Wait, I thought this was a fantasy question. He hasn't earned NHL minutes yet...
- 1970vintage

Ouch

How would a Shink McCann Vey 3 Rd line work.? Yes they re small but skilled

You can't statistically track being a POS douchebag. Or can you?
- LeftCoaster

Corsi.

I don't mind him being a POS I just don't think he is an effective POS in the playoffs when it matters
- VANTEL

He's about as useful as Burrows and fights like him too

Corsi.
- Marwood

I think you need to brush up on your advanced stats...perhaps a meeting with Nucker?

Edler being a best D is a big problem
- VANTEL

Elder needs to go play for someone else !

I am a fan of Hansen. Have been for years but I would trade him if I could get a first.

With two firsts you could move up in the draft
- VANTEL

The right two firsts you can get two real good players ....ALA jake and Jared !

The right two firsts you can get two real good players ....ALA jake and Jared !
- Bullfrog77

We are not trading Jake or Jared

3rd line winger (once we trade Sven or Vey)
- dbot

Give him another full season in the AHL. Bring him up after trade deadline for a good look. I bet another full season in the A and he's scoring 40 consistent down there. Has skill potential for top line winger.

How would a Shink McCann Vey 3 Rd line work.? Yes they re small but skilled
- VANTEL

It wouldn't ....unless you're full pumpkin

Elder needs to go play for someone else !
- Bullfrog77

It would be easier if you cheered for someone else me thinks, I hear the flyers have room on the wagon.

Edler leads the team in virtually every category, there are only 15 players (D) in the league who play more minutes, or have scored more goals. He's not as bad as you make him out to be.

We are not trading Jake or Jared
- VANTEL

I'm suggesting keeping two firsts rather then trade up for 1

It would be easier if you cheered for someone else me thinks, I hear the flyers have room on the wagon.

Edler leads the team in virtually every category, there are only 15 players (D) in the league who play more minutes, or have scored more goals. He's not as bad as you make him out to be.
- 1970vintage

He is crap....he leads a lot of cat agonies because he's on the ice 28 mins a game. It was no fluke that he lead the league in worst plus minus...6 ft 4 pylon that has no idea how to check....I'll take biega , some draft picks an cap relief any time

He is crap....he leads a lot of cat agonies because he's on the ice 28 mins a game. It was no fluke that he lead the league in worst plus minus...6 ft 4 pylon that has no idea how to check....I'll take biega , some draft picks an cap relief any time
- Bullfrog77

Suter is 21st in the league in +/-, so there are 20 players you would have on your team instead?

He would make you his female dog on the ice I bet.

Suter is 21st in the league in +/-, so there are 20 players you would have on your team instead?

He would make you his female dog on the ice I bet.
- 1970vintage

Well that would make me the first in his entire career

He is crap....he leads a lot of cat agonies because he's on the ice 28 mins a game. It was no fluke that he lead the league in worst plus minus...6 ft 4 pylon that has no idea how to check....I'll take biega , some draft picks an cap relief any time
- Bullfrog77

Our D would look so much worse without him.

Do you really want the firedrill gang playing another 25 minutes a night?

I don't like Vrbata

The sooner he is gone the better
- VANTEL

Selfish player we aren't winning anytime soon send him to a contender for a 2nd which is totally reasonable. Completely agree.

Then grab or 1st for Hammy and see what Edler cam bring back for the love of jebus don't wait to long for Edler getting good value back he's worth a bunch at the moment

Suter is 21st in the league in +/-, so there are 20 players you would have on your team instead?

He would make you his female dog on the ice I bet.
- 1970vintage

I will admit I am not a fan of Edler. Saying that I do know what he brings to Canucks. If we were ever to move him we would need something of equal value to come back. We couldn't just say bye nd leave a bige hole. I am always for upgrading but easier said than done

He is crap....he leads a lot of cat agonies because he's on the ice 28 mins a game. It was no fluke that he lead the league in worst plus minus...6 ft 4 pylon that has no idea how to check....I'll take biega , some draft picks an cap relief any time
- Bullfrog77

I see you've been experimenting with Bath Salts. Do you have a spotter, in case things get real bad, real fast?

Our D would look so much worse without him.

Do you really want the firedrill gang playing another 25 minutes a night?
- golfingsince

Easily replaceable for the money were payin him. Could get two dependable defenceman that may actually be able to get their shots past the first blocker and hit the net too. An added bonus might be simply tying up opposing players sticks in front of there goalie. And being absoloutly crazy here if at all possible if they could....occasionally lay the body, well then I'd say the team would be much better off!

Easily replaceable for the money were payin him. Could get two dependable defenceman that may actually be able to get their shots past the first blocker and hit the net too. An added bonus might be simply tying up opposing players sticks in front of there goalie. And being absoloutly crazy here if at all possible if they could....occasionally lay the body, well then I'd say the team would be much better off!
- Bullfrog77

I usually agree with you but there is no way you can get two top D for 2.5 each

I usually agree with you but there is no way you can get two top D for 2.5 each
- VANTEL

Didn't say top d. League average with a bit of physicality would do

Didn't say top d. League average with a bit of physicality would do
- Bullfrog77

Could get a good prospect and Atleast a first rounder for him. Since the league has high hopes for him still. Draft and develop with some vets with character patrolling the line.

It would be easier if you cheered for someone else me thinks, I hear the flyers have room on the wagon.

Edler leads the team in virtually every category, there are only 15 players (D) in the league who play more minutes, or have scored more goals. He's not as bad as you make him out to be.
- 1970vintage

I agree with you 100% on this.

I also dont think we should part with Hamius, our most consistent and steady D man. On a poor D core why part w our most solid guy

Didn't say top d. League average with a bit of physicality would do
- Bullfrog77

I am all for getting tougher but you just can't take Edler out and replace him with Sbisa or Pedan. You need a skilled player to replace him