Would you do this trade ?

To Mtl : Eberle Nurse Scrivens 1 st overall

To Edm : Subbban Tinordi Tokarski Galyenchuck
- VANTEL

That's not too bad actually. I don't give much value to the goalies.

So it's...
McDavid, Eberle, Nurse
for
Subban, Galchenyuk, Tinordi

Lots of people in here missing Garrison right now. Don't remember which of us wasn't a fan of that deal...

Would you do this trade ?

To Mtl : Eberle Nurse Scrivens 1 st overall

To Edm : Subbban Tinordi Tokarski Galyenchuck
- VANTEL

Wow.

That decimates MTL's backend ... but for McDavid... It might be a little too expensive, but if the 1st was guaranteed.

Fleury has a .924 save percentage this year, Miller's is .900
- Nucker101

They are both turds

Lots of people in here missing Garrison right now. Don't remember which of us wasn't a fan of that deal...

- bezz44

Only issue was that he, Edler and Hamhuis were all lefties. They needed a RHD Garrison-caliber d-man.

Wow.

That decimates MTL's backend ... but for McDavid... It might be a little too expensive, but if the 1st was guaranteed.
- hillbillydeluxe

Nurse might be ready next year

They are both turds
- bezz44

I'd take the flower turd over our American hero turd right now.

That's not too bad actually. I don't give much value to the goalies.

So it's...
McDavid, Eberle, Nurse
for
Subban, Galchenyuk, Tinordi
- Nucker101

That's basically how I saw it.
McDavid>>Galchenyuk
Subban>>>Eberle
Nurse>Tinordi

Value seems to be pretty fair

Only issue was that he, Edler and Hamhuis were all lefties. They needed a RHD Garrison-caliber d-man.
- Nucker101

Boychuck or Franson

Linden on the TSN-1040 this morning.

He spoke about the goal for the new year is for greater output from their prospects.

Said he liked that Mccan and Virtanen have started to heat up, and thinks they are finally healthy from their different illnesses.

Said they expect more production in the AHL from Shinkaruk and Gaunce.
9 points and 10 points respectively in 27 games is not good enough.
- classic321

Looking toward the future and having a goal like that is great its nice to see a him doing his job and letting Benning and Desjardins do theirs.

Lots of people in here missing Garrison right now. Don't remember which of us wasn't a fan of that deal...

- bezz44

Didnt like his mobility, Didnt like the fact that his slapshot couldnt hit the broad side of a barn.

But he would look alot better than weber, stanton, Biega etc.

Nurse might be ready next year
- VANTEL

I think both GM's would pass on that one, but maybe I'm wrong. The value isn't horrible though.

That's basically how I saw it.
McDavid>>Galchenyuk
Subban>>>Eberle
Nurse>Tinordi

Value seems to be pretty fair
- bezz44

Something like that, I agree.

Nurse might be ready next year
- VANTEL

Creative. I guess it would have to be an off season move if it is McDavid.

I look at Subban and think Norris Trophy and then McDavid- potential generational...

good proposal.

Didnt like his mobility, Didnt like the fact that his slapshot couldnt hit the broad side of a barn.

But he would look alot better than weber, stanton, Biega etc.
- vancity787

He was arguably our steadiest D-man during the lockout season. Just seemed unfair that he had one "off" year (wasn't even the worst d-man last year) yet several players had struggled for multiple seasons and are only now getting some criticism

Creative. I guess it would have to be an off season move if it is McDavid.

I look at Subban and think Norris Trophy and then McDavid- potential generational...

good proposal.
- hillbillydeluxe

Boychuck or Franson
- VANTEL

Still don't trust Franson defensively, he's been really good this year but I'f I'm paying a d-man 5M+ long-term I'd want to see more than 1 year of a solid defensive play.

I do like Boychuck, I knew we discussed a trade for him during the summer and I thought he would have been a decent fit here. If he makes it to UFA, I hope Benning makes an offer.

He was arguably our steadiest D-man during the lockout season. Just seemed unfair that he had one "off" year (wasn't even the worst d-man last year) yet several players had struggled for multiple seasons and are only now getting some criticism
- bezz44

EVERYONE had a bad year last year.

Except for Santorelli, Who apperently has picked up in Toronto where he left off here.

Still don't trust Franson defensively, he's been really good this year but I'f I'm paying a d-man 5M+ long-term I'd want to see more than 1 year of a solid defensive play.

I do like Boychuck, I knew we discussed a trade for him during the summer and I thought he would have been a decent fit here. If he makes it to UFA, I hope Benning makes an offer.
- Nucker101

I would like to see KB out Boychuck in

He was arguably our steadiest D-man during the lockout season. Just seemed unfair that he had one "off" year (wasn't even the worst d-man last year) yet several players had struggled for multiple seasons and are only now getting some criticism
- bezz44

Garrison publicly came out and told the story of how he was asked to waive his ntc, maybe he wasn't the only one who was asked.

Still would like to know what those exit interviews were like last season.

EVERYONE had a bad year last year.

Except for Santorelli, Who apperently has picked up in Toronto where he left off here.
- vancity787

Centre is not one of our weaknesses .

I would like to see KB out Boychuck in
- VANTEL

That would be perfect. I think the Islanders will make a strong push to keep him though.

Centre is not one of our weaknesses .
- VANTEL

Santorelli would definitely be a huge upgrade on Richie as 3LC though. Hindsight is 20/20, but damn that one hurts.

You guys should get Tlusty and Sekera.

That will help.

Santorelli would definitely be a huge upgrade on Richie as 3LC though. Hindsight is 20/20, but damn that one hurts.
- Nucker101

I think most of us hoped he would be back so it extra hurts