I'd be fine with either of them going... just seems wrong to have both of them on the roster. My attachment to McQuaid is that he's played for a while with Krug, and they seem to pair pretty well together. I think Krug deserves (aka has earned) a better partner though.
If they could make a move, I'd feel a whole lot better with something along these lines:
Chara - Shattenkirk
Krug - Carlo
K Miller/C Miller/Morrow/McQuaid (whoever's left over)
(also think of the marketing possibilities of a Miller/Miller bottom pairing... If I close my eyes, I can already see the "ITS MILLER TIME" t-shirts outside of the Garden.)
- mixturebill
I see that vendor everyday with his stupid Win or Lose we still booze shirts/ I want to kick him in the stomach and burn those shirts.