Kulikov, Robak, and a second.
- PanthersGoal

Try again

as long as we can flip Marincin, Musil, and a 2nd for Barkov and Huberdeau that should work
- TheNugeIsHuge

Hey all comedy and stupid trade offers aside, what would you think would be a fair trade for Eberle? One that's fair for both teams. I'll judge your hockey knowledge by your response.

Hey all comedy and stupid trade offers aside, what would you think would be a fair trade for Eberle? One that's fair for both teams. I'll judge your hockey knowledge by your response.
- BravePackCats27

It would seriously take a Howden/Trocheck to make it happen. Plus prob a pick and a roster guy like Fleischman.

It would seriously take a Howden/Trocheck to make it happen. Plus prob a pick and a roster guy like Fleischman.
- Panthers88

No, Oilers need players that are goign to help now. Howden is a LW, they have enough of those, and Trocheck isnt NHL ready yet is a small Center and isnt close to being ready either. THey can just keep the German in the line up if thats the case. They just got rid of Gagner and have Acro, the 5'10 C isnt a player they are looking for in the West to compete

They are not selling off assets for futures in prospects and picks in a rebuilding effort

Pending UFA Fleishmann isnt a player they need, all they do is get worse as a team now by losing Eberle just to replace him with Flash.

They would be asking for Bjugstad or Gudbranson to be involved in any deal, other than that, they wont be listening to any offers. Center and D are their main places of concern.

No, Oilers need players that are goign to help now. Howden is a LW, they have enough of those, and Trocheck isnt NHL ready yet is a small Center and isnt close to being ready either. THey can just keep the German in the line up if thats the case. They just got rid of Gagner and have Acro, the 5'10 C isnt a player they are looking for in the West to compete

They are not selling off assets for futures in prospects and picks in a rebuilding effort

Pending UFA Fleishmann isnt a player they need, all they do is get worse as a team now by losing Eberle just to replace him with Flash.

They would be asking for Bjugstad or Gudbranson to be involved in any deal, other than that, they wont be listening to any offers. Center and D are their main places of concern.
- DDM-Coga

What do you mean Trocheck isn't NHL ready? I feel like you know less and less about the NHL every day. The only reason he isn't up here right now is because Tallon was an idiot and signed Bolland. When he was up here last season he played fantastic hockey. Howden is nothing short of a ball of energy. If they really will only ask for Bjugstad or Gudbranson, then they can take their failures and keep on looking. No way either of those two go anywhere.

What do you mean Trocheck isn't NHL ready? I feel like you know less and less about the NHL every day. The only reason he isn't up here right now is because Tallon was an idiot and signed Bolland. When he was up here last season he played fantastic hockey. Howden is nothing short of a ball of energy. If they really will only ask for Bjugstad or Gudbranson, then they can take their failures and keep on looking. No way either of those two go anywhere.
- Panthers88

Oh youre just being ridiculous now.

I just havent read anything about Trochek as any player to watch coming into this season so I didnt look too much more into him. But the comment still stands, small Center, something the Oilers are geting away from, why they moved Gagner and drafted Draisaitl

Howden is still a good prospect but hes a LW, they would moving their best RW just to put him behind Hall and Perror or force Perron or Howden to play their off wing. Plus they just signed Pouliot who is a LW, so they would just be adding a player to a position they already have quiet a bit of depth in already.

Flash is garbage throw in so there is no value to the Oilers long term.

Adding Small centers or wingers doesnt put them in any position to add to their positions of concern. Eberle is a legit Top 6 Winger and on most teams a Top Line RW. So unless a team is ready to pay the premium on him to add to the positions of need the oilers are lookign to upgrade in, why would they move him for a package of nice pieces of prospects and picks.

No, Oilers need players that are goign to help now. Howden is a LW, they have enough of those, and Trocheck isnt NHL ready yet is a small Center and isnt close to being ready either. THey can just keep the German in the line up if thats the case. They just got rid of Gagner and have Acro, the 5'10 C isnt a player they are looking for in the West to compete

They are not selling off assets for futures in prospects and picks in a rebuilding effort

Pending UFA Fleishmann isnt a player they need, all they do is get worse as a team now by losing Eberle just to replace him with Flash.

They would be asking for Bjugstad or Gudbranson to be involved in any deal, other than that, they wont be listening to any offers. Center and D are their main places of concern.
- DDM-Coga

We are looking for offense so giving them Bjugs would be a neutral step or a step backwards towards the offense gained by adding Eberle. Guddy I feel would be kind of an even deal but not one the Panthers would do as he is looked at as a future team leader and maybe Captain. I know the Panthers might give up some defense if that is what Edmonton is looking for just not sure what it would take.

We are looking for offense so giving them Bjugs would be a neutral step or a step backwards towards the offense gained by adding Eberle. Guddy I feel would be kind of an even deal but not one the Panthers would do as he is looked at as a future team leader and maybe Captain. I know the Panthers might give up some defense if that is what Edmonton is looking for just not sure what it would take.
- BravePackCats27

As Ebs is an established Top 6 guy, it has to be a pure hockey trade to get it done. Value for Value. Cant see it being for the rebuilding pieces.

Kulikov as a starter if Gudbranson isnt avilable, but a significant piece would have to be added as well, dont think 1st or 2nd round picks will do it as appealing as they are, that just means they have to wait longer to see value from them.

Who would you rather see we give up, huberdeau,gudbranson,Barkov,bjustad?

Who would you rather see we give up, huberdeau,gudbranson,Barkov,bjustad?
- harveykline

No Brainer-Huberdeau. All others have star potential, and enough bulk to play in the NHL.

Who would you rather see we give up, huberdeau,gudbranson,Barkov,bjustad?
- harveykline

Dude you're crazy if you think the Panthers would get rid of any of those players! Hubby will be good under Gallant, no way he leaves the team either! Kulikov is the only player I think they'd part ways with from the starting lineup! Plus maybe Howden and a pick would be plausible!

Every post here from Coga is 100% right.

Every post here from Coga is 100% right.
- Horseguts

Cabana Boy.

Cabana Boy.
- PanthersGoal

I prefer Superman.

I prefer Superman.
- Horseguts

No, they 100% are not.

Hey all comedy and stupid trade offers aside, what would you think would be a fair trade for Eberle? One that's fair for both teams. I'll judge your hockey knowledge by your response.
- BravePackCats27

EDM's needs are 2C and top 2D, so maybe something around Eberle for Bjugstad. Can't really see any other proposal that wouldn't be a non starter for either team (i.e. Barkov/Ekblad. 4 small useless pieces for Eberle)

EDM's needs are 2C and top 2D, so maybe something around Eberle for Bjugstad. Can't really see any other proposal that wouldn't be a non starter for either team (i.e. Barkov/Ekblad. 4 small useless pieces for Eberle)
- TheNugeIsHuge

AKA it isn't happening. Guys, we have some great pieces coming up of our own; Trocheck, Howden, Hawryluk, etc... we don't need Eberle.

AKA it isn't happening. Guys, we have some great pieces coming up of our own; Trocheck, Howden, Hawryluk, etc... we don't need Eberle.
- Panthers88

I hope you're right cause I'm not so sure any of the players you mentioned are gonna bring the offense Eberle would.


Let me also add that there is no way I would trade Big BJugs for him either.

I hope you're right cause I'm not so sure any of the players you mentioned are gonna bring the offense Eberle would.


Let me also add that there is no way I would trade Big BJugs for him either.
- BravePackCats27

Yeah never.

AKA it isn't happening. Guys, we have some great pieces coming up of our own; Trocheck, Howden, Hawryluk, etc... we don't need Eberle.
- Panthers88

Yes we do

Yes we do
- harveykline

No we really don't. We'll be fine with the kids we have. You trade for Eberle and you set us back even more.

I'd consider a package involving Huberdeau, but not Bjugstad.

No we really don't. We'll be fine with the kids we have. You trade for Eberle and you set us back even more.

I'd consider a package involving Huberdeau, but not Bjugstad.
- Panthers88

If you don't try you not trying to win. Eberle is better than any forward we presently have

If you don't try you not trying to win. Eberle is better than any forward we presently have
- harveykline

Granted. Like I said I like him, but Bjugstad isn't going anywhere. Neither are Gudbranson or Barkov.

Granted. Like I said I like him, but Bjugstad isn't going anywhere. Neither are Gudbranson or Barkov.
- Panthers88

Hope you got Pirri in your fantasy league

Same old poopty ass panthers