I was never aguing price isnt the superior tender.

did fans run him out when he was 13-20-5 in 2010?
how about when they were worst in the east in 2012?
in 2013 his .905 sv% ranked bottom 5 in the NHL.
price has had 3 terrible seasons and another not good one. Bernier has had 1. give him a year or 2 and see what we got instead of shipping him off for "poop"
- GardinerExpress

i'd ship him off for some one who'll clean the dog poop up in my back yard

i just want him traded now while they can get something in return cause he really is poop, but playing behind a poop Leafs team might make other GM's think he isn't
- the_eye

Well, fair enough. But he's not poop..

He's proven capable on a team that would make price look like pavelec. His numbers are a far cry from what they should be and have bordered on decent. And he's only 26. Not a big chunk of goaltenders have proven to be consistent difference makers at this age. He's only going to get better...

It does the leafs zero harm to keep him if they can't get desired value, which I'm sure won't be an issue. There's to many teams out there interested in that type of goaltender. But if they were to keep him, his value can only go up. Getting greased again next season isn't going to change GM's minds on him.

And in the event you're right, he's the worst goalie in the NHL, and he helps us draft Matthews next June. Sweet.

jeeeeez....
how many times do I need to say it:

Bernier to SJS for Hertl +2nd
or
Bernier to SJS for 1st

jeeeeez....
how many times do I need to say it:

Bernier to SJS for Hertl +2nd
or
Bernier to SJS for 1st
- mr.sir

Done. Especially if it's their 2015 first. That would be about as ideal a comparison to the Schneider deal as could be had.

They won't be trading hertl though. If we're going to draft marner or Strome, getting a solid d prospect out of that deal would be great. Mueller and a 2nd, or a 2016 first if they want us to take some garbage salary in return.

If we're wanting a young centre from them, Tierney is more than likely the one that could be pried away.

Well, fair enough. But he's not poop..


- joel878

He's proven capable on a team that would make price look like pavelec

. His numbers are a far cry from what they should be and have bordered on decent. And he's only 26. Not a big chunk of goaltenders have proven to be consistent difference makers at this age. He's only going to get better...

It does the leafs zero harm to keep him if they can't get desired value, which I'm sure won't be an issue. There's to many teams out there interested in that type of goaltender. But if they were to keep him, his value can only go up. Getting greased again next season isn't going to change GM's minds on him.

And in the event you're right, he's the worst goalie in the NHL, and he helps us draft Matthews next June. Sweet.

Price is already on said team.

Price is already on said team.
- maxbart5

fair enough.

Bernier

Reimer

Both have one I, two e, two r...but there are different letters too, like m and b that aren't in both names

jeeeeez....
how many times do I need to say it:

Bernier to SJS for Hertl +2nd
or
Bernier to SJS for 1st
- mr.sir

Not (frank)ing happening bro

Done. Especially if it's their 2015 first. That would be about as ideal a comparison to the Schneider deal as could be had.

They won't be trading hertl though. If we're going to draft marner or Strome, getting a solid d prospect out of that deal would be great. Mueller and a 2nd, or a 2016 first if they want us to take some garbage salary in return.

If we're wanting a young centre from them, Tierney is more than likely the one that could be pried away.
- joel878

Why not just keep him? Is there a better goalie option available?

jeeeeez....
how many times do I need to say it:

Bernier to SJS for Hertl +2nd
or
Bernier to SJS for 1st
- mr.sir

Your asking Price is a little high....

You paid a high Price for what you hoped Bernier would be.
He didn't turn out as you hoped.
Now that that has been established, the Price goes up?

How so?

WTF are you talking about, better read back, i didn't say anything about drafting goalies
- the_eye

ok but when the talk was about drafting goalies late you chimed in with

goal tending is the most important position of the game, no 1 centre is second most
- the_eye

Your asking Price is a little high....

You paid a high Price for what you hoped Bernier would be.
He didn't turn out as you hoped.
Now that that has been established, the Price goes up?

How so?
- Jeropotato

Bernier has .917SV% as a leaf, on two bad teams. could be worse.

I would definitively sign him long term.
He'll never be cheaper to sign.
- fidopro

This

i'd ship him off for some one who'll clean the dog poop up in my back yard
- the_eye

lets be glad you don't make the decision then haha

Your asking Price is a little high....

You paid a high Price for what you hoped Bernier would be.
He didn't turn out as you hoped.
Now that that has been established, the Price goes up?

How so?
- Jeropotato

How the heck did the Leafs pay a high price? They got him far cheaper than anyone thought.

And yes, he has turned out as we hoped. Very solid numbers on a bad team. What more do you expect?

How the heck did the Leafs pay a high price? They got him far cheaper than anyone thought.

And yes, he has turned out as we hoped. Very solid numbers on a bad team. What more do you expect?
- RogerRoeper

he is a leaf.

value is poop regardless of numbers.
could be a top 5 scorer over the past 5 years and we would have to take a bad contract just to give him away!

hilarious

A 917 save % on a horrific team. That's bad? Come on guys, give him another year. this is silly.

he is a leaf.

value is poop regardless of numbers.
could be a top 5 scorer over the past 5 years and we would have to take a bad contract just to give him away!

hilarious
- GardinerExpress

I'm tired of value of every Leaf players being in the toilet no matter who they are.

I'm going to love the return the Leafs get for Dion.

give him 10 years for 30 million.

just look at save percentage. goals/shots. he's a very respectable goalie.

Bernier has .917SV% as a leaf, on two bad teams. could be worse.
- GardinerExpress

Never said he was....just not sure his value has gone up. People league wide thought he was the Next great goalie when he was in LA....those feelings have diminished somewhat.

I'm tired of value of every Leaf players being in the toilet no matter who they are.

I'm going to love the return the Leafs get for Dion.
- RogerRoeper

Or hate it...if you're expectations are too high.

Or hate it...if you're expectations are too high.
- Jeropotato

Trolling, trolling, trolling, Jero keep on trolling, Jero keep on trolling....along.

Trolling, trolling, trolling, Jero keep on trolling, Jero keep on trolling....along.
- leonkennedy

How is having a rational discussion with other, rational posters trolling?