Kovalev - worse free agent signings have been made. There was demand from fans for such a move.
Heatley - I believe that Heatley became an arse after the contract signing. Murray would have been lynched if he let him go.
Ryan - Knee jerk reaction to the Alfie fiasco. Response to female doging and moaning from fan base. Needed to sell tickets. I personally didn't like the move but there have been worse moves made.
Kelly / Fisher - Perfectly fine with these moves.
Bishop - very bad move
signing Jason Smith to 2 year deal - Most of the free agent signings have not worked out well from a value perspective but this is true of most teams. That is why draft/develop is crucial.
Spezza trade - didn't get good value. Did he have the budget to sign him? Personally, I was very tired of hearing all the fans female doging about Spezza and the behind the back pass. Spezza's contract for Dallas - not the best value.
My 2 biggest issues with Murray is that he has rushed too many players into the league (Cowen, Ceci, Lazar) and the free agent signings.
Most teams have bad signings. Take Detroit's contracts for Jimmy Howard and Stephen Weiss.
The team had drafted poorly in the years before Murray became GM and had no cheap, up and coming talent.
Personally, i would rate BM as a B- overall.
- SensFan25
Yeah I think if Murray is making moves to keep the fans happy then we know why we are so bad. I don't think anybody in this city was excited to sign Kovalev, I think most people were like WTF?
And you're right, he has let young players push their way onto the team - so that to me means no management discipline - you see Lehner, Rundblad, Cowen all basically saying they are NHL ready or they'll sulk and I think Murray succumbed to some of that.