Just a curious question, Would you rather see Toronto pick 1st or Edmonton once again?
- Flynox

Ugghh...is there a none of the above option?

You can get the equivalent of Hall all over the NHL for far less than a top 2
Hell, JVR for 2 3's or something
- hubie

Not so sure about that. He's probably a top 5 winger in the league

Not so sure about that. He's probably a top 5 winger in the league
- sbroads24

WHo knows what they wil do in this rebuild

Just a curious question, Would you rather see Toronto pick 1st or Edmonton once again?
- Flynox

Edmonton. Screw the Leafs . Let them pick 5th

They can keep him than, Hall is fine player but he is also playing with a bunch of #1 overall talents and his stats are 80gp, 25g, 36A, 61pts and has his team in dead last AGAIN!!! We have four 20+ goal scores already on our team, I would love to have Hall but his production is not elite by any stretch of the imagination.
- sskkoo1

Hall - Eichel I think Hall is our plan B if we don't get Stamkos, Murray mentioned before that Eichels' winger is not on the team at the moment, I hope he does something big.

What if Edmonton offered TM Hall for the '16 1st, Guhle, and Pysyk??

They can keep him than, Hall is fine player but he is also playing with a bunch of #1 overall talents and his stats are 80gp, 25g, 36A, 61pts and has his team in dead last AGAIN!!! We have four 20+ goal scores already on our team, I would love to have Hall but his production is not elite by any stretch of the imagination.
- sskkoo1

Agree. Folks a couple pages back scoffing at bogo, Larsson + , then saying the convo for hall starts with risto and a first ....unbelievable.

What if Edmonton offered TM Hall for the '16 1st, Guhle, and Pysyk??
- Deuce81

I wouldnt lose my sheet and start spelling things wrong and get a ban. But I wouldnt be over joyed as well. All assuming we stay around 7th pick

You can get the equivalent of Hall all over the NHL for far less than a top 2
Hell, JVR for 2 3's or something
- hubie

Jvr would cost quite a bit more than 2 3rds. They value him, and should value him, more than Kessel.

What if Edmonton offered TM Hall for the '16 1st, Guhle, and Pysyk??
- Deuce81

Until we make the playoffs, our firsts should be off limits imo, or at least until draft order is established.

Jvr would cost quite a bit more than 2 3rds. They value him, and should value him, more than Kessel.
- Mentalorgasm5

for a 1 time 30 goal scorer? OK, who else

Just a curious question, Would you rather see Toronto pick 1st or Edmonton once again?
- Flynox

Toronto. Hands down. Seeing Matthews vs Eichel for the next 10 years would be great!

People on here like to over value our assets, 7th Pick in this years draft won't help us next year, How long is Murray going to wait around for prospects to develop? He wants the team to be able to compete for a playoff spot next year with Eichel and Reinhart on their rookie deals, in that case he needs a Top 2 Defensemen or top 6 Winger to play with Eichel, and Bogo / Larsson will not get you Hall.

What if Edmonton offered TM Hall for the '16 1st, Guhle, and Pysyk??
- Deuce81

This would be a big surprise.

I'd take it and run.

It's a better deal than Kane for Myers, Armia and Lemieux.

What if Edmonton offered TM Hall for the '16 1st, Guhle, and Pysyk??
- Deuce81

Ask them where to sign and get the fax in beofre that crack wheres off.

They can keep him than, Hall is fine player but he is also playing with a bunch of #1 overall talents and his stats are 80gp, 25g, 36A, 61pts and has his team in dead last AGAIN!!! We have four 20+ goal scores already on our team, I would love to have Hall but his production is not elite by any stretch of the imagination.
- sskkoo1

It kind of is.

4th in the league in even strength points
14th in the league in points per 60 min

Ask them where to sign and get the fax in beofre that crack wheres off.
- CoHo_to_B-Lo

Agree. Folks a couple pages back scoffing at bogo, Larsson + , then saying the convo for hall starts with risto and a first ....unbelievable.
- LandlordTom

If a knock on Taylor Hall is that "He hasn't won them anything" then does that reduce Ristolainen's value as well?

If a knock on Taylor Hall is that "He hasn't won them anything" then does that reduce Ristolainen's value as well?
- sbroads24

Hall is BY FAR the better player, but Risto plays a position that is much harder to find top end talent.

Hall is BY FAR the better player, but Risto plays a position that is much harder to find top end talent.
- CoHo_to_B-Lo

I get that, I just hate the "He never won" argument. It's not like we got a locker room full of winners here

I get that, I just hate the "He never won" argument. It's not like we got a locker room full of winners here
- sbroads24

We have EXACTLY 0 winners in the locker room.

If a knock on Taylor Hall is that "He hasn't won them anything" then does that reduce Ristolainen's value as well?
- sbroads24

risto is more valuable to us than hall is to Edmonton...I agree with Kaiser that we are not good trade partners.

We have EXACTLY 0 winners in the locker room.
- CoHo_to_B-Lo

We could trade for Pat Lafontaine, Cam Neely, Pavel Bure, Eric Lindros, Marcel Dionne, and Alex Ovechkin, all in the primes, and still have 0 winners.

It's a crap argument.

We could trade for Pat Lafontaine, Cam Neely, Pavel Bure, and Alex Ovechkin, all in the primes, and still have ) winners.

It's a crap argument.
- Der Kaiser

I wasn't arguing...

We have EXACTLY 0 winners in the locker room.
- CoHo_to_B-Lo

False