I never said they were EQUAL!


When you include the almost double Salary and AGE Nash doesn't fit our team at this time.

Tim Murray hangs up the phone.
- MEBSabresFAN

You're not even close...

Ennis for Nash straight up EVERY SINGLE GM in the league would get fired if they turned that down...and Sather would get fired for taking Ennis for Nash.

And Nash will be the top line winger for the next 3 years.
- Stripes77

I believe Tyler Ennis will out score Rich Nash over the next 5 years at almost half the Cap.

That is insane. We are just starting to rise and should have no interest in a 31 year old winger with 3 years left on his contract.
- Slump Buster

How old was Hossa when Chicago acquired him?

You're not even close...

Ennis for Nash straight up EVERY SINGLE GM in the league would get fired if they turned that down...and Sather would get fired for taking Ennis for Nash.
- Stripes77

I think NY fan would be happy with Ennis ++ for Nash. Remember, he is the face of their playoff failure. As a Buffalo fan we should appreciate that.

You're not even close...

Ennis for Nash straight up EVERY SINGLE GM in the league would get fired if they turned that down...and Sather would get fired for taking Ennis for Nash.
- Stripes77

He never said they were equal, he said Ennis has more value by saying he wouldnt trade Ennis straight up for Nash.

This guy is the biggest homer Ive seen. And then when facts are brought up, he just makes things up, and tries to say cute things.

How old was Hossa when Chicago acquired him?
- sbroads24

Around 30?

Around 30?
- Slump Buster

31

You're not even close...

Ennis for Nash straight up EVERY SINGLE GM in the league would get fired if they turned that down...and Sather would get fired for taking Ennis for Nash.
- Stripes77

Thanks for the lively debate about my favorite sport fellow posters

I'm off to play Elder Scrolls and try and Level up DING!

Peace

I believe Tyler Ennis will out score Rich Nash over the next 5 years at almost half the Cap.
- MEBSabresFAN

You can believe that all you want

I'll take that bet all day everyday

Nash in 4 years will probably outscore Ennis in 5...

I think NY fan would be happy with Ennis ++ for Nash. Remember, he is the face of their playoff failure. As a Buffalo fan we should appreciate that.
- Slump Buster

This is exactly why we don't need him on this team.
I will take Ennis over Nash.

I think NY fan would be happy with Ennis ++ for Nash. Remember, he is the face of their playoff failure. As a Buffalo fan we should appreciate that.
- Slump Buster

He can be their face but they aren't built to win. Not enough offensive talent.

As Buffalo fans we don't know what the playoffs are

You can believe that all you want

I'll take that bet all day everyday

Nash in 4 years will probably outscore Ennis in 5...
- Stripes77

Nash will probably score 30 goals until he's 35 or 36. He's huge and has a great shot, not to mention a great skater and incredibly durable

He can be their face but they aren't built to win. Not enough offensive talent.

As Buffalo fans we don't know what the playoffs are
- Stripes77

I don't disagree with that either. While he has been run out of one town already (soon to be two), he is still an elite talent. For me, he just doesn't fit our schedule.

With that... great debate tonight gents. I'm out.

Nash will probably score 30 goals until he's 35 or 36. He's huge and has a great shot, not to mention a great skater and incredibly durable
- sbroads24

Yea but Ennis score like 40 points a season and tries hard.......there is a trophy for trying hard, right?

Yea but Ennis score like 40 points a season and tries hard.......there is a trophy for trying hard, right?
- Mentalorgasm5

I love Ennis, but Nash is a top 5 winger, and maybe top 20 player in the league.

If it's Ennis and a 2016 1st, I'm doing it and going for the cup in 2016-17

I love Ennis, but Nash is a top 5 winger, and maybe top 20 player in the league.

If it's Ennis and a 2016 1st, I'm doing it and going for the cup in 2016-17
- sbroads24

The way we acquired McGinn, I said Ennis, Foligno, a 2nd, and prospect (Cornel)

If something like that can be worked out, get it done. His style would have good chemistry with Reinhart.

I love Ennis, but Nash is a top 5 winger, and maybe top 20 player in the league.

If it's Ennis and a 2016 1st, I'm doing it and going for the cup in 2016-17
- sbroads24

Good luck.
Nash takes a nap in the playoffs.

Yea but Ennis score like 40 points a season and tries hard.......there is a trophy for trying hard, right?
- Mentalorgasm5

Facts

Nash 862 Gms 697 pts -165 7.8 Million 60 Playoff Gms 10 Goals 32pts -28

Ennis 345 Gms 212 pts -133 4.6 Million 13 Playoff Gms 3 Goals 8pts -5


On this roster and its projected climb and development. I'm with Ennis all day every day.

Good luck.
Nash takes a nap in the playoffs.
- Sabresfan88

And Nash has never played with a top 6 like ROR, Kane, Moulson, Eichel and Girgensons.

Facts

Nash 862 Gms 697 pts -165 7.8 Million 60 Playoff Gms 10 Goals

Ennis 345 Gms 212 pts -133 4.6 Million 13 Playoff Gms 3 Goals


On this roster and its projected climb and development. I'm with Ennis all day every day.
- MEBSabresFAN

Cool, you're 100% wrong, go play elder scrolls

Good luck.
Nash takes a nap in the playoffs.
- Sabresfan88

Good Luck,
Ennis doesnt get you to the playoffs

Good Luck,
Ennis doesnt get you to the playoffs
- Mentalorgasm5

We have to give him a chance with decent players.

Good Luck,
Ennis doesnt get you to the playoffs
- Mentalorgasm5

Tyler Ennis will be playing on this team when we make the playoffs.

Rick Nash won't be.

Yikes Ennis and a first now? So we go after guys like ROR and Kane because they are going into there prime and now suddenly we are trading ennis "top 6 forward" and a first for Nash. Maybe if we are near the top of the league at trade deadline we do that. That kind of move is something a team that is looking for the final piece does. Maybe we get him as a rental in his final year and run with that into the playoffs. But right now? No way i'd do that.

Good Luck,
Ennis doesnt get you to the playoffs
- Mentalorgasm5

No.. Eichel, Kane, Risto, RoR will do that for the sabres. Actually I correct myself. Ennis does get us into the playoffs. Its a team sport and he will be killing it with the rest of the guys.