Should Nelson be traded for RNH?

Should Nelson be traded for RNH?
- bgainesDM

For me No. hope that doesn't insult you.

For me No. hope that doesn't insult you.
- nyisles7

Numbnutz

Numbnutz
- Upstate_isles

you Ass!

Fellas would it help a JT signing if center support was made. That pressure wasn't put on Barzal and he was traded out. Would Sutter help the cause? The boys on Canucks thread were wondering.

Fellas would it help a JT signing if center support was made. That pressure wasn't put on Barzal and he was traded out. Would Sutter help the cause? The boys on Canucks thread were wondering.
- Nuck4U

Um, what?

Um, what?
- PeteM

Would it make the team better now, help JT to sign, if you traded Barzal for Sutter?

Personally I don't care. It was brought up in Canucks thread and I'd thought I'd get a poll response.

Would it make the team better now, help JT to sign, if you traded Barzal for Sutter?

Personally I don't care. It was brought up in Canucks thread and I'd thought I'd get a poll response.
- Nuck4U

That's a trade that is heavily in Vacouver's favor. Whoever suggested that is crazy. Hard pass on that.

Would it make the team better now, help JT to sign, if you traded Barzal for Sutter?

Personally I don't care. It was brought up in Canucks thread and I'd thought I'd get a poll response.
- Nuck4U

Yeah, tell whomever originated that trade proposal to put the bong down. Not even plausible.

Yeah, tell whomever originated that trade proposal to put the bong down. Not even plausible.
- Isleshockeyman

On top of all the other reasons this trade makes no sense (for the Islanders), Sutter has a no trade clause.

https://www.capfriendly.com/players/brandon-sutter

On top of all the other reasons this trade makes no sense (for the Islanders), Sutter has a no trade clause.

https://www.capfriendly.com/players/brandon-sutter
- JohnScammo

Maybe he's the one player that doesn't have the Islanders on his no trade list.

Maybe he's the one player that doesn't have the Islanders on his no trade list.


- JimmyP

Doubt it.

http://www.thehockeynews.com/news/article/the-15-nhl-teams-that-won-t-make-the-playoffs-in-2017-18
- Cptmjl

That paragraph was wayyyyy to long. All it needed was the sentence: "Garth Snow still GM. 'Nuff said."

JT to Nashville for Ellis Craig smith and a first round draft pick
E6

Should Nelson be traded for RNH?
- bgainesDM

No because then we'd be weak at LW
If we can keep nelson and get a 2C we would have a great forward group.

Would it make the team better now, help JT to sign, if you traded Barzal for Sutter?

Personally I don't care. It was brought up in Canucks thread and I'd thought I'd get a poll response.
- Nuck4U

Wow that's something else. Are you serious?

Should Nelson be traded for RNH?
- bgainesDM

I'm a no. Nelson has size, still has more upside and is a 25+goal scorer. Unless we use him to get Duchene he will be our #2 center this year and top 5 point getter.

Bailey Nelson Ho Sang will be our #2 line this year. JHS is plenty creative and a passer. RNH iseems too fragile, (always hurt)

http://www.thehockeynews.com/news/article/the-15-nhl-teams-that-won-t-make-the-playoffs-in-2017-18
- Cptmjl

no words

no words

- batteryjackson

But if we got rnh we would have a alternate left wing or an alt left wing and Trump would love the isles we do have jhs so maybe not. This is a joke people I know everyone has gone full blown idiot recently

I bet San Jose could afford him, does he like to surf?
- mgriffen

...you do realize people surf here, right?

E2 he's going to be a Ranger. Not sure which contract they will lose but he's going to Broadway.

Heard it here first folks, yibidy yibidy.................

But if we got rnh we would have a alternate left wing or an alt left wing and Trump would love the isles we do have jhs so maybe not. This is a joke people I know everyone has gone full blown idiot recently
- Upstate_isles

So the reason he hasn't signed yet ( Said by JT himself ) is there is no stability on where the organization will be playing in 2 years and also the state of the franchise as far as moving in the right direction so that JT can honestly compete for the cup with this team and that, is the 5% that is keeping him from Signing?

I'ld love to know what reasons make up the other 95% thats making him stay.
- nyisles7

Deli Egg Sandwiches and Adventureland

No because then we'd be weak at LW
If we can keep nelson and get a 2C we would have a great forward group.
- Danformo

Umm, as it stands, Nelson is the 2c. He's a center, not a LW. Not sure how they'd be weak at LW by trading Nelson.

Deli Egg Sandwiches and Adventureland
- Dedshark

That'd do it.