Why? Panarin's PPG were just shy of 1 in 80 games and McD's were just north of 1 in 45 games. McD didn't even play long enough to hit the rookie wall so odds are his pace would have declined a at least a little bit had played closer to a full season.
- Snowblind

Speculation... "Rookie wall."

Come on, dude, we both know who the more talented player is and he's also five years younger. Again, McDavid's GP costs him the award.

Im just waiting for Garth's Eichel got screwed/conspiracy blog about this lol
- lplafrance

was lots of great rookie talent this year.

that may not go over well with oilers fans... they have already had the fittings for the 3 stanley cup rings they are going to win
- derm10

Don't confuse us with the Leafs and their new dynamic duo of Stamkos / Matthews

The award isn't given to who is thought to be the best player; it is given to the player that had the best season, who is clearly Panarin.
- Snowblind

I've never argued that Connor unequivocally deserves the award. Stop arguing what isn't being argued. Jesus, you troll the oilers when there's nothing to troll


If the voters wanna give the award for more games played, I have no real issue as I know who the best rookie is beyond any shadow of a doubt. And I know Connor runs away with it if he plays 60. But he didn't. Oh well then I guess

Speculation... "Rookie wall."

Come on, dude, we both know who the more talented player is and he's also five years younger. Again, McDavid's GP costs him the award.
- As_I_See_It

playing the games he had missed and not performing would have cost him the award also.....alot of what if's

that may not go over well with oilers fans... they have already had the fittings for the 3 stanley cup rings they are going to win
- derm10

Says who?
When ?


Link?



You've never been good at this game. But at least you won't give up. Props for that I guess

Don't confuse us with the Leafs and their new dynamic duo of Stamkos / Matthews
- LittleRickyV2

was just remembering threads of the last 3-5 years

Says who?
When ?


Link?



You've never been good at this game. But at least you won't give up. Props for that I guess
- Ihateallofu

you are seriously going to try and argue that oilers fans haven't been claiming dynasty for the last couple years?

Speculation... "Rookie wall."

Come on, dude, we both know who the more talented player is and he's also five years younger. Again, McDavid's GP costs him the award.
- As_I_See_It

But the "rookie wall" something something

Just give it to someone else so the haters go away ...

Says who?
When ?


Link?



You've never been good at this game. But at least you won't give up. Props for that I guess
- Ihateallofu

i'll leave it to u to disprove me

playing the games he had missed and not performing would have cost him the award also.....alot of what if's
- derm10

what if your mom had swallowed ?

you are seriously going to try and argue that oilers fans haven't been claiming dynasty for the last couple years?
- derm10

Forget dynasty, Show me a link to an oiler fan even saying for sure playoffs this year. Just one


Even show me an oiler beat writer saying as such


K, go

Mcdavid should win the calder imo.

mcdavid 19 years old
Gostisbehere 23 years old
Panarin 24 years old

I get that ghost and Panarin are technically rookies but if they are that good at 19 in the nhl its a different story.

Let's see where mcdavid is in 4-5 years. Age has be a factor.

i'll leave it to u to disprove me
- derm10

It doesn't work this wAy, You made the claim. Not me


You're so bad at this

Forget dynasty, Show me a link to an oiler fan even saying for sure playoffs this year. Just one


Even show me an oiler beat writer saying as such


K, go
- Ihateallofu

i let u disprove me... not worth my time......
i'll ask u this then?
what is in store for the oilers next year? playoffs?

Why do you guys even bother trying to discuss anything with derp10?

You chodes should actually watch McDavid play... actually you Leaf turds should know just how good he is seeing as he not only torched your team for five points in one game but Leaf nation collectively lost their poop when the Leafs didn't win the lottery.
- LittleRickyV2

McDavid is from my home (frank)ing town. I GUARANTEE that knew about and watched McDavid YEARS before you did!

Mcdavid should win the calder imo.

mcdavid 19 years old
Gostisbehere 23 years old
Panarin 24 years old

I get that ghost and Panarin are technically rookies but if they are that good at 19 in the nhl its a different story.

Let's see where mcdavid is in 4-5 years. Age has be a factor.
- bryant

competing for hart trophies.

Mcdavid should win the calder imo.

mcdavid 19 years old
Gostisbehere 23 years old
Panarin 24 years old

I get that ghost and Panarin are technically rookies but if they are that good at 19 in the nhl its a different story.

Let's see where mcdavid is in 4-5 years. Age has be a factor.
- bryant

The award is for the best player under 25 years old in their first NHL season. Beyond that, age is irrelevant to the award. No one is debating who the best player will be in the years to come.

competing for hart trophies.
- derm10

Mcdavid wins based on age. Could those guys do what mcdavid did at 18-19 years old in the nhl?

i let u disprove me... not worth my time......
i'll ask u this then?
what is in store for the oilers next year? playoffs?
- derm10

I don't need to cause the evidence isn't there. That's the proof.

That's why you need to back your claim up to show otherwise
Wow


Dunno, depends on what they do this summer

The award is for the best player under 25 years old in their first NHL season. Beyond that, age is irrelevant to the award. No one is debating who the best player will be in the years to come.
- Snowblind

There is a huge age gap though. We're not talking 6 months or a year. These guys are 4/5 years older.

McDavid is from my home (frank)ing town. I GUARANTEE that knew about and watched McDavid YEARS before you did!
- As_I_See_It

That wasn't really directed at you as much as it was the other turd nuggets.

That wasn't really directed at you as much as it was the other turd nuggets.
- LittleRickyV2

Alright, carry on.

You chodes should actually watch McDavid play... actually you Leaf turds should know just how good he is seeing as he not only torched your team for five points in one game but Leaf nation collectively lost their poop when the Leafs didn't win the lottery.
- LittleRickyV2

Leafs don't make turd. They're inanimate.