I know that's the narrative a lot of folks jump on but has there been a Blues goalie that fans criticized unfairly when it was all said and done?
(Hoping you'll say Jaro Halak)
The team as a whole is playing poorly, that's not in dispute. But Elliot was dealt to give Allen the job cut and dried and he has had a very poor half season. He doesn't appear to be injured, and he's extremely athletic, we've seen that from him in the past.
So his troubles are totally and completely resting between his ears.
If he were hot, the team in front of him would be better and more confident whereas the team could play extremely well in front of him and he would still (and does) give up bad goals.
- bcallaway
Elliott?
Elliott wasn't dealt to give Allen the job. Elliott wanted to be the starter. The Blues rightfully said nope. They were happy giving them both time this year and they both played well enough to play regularly based on last year.
Allen was given his deal after Elliott requested a trade, and was then traded. At that point, the Blues decided they wanted to lock up Allen long term, which was the right call at the time.