can't believe there is a blog on most underrated dman and not one post mentioning Dion Phaneuf.

can't believe there is a blog on most underrated dman and not one post mentioning Dion Phaneuf.
- prock

How bout that matt Carle huh?

Seriously? McDonagh is pretty highly regarded around the league and in the media.

If anyone, I think Klein is fairly underrated.
- Rinosaur

I'd say RD went a little overboard with nominating all three of those guys, but personally, I've never heard anyone other than Rangers fans talk about McD. He may not be on the level of the truly elite defensemen in the league, but he certainly belongs in the next echelon.
Klein has easily been New York's worst Dman this season. Not sure what's up there, because he was a great pick up to this point, but there's been a big drop off.

Toby. Enstrom.
Total homer pick.