Only if Lydman is with him
- GERBE!!!75PTS

He was good with Sultzer too

I was going to start watching "GOT" Because of the dark Phoenix and Aquaman
But way too many seasons to catch up on lol
- GERBE!!!75PTS

Do it

He was good with Sultzer too
- jcragcrumple

But he was epic with Lydman

But soup wins hands down that's the type of defenseman we need back there now

does soupy make the list of 6 best d men all time?


shoenny
van boxmer
hajt
ramsey
housley
horton
campbell
korab
risto
guevremont
mckee
smehlik


that's my top 12 in no particular order

is soupy top 6 on that list?
- homiedclown

I think he's top 6 Sabres defense all-time. That hit in the Winter Classic that he absorbed and went airborne on will forever make me happy. But if we assemble an all Sabres team of who's who in their prime, he is for sure in the top 6.

I think he's top 6 Sabres defense all-time. That hit in the Winter Classic that he absorbed and went airborne on will forever make me happy. But if we assemble an all Sabres team of who's who in their prime, he is for sure in the top 6.
- BeadyEyedDouche

As of 2010 I had

Schoenfeld/Ramsey
Hajt/Housley
McKee/Korab

Soupy


It may change, but I still like it as laid out

Do it
- chilliard77

Too Many seasons lol

I still Believe we get rid of one of those guys
😥😥🤢🤢🤢🤢

I'm going to be super depressed if we don't trade for a top Winger
- GERBE!!!75PTS[/img]

Who would you like to see them bring in? Most teams that have top 6 wingers to move want dmen in return, which we don't have extra of. I would have thought if another winger was going to be added Jbotts would have looked into Eberle and Johansen (SP).
Id love to see another top 6 LW to play with Jack, just don't see how it happens, with the assets we are most likely to offer.

Too Many seasons lol
- GERBE!!!75PTS

Man up

Only 10 episodes per season

I would take prime Tallinder over Campbell

*ducks*
- jcragcrumple

i feel like the justification for this is similar to the one about girardi deserving more norris votes than Karlsson a few years ago.

does soupy make the list of 6 best d men all time?


shoenny
van boxmer
hajt
ramsey
housley
horton
campbell
korab
risto
guevremont
mckee
smehlik


that's my top 12 in no particular order

is soupy top 6 on that list?
- homiedclown

Risto over Teppo?

where is broad side of the barn Kalinin

Man up

Only 10 episodes per season
- chilliard77

Maybe on a sick day

i feel like the justification for this is similar to the one about girardi deserving more norris votes than Karlsson a few years ago.
- Sabresfan-365

Attaboy

(This does not mean I think Giarardi is good.)

Attaboy

(This does not mean I think Giarardi is good.)
- Der Kaiser

i protest. No mention of kulikov or any of my other usuals.

I liked tallinder but i just dont see a scenario where he'd even be in the same tier as campbell.

Maybe on a sick day
- GERBE!!!75PTS

You only get sick days when you work.

You're a millnial, so you cant possibly really work, therefore you're not entitled to any sick days.

i protest. No mention of kulikov or any of my other usuals.

I liked tallinder but i just dont see a scenario where he'd even be in the same tier as campbell.
- Sabresfan-365

There are still things called defensive defenseman.

Risto over Teppo?

where is broad side of the barn Kalinin
- IndianaSabresFan

Teppo was good for 1 season and the rest of his career here was meh (obviously the heart problems didnt help that). The last year he was unbelievably slow

Who would you like to see them bring in? Most teams that have top 6 wingers to move want dmen in return, which we don't have extra of. I would have thought if another winger was going to be added Jbotts would have looked into Eberle and Johansen (SP).
Id love to see another top 6 LW to play with Jack, just don't see how it happens, with the assets we are most likely to offer.
- Sabres1523

I don't know what winger he will bring in but the gm is very crafty can't really win games when you can't score goals ..

And Jack sets up people with a perfect dime but they cant score

There are still things called defensive defenseman.
- Der Kaiser

was tallinder ever that good defensively that would make him as good as or better than campbell?

i protest. No mention of kulikov or any of my other usuals.

I liked tallinder but i just dont see a scenario where he'd even be in the same tier as campbell.
- Sabresfan-365

My argument would be that Campbell wasn't even top pair here. Lydman and Tallinder were 1-2

You only get sick days when you work.

You're a millnial, so you cant possibly really work, therefore you're not entitled to any sick days.
- Der Kaiser

I work but only on my time

My argument would be that Campbell wasn't even top pair here. Lydman and Tallinder were 1-2
- jcragcrumple

Campbell saw more ice time than them (at least in 06-07 and 07-08)

I work but only on my time
- GERBE!!!75PTS

jesus christ thats the most millennial thing ive ever read

I work but only on my time
- GERBE!!!75PTS

That's not called work

Campbell saw more ice time than them (at least in 06-07 and 07-08)
- Sabresfan-365

He averaged 30 seconds more a game than Tallinder bc he played more PP time but Tallinder/Lydman were the workhorse pair

jesus christ thats the most millennial thing ive ever read
- Sabresfan-365