If we want apples to apples, yes. AHL hockey is different than OHL hockey.

Look, if it makes you feel better, I'll reorder my list so Finn is #3 and Nilsson and Mac are 4 and 5. Will that work better for you?
- TheThrill

I haven't seen enough from WcWilliam to be that high on him.

DEFENSEMEN
LEAGUE PROSP. TALENT PROB. OF SUCCESS
1. Matt Finn Pro 7.0 C
2. Stuart Percy Pro 7.0 C
3. Rinat Valiev CHL 7.0 C
4. Tom Nilsson Europe 6.5 C
5. Petter Granberg Pro 6.5 C
6. Viktor Loov Europe 6.5 C
7. Eric Knodel Pro 6.5 D
8. Andrew MacWilliam Pro 6.0 C
9. Max Everson NCAA 5.0 D

I haven't seen enough from WcWilliam to be that high on him.

DEFENSEMEN
LEAGUE PROSP. TALENT PROB. OF SUCCESS
1. Matt Finn Pro 7.0 C
2. Stuart Percy Pro 7.0 C
3. Rinat Valiev CHL 7.0 C
4. Tom Nilsson Europe 6.5 C
5. Petter Granberg Pro 6.5 C
6. Viktor Loov Europe 6.5 C
7. Eric Knodel Pro 6.5 D
8. Andrew MacWilliam Pro 6.0 C
9. Max Everson NCAA 5.0 D
- burn

MAX EVEEEEEEERSON!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!

In all honesty, the biggest thing for brother Finner will be his durability. He is barely even into his pro career and injuries seem to be somewhat the norm.

Fingers crossed that we got a good one here
- TheThrill

He hasn't had a lot of injuries. He missed time early this year (training camp) because of an injury but other than that hasn't had much injuries. He's missed some time from Mono.

MAX EVEEEEEEERSON!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!
- AdamFrench

Putting up the same pts/game basically as Mcwilliam.

He hasn't had a lot of injuries. He missed time early this year (training camp) because of an injury but other than that hasn't had much injuries. He's missed some time from Mono.
- burn

Maybe if he wasn't kissing everything in sight!

Night life problems!

Gonna need dry island in here!

Putting up the same pts/game basically as Mcwilliam.
- burn

Doesn't hit like Scott Stevens though. Only Garnet Exelby ever could do that.

I haven't seen enough from WcWilliam to be that high on him.

DEFENSEMEN
LEAGUE PROSP. TALENT PROB. OF SUCCESS
1. Matt Finn Pro 7.0 C
2. Stuart Percy Pro 7.0 C
3. Rinat Valiev CHL 7.0 C
4. Tom Nilsson Europe 6.5 C
5. Petter Granberg Pro 6.5 C
6. Viktor Loov Europe 6.5 C
7. Eric Knodel Pro 6.5 D
8. Andrew MacWilliam Pro 6.0 C
9. Max Everson NCAA 5.0 D
- burn

Valiev really ranked that high eh?

Wasn't expecting Granber ranked that low, or Loov. both looked good to me.

But we can't rely on eyes anymore. Gotta go check the corsis

Maybe if he wasn't kissing everything in sight!

Night life problems!

Gonna need dry island in here!
- TheThrill

Valiev really ranked that high eh?

Wasn't expecting Granber ranked that low, or Loov. both looked good to me.

But we can't rely on eyes anymore. Gotta go check the corsis
- TheThrill

I think Loov is doing well. I think guys like him and Valiev are more the future than Granberg and Mcwilliam. Those guys can skate really well, move the puck well and defend well enough. Same goes for Finn. The likes of Grnaberg and McWilliam bring grit and good D, and that's it. They may be too slow to make it in the NHL now.

Maybe if he wasn't kissing everything in sight!

Night life problems!

Gonna need dry island in here!
- TheThrill

I had mono when I was 18 - seems to be fairly common around the rink at that age. Freakin kicked the crap out of me...missed so much hockey that year... missed so much of everything that year because of it.

I think Finn is better prospect.

Matt Finn’s dominance in the CHL in 2013-14 positions him as the best all round two-way defenseman in the Leafs system

Second year Toronto Marlies defenseman Andrew MacWilliam, and minor pro rookies Tom Nilsson and Eric Knodel, represent a second tier of Leafs prospects with potential
- burn

I think Finn is a better prospect. But that doesn't mean he's a better player right now.

I think Finn is a better prospect. But that doesn't mean he's a better player right now.
- Feeling Glucky?

I think Finn is a better prospect. But that doesn't mean he's a better player right now.
- Feeling Glucky?

I'm not so sure, and I don't think that was the point anyways. Or else Holzer as I said would be higher on the list (on it at least)

If your glass is still half empty after a game where the Leafs dominated with all 4 lines and game up a franchise record 10 shots against then you are just dumb. Move on Sports is not for you.

Take it for what it is. It's sports and entertainment. It's a game. Don't get too into the analysis of it.

Leafs kicked ass period. Be happy.

If your glass is still half empty after a game where the Leafs dominated with all 4 lines and game up a franchise record 10 shots against then you are just dumb. Move on Sports is not for you.

Take it for what it is. It's sports and entertainment. It's a game. Don't get too into the analysis of it.

Leafs kicked ass period. Be happy.
- 13LEAFS01

Enjoy ya ban.

Team's still poopty