No. I said something like Draisitl Yakupov Kassian for McD and Fast. Maybe they can add a little. Maybe a pick or something.
- nyrangers9479

I'll pass man if I'm dealing McDonagh I want Seguin or Hall or Gaudreau or Tarasenko. McDonagh is a sure thing so we need to get a bonafide sure thing back.

I'll pass man if I'm dealing McDonagh I want Seguin or Hall or Gaudreau or Tarasenko. McDonagh is a sure thing so we need to get a bonafide sure thing back.
- rangerdanger94

I think Draisitl can be just as good. Taking a chance on Yakupov and I think Kassian could be a great 4th liner for us. Maybe add a 2nd or something.

Miller Stepan Kreider
Buchnevich Draisitl Nash
Zucc Hayes Yakupov
C.Stewart Helm Kassian

No one thinks that looks good?

I think Draisitl can be just as good. Taking a chance on Yakupov and I think Kassian could be a great 4th liner for us. Maybe add a 2nd or something.
- nyrangers9479

That is the key though. If you are trading McDonagh on a great contract you better replace "I think" with a player that "Is already great"

That is the key though. If you are trading McDonagh on a great contract you better replace "I think" with a player that "Is already great"
- TPC

That's why you should trade him for Kadri

That's why you should trade him for Kadri
- smellmyfinger

Tanner would, thats for sure. Probably cost McDonagh and a 1st to get him

Miller Stepan Kreider
Buchnevich Draisitl Nash
Zucc Hayes Yakupov
C.Stewart Helm Kassian

No one thinks that looks good?
- nyrangers9479

Dude, tht's WAY too much turnover in 1 yr. No idea if Buch is gonna make any impact this year to make him top 6. Yak is an enigma & EDMONTON STILL WANTS THE FARM for him. I don't know why your so down on Mac. I just can't see the Rangers trading away another Captain within 3 years of dealing away Cally mid season.

Dude, tht's WAY too much turnover in 1 yr. No idea if Buch is gonna make any impact this year to make him top 6. Yak is an enigma & EDMONTON STILL WANTS THE FARM for him. I don't know why your so down on Mac. I just can't see the Rangers trading away another Captain within 3 years of dealing away Cally mid season.
- B2B76

This is what people aren't getting. I'm not down on McD. . . I see an opportunity to strengthen this team but in order to do that we need to trade 1 of our best players.

I think Draisitl can be just as good. Taking a chance on Yakupov and I think Kassian could be a great 4th liner for us. Maybe add a 2nd or something.
- nyrangers9479

He can be but I'm not taking that risk. McDonagh already IS the real deal. You don't trade the real deal in his prime for a "probably".

You want Draisatl, then give them a package around Skjei. But McDonagh? No way.

He can be but I'm not taking that risk. McDonagh already IS the real deal. You don't trade the real deal in his prime for a "probably".

You want Draisatl, then give them a package around Skjei. But McDonagh? No way.
- rangerdanger94

I think the last thing we need is making another package. We need a package in return for once. Look how it worked out with Gaborik.

I think the last thing we need is making another package. We need a package in return for once. Look how it worked out with Gaborik.
- nyrangers9479

We're both too stubborn to change our opinions so let's just agree to disagree

We're both too stubborn to change our opinions so let's just agree to disagree
- rangerdanger94

we can debate all we want about whether or not it's a good idea to trade Ryan McDonagh, but, ultimately, does anyone really believe the Rangers would actually trade Ryan McDonagh? because I certainly don't

we can debate all we want about whether or not it's a good idea to trade Ryan McDonagh, but, ultimately, does anyone really believe the Rangers would actually trade Ryan McDonagh? because I certainly don't
- jimbro83

Something something Wayne Gretzky was traded something something

I tell you, Edmonton would be wise to trade Leon Draisaitl now to someone. That guy blew it up stats wise in October and November and then completely died. 7 points after March 1st.

we can debate all we want about whether or not it's a good idea to trade Ryan McDonagh, but, ultimately, does anyone really believe the Rangers would actually trade Ryan McDonagh? because I certainly don't
- jimbro83

The way the defense was for awhile last year, no, not a chance.

Lets just assume our defense was really good, and every defenseman we had was playing great. Would you think about a Taylor Hall for McDonagh if the offense was awful?

we can debate all we want about whether or not it's a good idea to trade Ryan McDonagh, but, ultimately, does anyone really believe the Rangers would actually trade Ryan McDonagh? because I certainly don't
- jimbro83

We just need to get to the offseason. 99.9% of all these roster ideas people have won't happen. Its dumb to argue about lol

We just need to get to the offseason. 99.9% of all these roster ideas people have won't happen. Its dumb to argue about lol
- TPC

Meh, you guys are just miserable (frank)s with delicate sensibilities. It gives something to talk about during the long wait till next year.

Meh, you guys are just miserable (frank)s with delicate sensibilities. It gives something to talk about during the long wait till next year.
- mdw7413

I don't mind throwing ideas out there but there is no point in arguing. Neither person is going to be right

The way the defense was for awhile last year, no, not a chance.

Lets just assume our defense was really good, and every defenseman we had was playing great. Would you think about a Taylor Hall for McDonagh if the offense was awful?
- mdw7413

if the Rangers re-signed Yandle and traded McDonagh straight up for Taylor Hall i'd probably do some dancin'

but, I don't think they are trading Mac

We just need to get to the offseason. 99.9% of all these roster ideas people have won't happen. Its dumb to argue about lol
- TPC

You mean you can't trade contracts no one wants, and clear cap space, add young superstars, trade your captain and all veteran leadership and keep morale up all in one offseason? Liar.

I don't mind throwing ideas out there but there is no point in arguing. Neither person is going to be right
- TPC

I'm always right......

if the Rangers re-signed Yandle and traded McDonagh straight up for Taylor Hall i'd probably do some dancin'

but, I don't think they are trading Mac
- jimbro83

Obviously, just a hypothetical.

I'm always right......
- mdw7413

Obviously, just a hypothetical.
- mdw7413

You're a hypothetical

- smellmyfinger