I will, only because someone here used to post the ESPN Insider articles occasionally when I asked






1. Ownership's handling of the John Tavares situation.

There is plenty of blame to go around as the Islanders captain and cornerstone player heads into the offseason without a contract extension and begins to examine where he'd like to play the next seven or eight seasons. We'll start at the top.

From the time owner Scott Malkin invited Pat Brisson, Tavares' agent, to Barclays Center for the first of at least half a dozen meetings midway through the 2016-17 season, the negotiation — if you can call it that, since there have been no formal offers exchanged — has run through the highest level of the Islanders structure. GM Garth Snow (more on him to come) has a good relationship with both Tavares and Brisson, but Malkin and co-owner Jon Ledecky have been the point people with Tavares' agent for over a year now.

According to numerous sources around the league, it has been Malkin who kept Brisson and, by extension, Tavares, apprised of the arena situation as it unfolded towards the Dec. 20 announcement. Malkin brought Brisson along to meet with Gary Bettman last offseason and Malkin has continued to make trips to Brisson's office in Los Angeles.

So it's clear that ownership has given Tavares and his camp all the latitude from the time last offseason that Tavares told the Isles he wasn't interested in talking about an extension prior to this season — the Islanders acquiesced to Tavares' desire to not be traded and not talk contract at all throughout the year, even as the team tumbled down the standings.

Malkin and Ledecky also made personnel moves that they hoped would convince Tavares to stay. Retaining Snow last April, after Ledecky spoke to roughly 40 people around the league regarding a potential president of hockey operations job, and then making Doug Weight the full-time coach were moves made in part because of both men's relationships with Tavares.

Giving the captain all the leverage regarding his future was a risky strategy last offseason. Making decisions based on influencing Tavares to stay without knowing if he cared or not seems more than risky, it's reckless. The Islanders will still be an NHL franchise whether Tavares stays or goes, yet ownership attacked this situation as if he were the only one that mattered.

2. Garth Snow's handling of the Tavares situation — and so much more.

The GM has taken the brunt of the fans' dissatisfaction with this season and, after four playoff appearances in 12 seasons, Snow's seat has never been hotter. That's justified.

Even with his bosses taking the Tavares contract situation off his table, Snow's relationship with his captain could and should have prompted Snow to do more. He made two strong moves at the draft last June, acquiring Jordan Eberle for Ryan Strome and an unprotected first-rounder plus two seconds from the Flames for Travis Hamonic.

But the contracts Snow signed from June-December of 2016 — Casey Cizikas for five years at $3.35 million per, Andrew Ladd for seven years at $5.5 million, Jason Chimera for two years at $2.25 million and Cal Clutterbuck for five years at $3.5 million — have been huge misses. Chimera was dealt at the deadline for pending UFA Chris Wagner; those two combined for three goals this season.

And the breakdowns, offensively and physically, for the other three have been documented before. The Isles' bottom six forward group is clogged with overpaid, underperforming players, two of whom are on the wrong side of 30; that necessitated a strong approach to either shore up that bottom six with an acquisition or implore Malkin and Ledecky to set a timetable for a Tavares contract, either prior to the June draft or the trade deadline, to improve the roster in some way.

Now, Snow may lose his job or get kicked upstairs with only weeks to go before Tavares makes his choice. Doesn't seem worth it to have sat idly by during this season.

3. Tavares' handling of his own situation.

After 668 games and 620 points, Tavares has been the face of the Islanders ever since he arrived as the sure-fire first pick in 2009. Yes, a few members of the Isles' scouting staff wanted Matt Duchene, but Snow never wavered and all those employees who pushed for Duchene are now former employees. Just to set that record straight.

He has also, as Weight and many others have stated publicly, earned the right to call his shot entering free agency. What Tavares likely never expected when he informed the team of his decision to wait last offseason was that Malkin and company would give in to his every wish and then some. Never in team history has a player so thoroughly controlled his own destiny, as many of the dynasty-era Islanders can attest after they were traded or simply let go once they started to wear down.

Tavares got all he wished for: To take his time this season, not talk contract and not be traded. And here we are, with the team barreling towards the draft lottery once again.

For the captain to say it hasn't affected him or his team is bending the truth at best. He's got his second-highest point total of his career with a game to go, yet he hasn't been a force on possession or at even-strength — his five-on-five Corsi For percentage is 48.7, third-worst of his career (thanks to Natural Stat Trick for the numbers).

Worse still is, in his role as captain, he's the one who sets the tone. He can go to Weight or Snow if he sees something is hurting the team. The Islanders are 18-30-8 since Dec. 1 with the third-fewest points in the league in that span. Tavares could have gone to the coach, the GM or ownership at any time and said, “I've made up my mind.” He could have asked to talk contract and resolve this thing or told them all he's leaving and it's best to make a move to get something for him to allow the franchise he says has been so great to him to start building towards a future without No. 91.

Tavares made some big demands and they were all granted. If he walks away now and points the finger at poor ownership, a bad GM and lousy coaching, what does that say about him?

4. Weight's D-zone adjustment comes too late.

The Islanders started the season 15-7-2. All these months later, it's easy to point to the cracks that were already showing during that heady stretch, but in reality, the Isles were an above-average team in Corsi For percentage at 5v5 (50.6, 12th in the league) and had a .922 even-strength save percentage, which was 16th. They could have won plenty of games playing that way.

But December came, Calvin de Haan and then Johnny Boychuk went down with serious injuries and the Isles' man-on-man defensive-zone style became a mad scramble without two of their smartest and most senior defensemen. Weight seemed to feel his team could stick with the system and newer players could adjust quickly, but the breakdowns started coming everywhere — neutral zone, defensive zone, in goal.

And the coaching staff did not tweak the system until February. In that 10-week span when the Islanders struggled to regain their footing, they were the second-worst team in the league at 45.5 percent CF and gave up 1,031 5v5 shots on goal, 94 more than the next team. At all strengths, they allowed 38.2 shots on goal per game, two full SOG per game more than anyone else.

Also, they were losing — 12-18-4 in that stretch until Weight moved the D zone to more of a zone, allowing the defensemen's eyes to stay forward to find opposing players in soft spots in the slot. That hasn't fixed the whole losing games thing, but they stopped giving up shots and chances by the bushel.

5. No reinforcements on defense in December.

De Haan's major shoulder injury was known just about the minute he left the Barclays Center ice, howling in pain, after the Isles' 4-3 overtime win over the Kings on Dec. 16. Boychuk's nagging leg issues that forced him out from just after Christmas until Feb. 9 were also known then, as was Devon Toews' problematic shoulder that shut him down for the season in Bridgeport.

Toews would have been the call-up to replace Boychuk. Sebastian Aho performed ably in his stint in place of Toews, but does anyone think either of them could have stepped right into a leaking D corps and solidified things? That could only have been done by acquiring a steady veteran.

Cody Franson was also not likely The Answer, but he was an answer of some sort. The Hawks put Franson on waivers on Jan. 8, during the Isles' five-day break and just after a horrific five-game losing streak. Snow declined to put in a claim (as did every other team). Ian Cole was available from the Penguins; again, not the linchpin, but a steady veteran who could have provided a fresh set of eyes and legs to the team.

Cole ended up being swapped in the Derick Brassard deal, then Ottawa flipped him to Columbus for a low-level prospect and a third-rounder. Easily affordable, even if the in-division cost from the Pens was more like a second-rounder — the Isles have two of those in the 2019 draft.

We don't want to be accused of being part of the “do something, anything!” crowd. Those moves don't often make sense. But the Islanders had a huge need and they filled it with Dennis Seidenberg and a 21-year-old in his first North American season.

6. The Josh Ho-Sang conundrum.

Ho-Sang's season mirrored the Isles' season: When he was up, the Islanders were winning. When he was sent down, the losing began in earnest.

It's hard to say Ho-Sang was the main reason, since the defense issues and injuries were spelled out above. But he did provide a threat on the third line and for Brock Nelson, whose season has been low-impact, to say the least. Ho-Sang made mistakes, but that is his game: high-risk, high-reward.

It was much the same when Snow drafted Ho-Sang 28th overall four years ago. The Islanders knew what they were getting in Ho-Sang and he's been quite consistent since he arrived — very talented, very mercurial. Sending him down in December and leaving him there would perhaps teach a wayward player a lesson, but Ho-Sang is no ordinary player or person.

So setting such a hard line with him while the season went up in flames didn't make sense. If the Isles felt like Ho-Sang may never learn, why wouldn't you take advantage of the skill? And there's no use trotting out the “rules are for everyone” line. Different players have different rules and guidelines, even rookies. Ho-Sang is who he is and the Islanders failed to realize that or capitalize on it when their third and fourth lines were offering nothing but goals against in January and February.

Ho-Sang was playing through an injury in January, when Tanner Fritz got the call from Bridgeport. But he should've been up before then. Maybe if you're Weight and you feel you're not getting through to him, sit him out on occasion.

The Islanders needed Ho-Sang this season, problems and all.

7. Veterans on the decline.

The quartet of Islanders mentioned earlier (Ladd, Chimera, Clutterbuck, Cizikas) had serious scoring droughts that the team managed to get through the first half of the season. When the top-line guys started to revert to the mean on shooting percentage, the absence of offense — coupled with the absence of defense — from those four became a glaring weakness.

Ladd, who has two goals in his last 37 games, has put up decent underlying numbers. His CF% of 51.7 is third-best on the roster. But the other three — Chimera is headed to the playoffs with the Ducks, so he's free of this mess — were unable to provide much of anything positive on the fourth line through the majority of the season. None of those three had a CF% above 43.7.

Weight did sit out Chimera a few times before he was dealt on deadline day, but the others — and you can include Nelson in this list, despite him getting to 20 goals — continued to play. It makes sense, given that Weight didn't have many other options and even struggling, Ladd and Nelson were the best options for the third line.

But no matter who is making the decisions going forward, that person is going to need to see more from the third and fourth lines or make some changes.

8. The woeful penalty kill.

Cizikas and Clutterbuck could have justified those contracts by being stalwarts on the PK, as they had been in prior seasons. Tavares, added to the PK rotation last season, was supposed to that as well. But losing Nikolay Kulemin in November was a blow to that group, following by de Haan and Boychuk.

The Islanders killed off 82.4 percent of opposing power plays in 2016-17. With much the same personnel, skaters and goaltenders, plus the same coach in associate Greg Cronin, the Isles are at 73.5 percent entering Saturday's finale.

Once the roster takes shape by July, this is probably the biggest area to fix.

9. Too much leeway for Thomas Greiss.

No goaltender will escape this Islanders season unscathed. The numbers are truly atrocious — 3.6 goals against and an .898 save percentage — so Jaroslav Halak and Greiss are not assured of anything next season. Halak is a free agent and almost certainly headed elsewhere.

Greiss, however, earned a three-year extension last January at $3.3 million per. He will likely get the call on Saturday based solely on the years left on his deal. He managed to win half his starts despite recording an .899 even-strength save percentage, 49th of 50 goalies who made at least 25 appearances this season.

Greiss was struggling even before the Islanders really started to slide but the Isles were outscoring their problems. Once December hit, Greiss allowed at least four goals in 13 of 15 starts. Christopher Gibson did get the call in February when Greiss was out with a high ankle sprain, but in December or January the Isles could have summoned Gibson or made a move for a goaltender to simply change the makeup in goal.

Another reason for Snow to be proactive on the goaltender market during the season: If Greiss isn't the answer as a No. 1 and Halak won't be back, why not go out and find someone like the Wings' Jimmy Howard to come in? Howard has a year left on his deal. There's no guarantee anyone better will be available this offseason, when the Isles will only get 22-year-old Swede Linus Soderstrom into the organization. The answer in goal is still out there and now the Isles will be competing with a few other teams for the meager pickings.

10. No need for the kids?

Aho was a pleasant surprise when he came up at the end of December. His third NHL game was a memorable one, when he scored his only goal and set up Cal Clutterbuck for a late tying score in a shootout win on Jan. 7. His size (5-10, 170) was obviously an issue, but once the calendar flipped to March and the Islanders were losing often, Aho was in street clothes.

Aho was a healthy scratch in nine of the last 11 games before he was sent down on March 23. Given the injury issues with the Islanders and in Bridgeport, it's understandable that no other prospects got a call late in the season. But sitting Aho when the team might have needed to see more of what they have in the young defenseman is a head-scratcher.

11. The Isles' landlord can't even avoid blame.

Barclays Center CEO Brett Yormark was an eager salesman when the Islanders first moved to his arena, even if the team didn't always feel like first-class citizens with few games on weekends and bad ice. Malkin and Ledecky made it clear they were looking for other digs when they took over from Charles Wang. Finding a home at Belmont with the help of the MSG-backed Oak View Group meant the Isles would be direct competitors in a few years with Barclays Center and Nassau Coliseum, where the Isles will split their time the next three seasons in yet another unconventional and fan-unfriendly arrangement.

Yormark then decided to do a brief media tour in February bashing the Isles for “never really embracing Brooklyn.” That can't make things easy on Barclays/Nassau ticket operations — will the fans want to make the trek to Brooklyn for games the next three seasons when their host doesn't want them there?

12. Billboards go up, ownership goes silent.

Ledecky is a front-and-center sort of owner, roaming the corridors at Barclays Center during intermissions, riding the Long Island Rail Road to games with fans and generally willing to talk to anyone and everyone. But when the team fell off the map — and, coincidentally, the two billboards calling for Snow's removal went up in Brooklyn — Ledecky was nowhere to be found.

That's the right of any owner. It's Malkin's and Ledecky's team and they choose what to address and what not to address. But if you want the pats on the back for Belmont and for being so accessible, you can't disappear when times get tough.

Whether the owners intend to keep Snow as GM and/or president after the season ends is immaterial. When the fans are unhappy, it's time to step forward, difficult as that may be.

The lesson from such an incredible collapse should be obvious. Tavares may stay, he may go, but either way, this is a team in dire need of restoration. There needs to be a foundation of defensive hockey to go along with all the high flyers and big scorers. Plenty of other teams can pull that off, so it's not that farfetched to think the Islanders could do so.

But from ownership to management to coaching to star players to pluggers to goaltenders, the Islanders need some sort of attitude adjustment. Whatever they did this season can't be changed with a minor move here or there, or even with ping-pong balls bouncing their way at the draft lottery drawing on April 28.

This will take work. The Islanders got their biggest win in ages with Belmont; do they have what it takes to have a team worth seeing at that new arena three years from now?
- eichiefs9

Thanks you (frank)ing miser

My God
- Cptmjl

These 2 are dumber than we thought. To even consider bringing him back is insane. Bet they don't have the stones to pull the trigger.

Well Snow is responsible for the coaching staff and hired them so there's that so ultimately he did the worse job of all and has been for the last 11 years.
- Cptmjl

All true Cpt but we've known how bad Garth has been for years and this coaching staff had a chance to make things a little better.

It takes a heck of a lot to mess up the offensive season the Isles had. The job the coaching staff did was even worse than the job Garth did and that's saying something.
- ses111

I haven't watched enough of your games to have an opinion about the coaching, but with that offense, I would say this has to be the most disappointing season in a while.

I haven't watched enough of your games to have an opinion about the coaching, but with that offense, I would say this has to be the most disappointing season in a while.
- mdw7413

No question the most disappointing season in a long time. This coaching staff was bad and maybe worse than Cappy.

I will, only because someone here used to post the ESPN Insider articles occasionally when I asked




Other than the fans getting a chance to plead their case to John Tavares on Thursday night, the 2017-18 Islanders season is just about done — and it's one of the most disappointing seasons in a long while.

That's saying something for a franchise that has missed the playoffs nine of the last 13 seasons and 16 of the last 25.

There was the arrival of Mathew Barzal, a 15-7-2 start and a franchise-defining moment on Dec. 20, when the team was selected to build an arena at Belmont Park. This should have been a big year for the Islanders.

Instead, they will end the season Saturday in Detroit with many, many questions about the future — and about what derailed this team. Here are 12 instances, big and small, that turned this Islanders season into such a failure:

1. Ownership's handling of the John Tavares situation.

There is plenty of blame to go around as the Islanders captain and cornerstone player heads into the offseason without a contract extension and begins to examine where he'd like to play the next seven or eight seasons. We'll start at the top.

From the time owner Scott Malkin invited Pat Brisson, Tavares' agent, to Barclays Center for the first of at least half a dozen meetings midway through the 2016-17 season, the negotiation — if you can call it that, since there have been no formal offers exchanged — has run through the highest level of the Islanders structure. GM Garth Snow (more on him to come) has a good relationship with both Tavares and Brisson, but Malkin and co-owner Jon Ledecky have been the point people with Tavares' agent for over a year now.

According to numerous sources around the league, it has been Malkin who kept Brisson and, by extension, Tavares, apprised of the arena situation as it unfolded towards the Dec. 20 announcement. Malkin brought Brisson along to meet with Gary Bettman last offseason and Malkin has continued to make trips to Brisson's office in Los Angeles.

So it's clear that ownership has given Tavares and his camp all the latitude from the time last offseason that Tavares told the Isles he wasn't interested in talking about an extension prior to this season — the Islanders acquiesced to Tavares' desire to not be traded and not talk contract at all throughout the year, even as the team tumbled down the standings.

Malkin and Ledecky also made personnel moves that they hoped would convince Tavares to stay. Retaining Snow last April, after Ledecky spoke to roughly 40 people around the league regarding a potential president of hockey operations job, and then making Doug Weight the full-time coach were moves made in part because of both men's relationships with Tavares.

Giving the captain all the leverage regarding his future was a risky strategy last offseason. Making decisions based on influencing Tavares to stay without knowing if he cared or not seems more than risky, it's reckless. The Islanders will still be an NHL franchise whether Tavares stays or goes, yet ownership attacked this situation as if he were the only one that mattered.

2. Garth Snow's handling of the Tavares situation — and so much more.

The GM has taken the brunt of the fans' dissatisfaction with this season and, after four playoff appearances in 12 seasons, Snow's seat has never been hotter. That's justified.

Even with his bosses taking the Tavares contract situation off his table, Snow's relationship with his captain could and should have prompted Snow to do more. He made two strong moves at the draft last June, acquiring Jordan Eberle for Ryan Strome and an unprotected first-rounder plus two seconds from the Flames for Travis Hamonic.

But the contracts Snow signed from June-December of 2016 — Casey Cizikas for five years at $3.35 million per, Andrew Ladd for seven years at $5.5 million, Jason Chimera for two years at $2.25 million and Cal Clutterbuck for five years at $3.5 million — have been huge misses. Chimera was dealt at the deadline for pending UFA Chris Wagner; those two combined for three goals this season.

And the breakdowns, offensively and physically, for the other three have been documented before. The Isles' bottom six forward group is clogged with overpaid, underperforming players, two of whom are on the wrong side of 30; that necessitated a strong approach to either shore up that bottom six with an acquisition or implore Malkin and Ledecky to set a timetable for a Tavares contract, either prior to the June draft or the trade deadline, to improve the roster in some way.

Now, Snow may lose his job or get kicked upstairs with only weeks to go before Tavares makes his choice. Doesn't seem worth it to have sat idly by during this season.

3. Tavares' handling of his own situation.

After 668 games and 620 points, Tavares has been the face of the Islanders ever since he arrived as the sure-fire first pick in 2009. Yes, a few members of the Isles' scouting staff wanted Matt Duchene, but Snow never wavered and all those employees who pushed for Duchene are now former employees. Just to set that record straight.

He has also, as Weight and many others have stated publicly, earned the right to call his shot entering free agency. What Tavares likely never expected when he informed the team of his decision to wait last offseason was that Malkin and company would give in to his every wish and then some. Never in team history has a player so thoroughly controlled his own destiny, as many of the dynasty-era Islanders can attest after they were traded or simply let go once they started to wear down.

Tavares got all he wished for: To take his time this season, not talk contract and not be traded. And here we are, with the team barreling towards the draft lottery once again.

For the captain to say it hasn't affected him or his team is bending the truth at best. He's got his second-highest point total of his career with a game to go, yet he hasn't been a force on possession or at even-strength — his five-on-five Corsi For percentage is 48.7, third-worst of his career (thanks to Natural Stat Trick for the numbers).

Worse still is, in his role as captain, he's the one who sets the tone. He can go to Weight or Snow if he sees something is hurting the team. The Islanders are 18-30-8 since Dec. 1 with the third-fewest points in the league in that span. Tavares could have gone to the coach, the GM or ownership at any time and said, “I've made up my mind.” He could have asked to talk contract and resolve this thing or told them all he's leaving and it's best to make a move to get something for him to allow the franchise he says has been so great to him to start building towards a future without No. 91.

Tavares made some big demands and they were all granted. If he walks away now and points the finger at poor ownership, a bad GM and lousy coaching, what does that say about him?

4. Weight's D-zone adjustment comes too late.

The Islanders started the season 15-7-2. All these months later, it's easy to point to the cracks that were already showing during that heady stretch, but in reality, the Isles were an above-average team in Corsi For percentage at 5v5 (50.6, 12th in the league) and had a .922 even-strength save percentage, which was 16th. They could have won plenty of games playing that way.

But December came, Calvin de Haan and then Johnny Boychuk went down with serious injuries and the Isles' man-on-man defensive-zone style became a mad scramble without two of their smartest and most senior defensemen. Weight seemed to feel his team could stick with the system and newer players could adjust quickly, but the breakdowns started coming everywhere — neutral zone, defensive zone, in goal.

And the coaching staff did not tweak the system until February. In that 10-week span when the Islanders struggled to regain their footing, they were the second-worst team in the league at 45.5 percent CF and gave up 1,031 5v5 shots on goal, 94 more than the next team. At all strengths, they allowed 38.2 shots on goal per game, two full SOG per game more than anyone else.

Also, they were losing — 12-18-4 in that stretch until Weight moved the D zone to more of a zone, allowing the defensemen's eyes to stay forward to find opposing players in soft spots in the slot. That hasn't fixed the whole losing games thing, but they stopped giving up shots and chances by the bushel.

5. No reinforcements on defense in December.

De Haan's major shoulder injury was known just about the minute he left the Barclays Center ice, howling in pain, after the Isles' 4-3 overtime win over the Kings on Dec. 16. Boychuk's nagging leg issues that forced him out from just after Christmas until Feb. 9 were also known then, as was Devon Toews' problematic shoulder that shut him down for the season in Bridgeport.

Toews would have been the call-up to replace Boychuk. Sebastian Aho performed ably in his stint in place of Toews, but does anyone think either of them could have stepped right into a leaking D corps and solidified things? That could only have been done by acquiring a steady veteran.

Cody Franson was also not likely The Answer, but he was an answer of some sort. The Hawks put Franson on waivers on Jan. 8, during the Isles' five-day break and just after a horrific five-game losing streak. Snow declined to put in a claim (as did every other team). Ian Cole was available from the Penguins; again, not the linchpin, but a steady veteran who could have provided a fresh set of eyes and legs to the team.

Cole ended up being swapped in the Derick Brassard deal, then Ottawa flipped him to Columbus for a low-level prospect and a third-rounder. Easily affordable, even if the in-division cost from the Pens was more like a second-rounder — the Isles have two of those in the 2019 draft.

We don't want to be accused of being part of the “do something, anything!” crowd. Those moves don't often make sense. But the Islanders had a huge need and they filled it with Dennis Seidenberg and a 21-year-old in his first North American season.

6. The Josh Ho-Sang conundrum.

Ho-Sang's season mirrored the Isles' season: When he was up, the Islanders were winning. When he was sent down, the losing began in earnest.

It's hard to say Ho-Sang was the main reason, since the defense issues and injuries were spelled out above. But he did provide a threat on the third line and for Brock Nelson, whose season has been low-impact, to say the least. Ho-Sang made mistakes, but that is his game: high-risk, high-reward.

It was much the same when Snow drafted Ho-Sang 28th overall four years ago. The Islanders knew what they were getting in Ho-Sang and he's been quite consistent since he arrived — very talented, very mercurial. Sending him down in December and leaving him there would perhaps teach a wayward player a lesson, but Ho-Sang is no ordinary player or person.

So setting such a hard line with him while the season went up in flames didn't make sense. If the Isles felt like Ho-Sang may never learn, why wouldn't you take advantage of the skill? And there's no use trotting out the “rules are for everyone” line. Different players have different rules and guidelines, even rookies. Ho-Sang is who he is and the Islanders failed to realize that or capitalize on it when their third and fourth lines were offering nothing but goals against in January and February.

Ho-Sang was playing through an injury in January, when Tanner Fritz got the call from Bridgeport. But he should've been up before then. Maybe if you're Weight and you feel you're not getting through to him, sit him out on occasion.

The Islanders needed Ho-Sang this season, problems and all.

7. Veterans on the decline.

The quartet of Islanders mentioned earlier (Ladd, Chimera, Clutterbuck, Cizikas) had serious scoring droughts that the team managed to get through the first half of the season. When the top-line guys started to revert to the mean on shooting percentage, the absence of offense — coupled with the absence of defense — from those four became a glaring weakness.

Ladd, who has two goals in his last 37 games, has put up decent underlying numbers. His CF% of 51.7 is third-best on the roster. But the other three — Chimera is headed to the playoffs with the Ducks, so he's free of this mess — were unable to provide much of anything positive on the fourth line through the majority of the season. None of those three had a CF% above 43.7.

Weight did sit out Chimera a few times before he was dealt on deadline day, but the others — and you can include Nelson in this list, despite him getting to 20 goals — continued to play. It makes sense, given that Weight didn't have many other options and even struggling, Ladd and Nelson were the best options for the third line.

But no matter who is making the decisions going forward, that person is going to need to see more from the third and fourth lines or make some changes.

8. The woeful penalty kill.

Cizikas and Clutterbuck could have justified those contracts by being stalwarts on the PK, as they had been in prior seasons. Tavares, added to the PK rotation last season, was supposed to that as well. But losing Nikolay Kulemin in November was a blow to that group, following by de Haan and Boychuk.

The Islanders killed off 82.4 percent of opposing power plays in 2016-17. With much the same personnel, skaters and goaltenders, plus the same coach in associate Greg Cronin, the Isles are at 73.5 percent entering Saturday's finale.

Once the roster takes shape by July, this is probably the biggest area to fix.

9. Too much leeway for Thomas Greiss.

No goaltender will escape this Islanders season unscathed. The numbers are truly atrocious — 3.6 goals against and an .898 save percentage — so Jaroslav Halak and Greiss are not assured of anything next season. Halak is a free agent and almost certainly headed elsewhere.

Greiss, however, earned a three-year extension last January at $3.3 million per. He will likely get the call on Saturday based solely on the years left on his deal. He managed to win half his starts despite recording an .899 even-strength save percentage, 49th of 50 goalies who made at least 25 appearances this season.

Greiss was struggling even before the Islanders really started to slide but the Isles were outscoring their problems. Once December hit, Greiss allowed at least four goals in 13 of 15 starts. Christopher Gibson did get the call in February when Greiss was out with a high ankle sprain, but in December or January the Isles could have summoned Gibson or made a move for a goaltender to simply change the makeup in goal.

Another reason for Snow to be proactive on the goaltender market during the season: If Greiss isn't the answer as a No. 1 and Halak won't be back, why not go out and find someone like the Wings' Jimmy Howard to come in? Howard has a year left on his deal. There's no guarantee anyone better will be available this offseason, when the Isles will only get 22-year-old Swede Linus Soderstrom into the organization. The answer in goal is still out there and now the Isles will be competing with a few other teams for the meager pickings.

10. No need for the kids?

Aho was a pleasant surprise when he came up at the end of December. His third NHL game was a memorable one, when he scored his only goal and set up Cal Clutterbuck for a late tying score in a shootout win on Jan. 7. His size (5-10, 170) was obviously an issue, but once the calendar flipped to March and the Islanders were losing often, Aho was in street clothes.

Aho was a healthy scratch in nine of the last 11 games before he was sent down on March 23. Given the injury issues with the Islanders and in Bridgeport, it's understandable that no other prospects got a call late in the season. But sitting Aho when the team might have needed to see more of what they have in the young defenseman is a head-scratcher.

11. The Isles' landlord can't even avoid blame.

Barclays Center CEO Brett Yormark was an eager salesman when the Islanders first moved to his arena, even if the team didn't always feel like first-class citizens with few games on weekends and bad ice. Malkin and Ledecky made it clear they were looking for other digs when they took over from Charles Wang. Finding a home at Belmont with the help of the MSG-backed Oak View Group meant the Isles would be direct competitors in a few years with Barclays Center and Nassau Coliseum, where the Isles will split their time the next three seasons in yet another unconventional and fan-unfriendly arrangement.

Yormark then decided to do a brief media tour in February bashing the Isles for “never really embracing Brooklyn.” That can't make things easy on Barclays/Nassau ticket operations — will the fans want to make the trek to Brooklyn for games the next three seasons when their host doesn't want them there?

12. Billboards go up, ownership goes silent.

Ledecky is a front-and-center sort of owner, roaming the corridors at Barclays Center during intermissions, riding the Long Island Rail Road to games with fans and generally willing to talk to anyone and everyone. But when the team fell off the map — and, coincidentally, the two billboards calling for Snow's removal went up in Brooklyn — Ledecky was nowhere to be found.

That's the right of any owner. It's Malkin's and Ledecky's team and they choose what to address and what not to address. But if you want the pats on the back for Belmont and for being so accessible, you can't disappear when times get tough.

Whether the owners intend to keep Snow as GM and/or president after the season ends is immaterial. When the fans are unhappy, it's time to step forward, difficult as that may be.

The lesson from such an incredible collapse should be obvious. Tavares may stay, he may go, but either way, this is a team in dire need of restoration. There needs to be a foundation of defensive hockey to go along with all the high flyers and big scorers. Plenty of other teams can pull that off, so it's not that farfetched to think the Islanders could do so.

But from ownership to management to coaching to star players to pluggers to goaltenders, the Islanders need some sort of attitude adjustment. Whatever they did this season can't be changed with a minor move here or there, or even with ping-pong balls bouncing their way at the draft lottery drawing on April 28.

This will take work. The Islanders got their biggest win in ages with Belmont; do they have what it takes to have a team worth seeing at that new arena three years from now?
- eichiefs9

Thanks chief! Art can make some good points when he is not trying to protect Garth. His comments about JT were spot on. JT could have done more and is not an innocent party.

Thanks chief! Art can make some good points when he is not trying to protect Garth. His comments about JT were spot on. JT could have done more and is not an innocent party.
- ses111

Its funny to see writers biases though. He admits defense, goaltending and the PK were basically the biggest issues, but then goes on to whine about Ho-Sang. Ho-Sang does not help any of the three major issues so its really a dumb argument.

It would take some stones for L&M to bring back Garth. It's one thing to have billboard go up about the GM, but fans will turn towards the owners when they have the power to make real changes.
- ses111

Keeping Snow would be easy for them. No stones required. I would be shocked (yet absolutely thrilled) if they shit-canned Snow. Here's my reasoning. When things were going ok and it was raining unicorns and gum drops, Ledecky was all over the place. Once it went south, he went invisible. He didn't want to hear anything negative because he can't handle it. Therefore, in order to can Snow, he'd have to put on his really big boy pants and dial up some cajones. Which I don't think he has. I think he is hoping that Snow does something so egregious that he essentially fires himself.

Its funny to see writers biases though. He admits defense, goaltending and the PK were basically the biggest issues, but then goes on to whine about Ho-Sang. Ho-Sang does not help any of the three major issues so its really a dumb argument.
- mdw7413

Yeah but in a round-about way it's him reverting to his Garth protection mode.

Keeping Snow would be easy for them. No stones required. I would be shocked (yet absolutely thrilled) if they shit-canned Snow. Here's my reasoning. When things were going ok and it was raining unicorns and gum drops, Ledecky was all over the place. Once it went south, he went invisible. He didn't want to hear anything negative because he can't handle it. Therefore, in order to can Snow, he'd have to put on his really big boy pants and dial up some cajones. Which I don't think he has. I think he is hoping that Snow does something so egregious that he essentially fires himself.
- Isleshockeyman

If Ledecky does not want to hear anything negative, how will he feel about seeing negative billboards about himself? This is a new day and people have no issue protesting and L&M have to worry about their wallets. This is not the old days before the internet.when fans could be easily ignored. At the very least, a POHO needs to be hired. Anything short of that and it will not be a fun offseason for L&M.

Its funny to see writers biases though. He admits defense, goaltending and the PK were basically the biggest issues, but then goes on to whine about Ho-Sang. Ho-Sang does not help any of the three major issues so its really a dumb argument.
- mdw7413

Ho Sang was another example though of poor development. Ho Sang has issues but the 3rd line was better with him.

Its funny to see writers biases though. He admits defense, goaltending and the PK were basically the biggest issues, but then goes on to whine about Ho-Sang. Ho-Sang does not help any of the three major issues so its really a dumb argument.
- mdw7413

His point was that it was moronic that they kept calling up talentless assrockets like Fritz and Johnston when there was a perfectly suitable player sitting in the minors. They knew the type of player and person they drafted. He's high-risk, high-reward and he's probably never going to change. Either deal with it adapt or admit that you knowingly drafted a player that would never fit what you were looking for. But leaving someone that could have helped down in the minors makes them look pretty stupid.

Yeah but in a round-about way it's him reverting to his Garth protection mode.
- Isleshockeyman

I mean you can make the argument he should have been up to get experience, maybe JT could have mentored him a little, etc. but to say it would have changed anything for the season is certainly reaching

I mean you are 7th and offense and last in defense by a pretty good margin.

Thanks chief! Art can make some good points when he is not trying to protect Garth. His comments about JT were spot on. JT could have done more and is not an innocent party.
- ses111

The "kicking him upstairs" comment when referring to moving Snow to a possible full time president position is super concerning to me. Swallow whatever Snow is owed from the moron contract extension Wang gave him. Give me a break guys you're spending hundreds of millions on a new arena get rid of this guy he's only hurting your investment it's beyond moronic.

His point was that it was moronic that they kept calling up talentless assrockets like Fritz and Johnston when there was a perfectly suitable player sitting in the minors. They knew the type of player and person they drafted. He's high-risk, high-reward and he's probably never going to change. Either deal with it adapt or admit that you knowingly drafted a player that would never fit what you were looking for. But leaving someone that could have helped down in the minors makes them look pretty stupid.
- eichiefs9

I thought it was a season review and what would have helped the team be better. Thats how I looked at it.

Again, not saying he shouldn't have been with the club, but it wouldn't have changed anything.

The "kicking him upstairs" comment when referring to moving Snow to a possible full time president position is super concerning to me. Swallow whatever Snow is owed from the moron contract extension Wang gave him. Give me a break guys you're spending hundreds of millions on a new arena get rid of this guy he's only hurting your investment it's beyond moronic.
- Cptmjl

I agree Garth should be totally gone. If Garth stays I'm going to start to believe Wang put it in the contract that Garth cannot be fired for a certain amount of time. Nothing else makes sense.

The "kicking him upstairs" comment when referring to moving Snow to a possible full time president position is super concerning to me. Swallow whatever Snow is owed from the moron contract extension Wang gave him. Give me a break guys you're spending hundreds of millions on a new arena get rid of this guy he's only hurting your investment it's beyond moronic.
- Cptmjl

Agree. The only place I want Snow kicked to is a deep hole to the center of the earth. Where the mole people will relentlessly torture and torment him an eternity.

I thought it was a season review and what would have helped the team be better. Thats how I looked at it.

Again, not saying he shouldn't have been with the club, but it wouldn't have changed anything.
- mdw7413

The title of the article was "Breaking down the 12 mistakes that doomed the Islanders season"

No, it most likely wouldn't have changed anything. But what he hell is the point of having an NHL team if you're not going to try and ice the best roster every night? Ho Sang would have made them a more talented team than Fritz or Johnston did...end of story. I'm not debating whether or not Ho Sang is mature/coachable/deserving of a demotion/etc..., but he wouldn't have made the team defensive issues any worse and he likely would have made the third line a more viable scoring option.

I don't think there's anyone out there that would blame their bad season on Ho Sang's absence, but it was still unfathomably stupid to flex their muscles and banish him to the minors all year trying to make him play like someone he isn't.

I agree Garth should be totally gone. If Garth stays I'm going to start to believe Wang put it in the contract that Garth cannot be fired for a certain amount of time. Nothing else makes sense.
- ses111

I've already said that if Snow is the GM at the beginning of the season, I'm done. Might watch a portion of an occasional game. I'll keep tabs of course, and to the dislike of many, I'll still drop in here.

The title of the article was "Breaking down the 12 mistakes that doomed the Islanders season"

No, it most likely wouldn't have changed anything. But what he hell is the point of having an NHL team if you're not going to try and ice the best roster every night? Ho Sang would have made them a more talented team than Fritz or Johnston did...end of story. I'm not debating whether or not Ho Sang is mature/coachable/deserving of a demotion/etc..., but he wouldn't have made the team defensive issues any worse and he likely would have made the third line a more viable scoring option.

I don't think there's anyone out there that would blame their bad season on Ho Sang's absence, but it was still unfathomably stupid to flex their muscles and banish him to the minors all year trying to make him play like someone he isn't.
- eichiefs9

Hmmm. Snow handled JHS with his ego. Never would have guessed that he would do something like that. Seems a bit on the familiar side. Sort of like what that idiot pulled last year with Halak.

The title of the article was "Breaking down the 12 mistakes that doomed the Islanders season"

No, it most likely wouldn't have changed anything. But what he hell is the point of having an NHL team if you're not going to try and ice the best roster every night? Ho Sang would have made them a more talented team than Fritz or Johnston did...end of story. I'm not debating whether or not Ho Sang is mature/coachable/deserving of a demotion/etc..., but he wouldn't have made the team defensive issues any worse and he likely would have made the third line a more viable scoring option.

I don't think there's anyone out there that would blame their bad season on Ho Sang's absence, but it was still unfathomably stupid to flex their muscles and banish him to the minors all year trying to make him play like someone he isn't.
- eichiefs9

and also so completely expected and typical of the islanders coaching staff and management.

Hmmm. Snow handled JHS with his ego. Never would have guessed that he would do something like that. Seems a bit on the familiar side. Sort of like what that idiot pulled last year with Halak.
- Isleshockeyman

That's what I can't figure out. They knew exactly what/who Ho Sang was before, during, and after the draft. They knew he'd be a player that wasn't capable of playing both sides of the puck. They knew he was a quirky weirdo with an oddball mindset. But here we are, a few years in, and they're fighting tooth and nail to force him to be something he isn't and they're only shooting themselves in the foot for it. Either let him do his thing or get rid of him, but having a pissing contest with him helps nobody. This isn't much different than Nino's situation and it'll probably end the same.

Hmmm. Snow handled JHS with his ego. Never would have guessed that he would do something like that. Seems a bit on the familiar side. Sort of like what that idiot pulled last year with Halak.
- Isleshockeyman

Nino, Rolasson, and every other player that has donned an Islander sweater and didn't win the popularity contest.

and also so completely expected and typical of the islanders coaching staff and management.
- Cptmjl

Nin2.o

I've already said that if Snow is the GM at the beginning of the season, I'm done. Might watch a portion of an occasional game. I'll keep tabs of course, and to the dislike of many, I'll still drop in here.
- Isleshockeyman

HB would not be the same without IHM.

I'll still watch the games but no going to see them and no buying Isles merchandise. I'll be first in giving money for more billboards though.