Unless 1st round picks Ryan Hartman or even McNeill turn out to be an adequate replacement, Shaw's loss will hurt big time. It isn't the pure hockey skill he brought to the team as much as the fibre.
But I always remember what Bill Torrey said about managing the Islanders at the end of their glory era - purely out of loyalty he waited too long to move out players he could have gotten good returns for and then they all got old together.
- RickJ
From what I hear from those who watch this stuff closely...Hartman has to get a lot smarter and learn to control his emotions. Otherwise any comparison to Shaw will be short lived.