How are Dionne, Ciccarelli, and Gartner winners? They have no rings. Dionne's teams never even made it out of the 2nd round.
- DeflatedPucks

Might want to research that and get back.

Also, good work spending an hr finding 3 who didn't agree with your argument. 2 of which went past the 2nd rd.

Don't know about the Hawks missing the Playoffs, but they do have the worst fans in hockey

- Ovechkin's scoring in the lowest scoring era makes him the greatest scorer ever. His career high in the year he did it is possibly the single greatest scoring season in NHL history.

- Donald Trump is not "my boy"

- I can't win a Pulitzer beacuse I'm Canadian.

- The Canadians win/loss record (no advanced stats) would likely make them a lottery team if we ignore their crazy October.
- James_Tanner

October is part of the hockey season, you just can't remove it from the records just to try and make your point.

Might want to research that and get back.

Also, good work spending an hr finding 3 who didn't agree with your argument. 2 of which went past the 2nd rd.
- FLflames34

Good job taking "half an hour" to do your research and respond to my post.

All of them also know how to win.

I think you should understand the definition of "winning" before you put out any more arguments.

Good job taking "half an hour" to do your research and respond to my post.



I think you should understand the definition of "winning" before you put out any more arguments.
- DeflatedPucks

They are all in the HOF. That is winning. Dino especially was close to the final. Out of....14 15 names I listed?

Sorry I proved you incorrect and you feel sad about it. That is life.

Still waiting for your list, which will never come. Let us hope McDavid is at the top.

They are all in the HOF. That is winning. Dino especially was close to the final. Out of....14 15 names I listed?

Sorry I proved you incorrect and you feel sad about it. That is life.

Still waiting for your list, which will never come. Let us hope McDavid is at the top.
- FLflames34

Ovechkin will be in the HOF, or do you doubt that?

Please cite where exactly you request a list from me. I will wait.

All of them also know how to win

Please don't embarass yourself further.

Ovechkin will be in the HOF, or do you doubt that?

Please cite where exactly you request a list from me. I will wait.



Please don't embarass yourself further.
- DeflatedPucks

Pretty simple broski. Top 10 pure goal scorers.

Try to keep Oilers to a minimum.

Pretty simple broski. Top 10 pure goal scorers.

Try to keep Oilers to a minimum.
- FLflames34

So now your list is the top 10 pure goal scorers? Its is laughable that Orr, Shanahan, Ciccarelli and Jagr are even included.

Delete your account

So now your list is the top 10 pure goal scorers? Its is laughable that Orr, Shanahan, Ciccarelli and Jagr are even included.

Delete your account
- DeflatedPucks

Agreed.

Pretty simple broski. Top 10 pure goal scorers.

Try to keep Oilers to a minimum.
- FLflames34

I would consider to include Bure in that group...

So now your list is the top 10 pure goal scorers? Its is laughable that Orr, Shanahan, Ciccarelli and Jagr are even included.

Delete your account
- DeflatedPucks

You must be 18.

Good job on the list btw.

I would consider to include Bure in that group...
- 21peter

Yeah that was my bad. Agreed on that.

You must be 18.

Good job on the list btw.
- FLflames34

It's ok to admit you're wrong. Just don't forget to delete your account.

It's ok to admit you're wrong. Just don't forget to delete your account.
- DeflatedPucks

Waiting for your list. Your arguments are nothing until you offer it.

Waiting for your list. Your arguments are nothing until you offer it.
- FLflames34

A list is not going to change your mentality that:

1. Orr, Shanahan, and Ciccarelli are top 10 pure goal scorers

2. Dionne, Gartner, and Ciccarelli are 'winners'

A list is not going to change your mentality that:

1. Orr, Shanahan, and Ciccarelli are top 10 pure goal scorers

2. Dionne, Gartner, and Ciccarelli are 'winners'


- DeflatedPucks

Orr was the first pure offensive dman and was absolutely a goal scorer. Sorry. Stopped at that.

Don't know about the Hawks missing the Playoffs, but they do have the worst fans in hockey

- Ovechkin's scoring in the lowest scoring era makes him the greatest scorer ever. His career high in the year he did it is possibly the single greatest scoring season in NHL history.

- Donald Trump is not "my boy"

- I can't win a Pulitzer beacuse I'm Canadian.

- The Canadians win/loss record (no advanced stats) would likely make them a lottery team if we ignore their crazy October.
- James_Tanner

That's exactly right. You "don't know". You don't know about ANYTHING, to be more specific.

Can't even find the decency to admit you're wrong because that's how salty you are about their success. Watching their fans spread across the nation all the way to Arizona as they flood the Yotes home games, having to deal with their popularity right in your face, as it slowly eats away at you. So you'd rather bash their fan base out of jealously and frustration, as if its the fans fault their team has achieved such success. Lord knows what you'll do if they win another Cup this year.

Orr was the first pure offensive dman and was absolutely a goal scorer. Sorry. Stopped at that.
- FLflames34

I stopped at

All of them also know how to win.

(and since you've singled out Orr, why not tell us why Shanahan is one of top 10 pure goal scorers in nhl history)

[quote=DeflatedPucks]
Still no list. Why is it so difficult for you?

And basic arithmetic and reading would result in it being more than 10 ppl and an off the cuff paper scratch and not definitive.

Your game is strong with memes and 1 line answers. Much worse with any substantive rebuttals.

Still no list. Why is it so difficult for you?

And basic arithmetic and reading would result in it being more than 10 ppl and an off the cuff paper scratch and not definitive.

Your game is strong with memes and 1 line answers. Much worse with any substantive rebuttals.
- FLflames34

All of them also know how to win.

Top 10 pure goal scorers.

Would you like to embarrass yourself further? Any other outrageous claims?

MINUS: If I can find any empathy for a millionaire jock who lives a lifestyle the likes of which I can only wish to one day emulate, it's for Taylor Hall.

He should be in Edmonton co-leading the Oilers to the Playoffs with the scariest 1-2-3 punch in the NHL (McDavid, Hall, Draisaitl) and instead he's in New Jersey.

Taylor Hall is the best player in the NHL no one knows about. He has the career stats to make put him among the elite of the elite, and......Peter Chiarelli is truly the worst.
- James_Tanner

You might be the dumbest blogger in hockeybuzz history

You might be the dumbest blogger in hockeybuzz history
- Reveen.

That's high praise.

Would you like to embarrass yourself further? Any other outrageous claims?
- DeflatedPucks

It is absolutely astounding that you have still offered no list. Instead it is one liners.

I've already noted who I believe the best pure goal scorer to be. Instead, you like to cycle round to antagonist.

For all you type, there is no substance. For all I knew, you were Whip's ghost.

It is absolutely astounding that you have still offered no list. Instead it is one liners.

I've already noted who I believe the best pure goal scorer to be. Instead, you like to cycle round to antagonist.

For all you type, there is no substance. For all I knew, you were Whip's ghost.
- FLflames34

Anyone who mentions Brendan Shanahan as a top ten all-time pure goal scorer should not be taken seriously.

Kindly, delete your account.

That's high praise.
- James_Tanner

I mean you just surpassed Richard Cloutier and that's quite a feat. You do realize that Chiarelli will be in contention for GM of the year and yet you call him terrible.

There is no way Hall and his ego could co-exist with McDavid.

Anyone who mentions Brendan Shanahan as a top ten all-time pure goal scorer should not be taken seriously.

Kindly, delete your account.
- DeflatedPucks

Arithmetic. Go back. Do it. Counting is hard.