so it's alright to criticize Hunwick, Polak, Martin and Marincin, but not to do same with Nylander?
Please explain to me how this works.
- MaximusAurelius

Each of those players has played multiple seasons in the NHL

so it's alright to criticize Hunwick, Polak, Martin and Marincin, but not to do same with Nylander?
Please explain to me how this works.
- MaximusAurelius

if you put Willie into the same category as those guys you need to roll smaller joints

If Nylander gets to the 55+ points he is on pace for he is in this group or 19-21yo who have done that...there are a few who didnt play enough games that would have also (Toews) but ya

Kane
Backstrom
Ryan
Duchene
Skinner
Couture
Mackinnon
Gaudreau
Forsberg
Eichel

He is really good
- senstroll

Irrelevant. Max doesn't like him, so he sucks.

so it's alright to criticize Hunwick, Polak, Martin and Marincin, but not to do same with Nylander?
Please explain to me how this works.
- MaximusAurelius

It's alright to criticise everyone.

so it's alright to criticize Hunwick, Polak, Martin and Marincin, but not to do same with Nylander?
Please explain to me how this works.
- MaximusAurelius

Nylander good

Hunwick, Polak, Marincin bad

Understand ?

if you put Willie into the same category as those guys you need to roll smaller joints
- jimi james

It's alright to criticise everyone.
- 1979AD

Except St. Marner

It's alright to criticise everyone.
- 1979AD

It's also alright to disagree

If Nylander gets to the 55+ points he is on pace for he is in this group or 19-21yo who have done that...there are a few who didnt play enough games that would have also (Toews) but ya

Kane
Backstrom
Ryan
Duchene
Skinner
Couture
Mackinnon
Gaudreau
Forsberg
Eichel

He is really good
- senstroll

I appreciate you at least having a normal discussion on this, without getting all defensive.
None of those guys actually plaed on a (PP) line with Matthews.
And although I agree Nylander is a good player, I think he's not great - and therefor should be traded for help on D.

It's also alright to disagree
- Santo_44

if you put Willie into the same category as those guys you need to roll smaller joints
- jimi james

not my fault you can't follow

Except St. Marner
- Steven_Seagull

He needs to fix his grill.

Nylander good

Hunwick, Polak, Marincin bad

Understand ?
- Santo_44

ME CHEW ROCKS!! ROCK TASTY!!

I appreciate you at least having a normal discussion on this, without getting all defensive.
None of those guys actually plaed on a (PP) line with Matthews.
And although I agree Nylander is a good player, I think he's not great - and therefor should be traded for help on D.
- MaximusAurelius

Awwww poor Backstrom had to play with Ovechkin.

It's also alright to disagree
- Santo_44

No, it's not.

Edit: oh - look, I guess it is!

I appreciate you at least having a normal discussion on this, without getting all defensive.
None of those guys actually plaed on a (PP) line with Matthews.
And although I agree Nylander is a good player, I think he's not great - and therefor should be traded for help on D.
- MaximusAurelius

Reaaalllly Max?

Kane - Toews/Hossa
Backstrom - Ovi
Ryan - Getz/Perry
Duchene - Mackinnon
Skinner - Staal
Couture - Thornton/Marleau
Mackinnon - Duchene
Gaudreau -
Forsberg -
Eichel - Garth

ME CHEW ROCKS!! ROCK TASTY!!
- twiztedmike

Little known fact. Babcock isn't vigorously chewing gum on the bench. He's chewing handfuls of gravel.

Reaaalllly Max?

Kane - Toews/Hossa
Backstrom - Ovi
Ryan - Getz/Perry
Duchene - Mackinnon
Skinner - Staal
Couture - Thornton/Marleau
Mackinnon - Duchene
Gaudreau -
Forsberg -
Eichel - Garth
- markmark

Reaaalllly Max?

Kane - Toews/Hossa
Backstrom - Ovi
Ryan - Getz/Perry
Duchene - Mackinnon
Skinner - Staal
Couture - Thornton/Marleau
Mackinnon - Duchene
Gaudreau -
Forsberg -
Eichel - Garth
- markmark

I Gaudreau and Forsberg are the most impressive in this list. Producing like that without linemates is mindblowing.

Reaaalllly Max?

Kane - Toews/Hossa
Backstrom - Ovi
Ryan - Getz/Perry
Duchene - Mackinnon
Skinner - Staal
Couture - Thornton/Marleau
Mackinnon - Duchene
Gaudreau -
Forsberg -
Eichel - Garth
- markmark

So what you're saying is Gaudreau and Forsberg are scrubs

ME CHEW ROCKS!! ROCK TASTY!!
- twiztedmike

You're actually Polak?

So what you're saying is Gaudreau and Forsberg are scrubs
- TheMussel

I mean... I guess Ribeiro and Monahan

You're actually Polak?
- Steven_Seagull

yassssssss

I mean... I guess Ribeiro and Monahan
- markmark

In their rookie seasons? Monahan at least

yassssssss
- twiztedmike

I criticize you anonymously from behind my computer screen because I think there are better hockey players than you, and no I'm not one of them.

Chew on them rocks, Polak!