in comparison to the last four years that Garth has had. I don’t think Milbury was great but I think Garth was worse.
- nyisles7

Milbury had to dump players to shed salary that Garth did not have to do. I hate to make it seem I'm making excuses for Milbury but he had it worse than Garth. Milbury had owners working against him while it was mostly Garth sinking himself.

Other than the Mike Peca and Jason Blake trades, name one other that Milbury won.
- JohnScammo

Bringing in Aucoin

Argh! I hate this debate! Would you rather be burned alive or fall off a cliff on to jagged rocks?

They were both (frank)ing horrible! Who cares which was worse.

I vote for Milbury as slightly worse. It's ok to lose a trade, but Milbury lost nearly EVERY trade.
- JohnScammo

Garth letting seasons die while doing nothing burns me more.

Bringing in Aucoin
- B.D. Gallof

Was he a free agent? Or did Milbury trade for him? I agree that Aucoin was a good pick up.

Argh! I hate this debate! Would you rather be burned alive or fall off a cliff on to jagged rocks?

They were both (frank)ing horrible! Who cares which was worse.
- JimmyP

Let's end this debate and back to chatting about how Lou will fix this team.

Let's end this debate and back to chatting about how Lou will fix this team.
- ses111

It's the Red Wing fan's fault. Just for that, I hope the Red Wings continue to stink.

Milbury had to dump players to shed salary that Garth did not have to do. I hate to make it seem I'm making excuses for Milbury but he had it worse than Garth. Milbury had owners working against him while it was mostly Garth sinking himself.
- ses111

I’ll never forget, Ziggy was due a new contract and I believe the Islanders Payroll was ~22 million at the time and the owners wanted him to cut the payroll under 20 million.

Bringing in Aucoin
- B.D. Gallof

Good one.

I’ll never forget, Ziggy was due a new contract and I believe the Islanders Payroll was ~22 million at the time and the owners wanted him to cut the payroll under 20 million.
- nyisles7

Sadly I remember this well. Hopefully these things are all the past now.

It's the Red Wing fan's fault. Just for that, I hope the Red Wings continue to stink.
- JohnScammo

First they steal Jimmy D and now they get us into this dopey vs dopey debate.

First they steal Jimmy D and now they get us into this dopey vs dopey debate.
- ses111

They deserve overpaying Frans Nielsen!

Sadly I remember this well. Hopefully these things are all the past now.
- ses111

I’m going to say seeing L and M come through with the rights to Belmont, bringing in Lou L and today firing Snow. I think this franchise is on the road to success and with that will come profitability

They deserve overpaying Frans Nielsen!
- JohnScammo

Yeah, he should have stayed here and then he would have been in the POs oh wait

Yeah, he should have stayed here and then he would have been in the POs oh wait
- nyisles7

Better to be on a worse team that misses the playoffs by an even wider margin!