So Petr Stastny is on your list? if that's the case I want to add him to my list

800 points 531 GP ~ Sid less point more games
977 GP 450 G 789A 1239 total points
- btbossman

NO

XxNYIxX

So Petr Stastny is on your list? if that's the case I want to add him to my list

800 points 531 GP ~ Sid less point more games
977 GP 450 G 789A 1239 total points
- btbossman

not trying to be rude, i just dont see the connection...

Their are plenty of non generational players in the hall of fame... Who cares

im saying work ethic maximizes talent, it doesnt create talent.
- LetsGoIsles

Gotcha but I still don't think that's 100% accurate but not worth debating right now.

not trying to be rude, i just dont see the connection...
- LetsGoIsles

Nothing rude with disagreeing. Like I said I think Sid is a great player. Just not there yet. I'm trying to clarify the credentials on what classified as a Generational player. That's all. Is it Art Ross? Stanley Cups? Points?


If Sids there why not Malkin or St. Louis?

Jagr should on the list?

Fellas....I have 2 kids now. Both girls.

Scary, I know!!
- potvin05

congrats

Why does EK still have the Isles interested in Devon Setoguchi ???? am I missing something or is really that bad...

Why does EK still have the Isles interested in Devon Setoguchi ???? am I missing something or is really that bad...
- Nolanders

random team generator came up with the Isles. Pretty sure his sources are a dart board.

Gotcha but I still don't think that's 100% accurate but not worth debating right now.
- Vukota

Summer is the worst for hockey fans.

Summer is the worst for hockey fans.
- eichiefs9

GM's love their summer vacation. They cannot be bothered making trades.

Nothing rude with disagreeing. Like I said I think Sid is a great player. Just not there yet. I'm trying to clarify the credentials on what classified as a Generational player. That's all. Is it Art Ross? Stanley Cups? Points?


If Sids there why not Malkin or St. Louis?

Jagr should on the list?
- btbossman

i think jagr could be on that list as well...

i think id classify this "generational talent" as the hall of fame of the hall of fame.

i think jagr could be on that list as well...

i think id classify this "generational talent" as the hall of fame of the hall of fame.
- LetsGoIsles

The SEAL Team Six of hockey players

i think jagr could be on that list as well...

i think id classify this "generational talent" as the hall of fame of the hall of fame.
- LetsGoIsles

I agree and that's why I didn't have Sid or Jagr on my list "Generational players" yet. Jagr could be there because he's near the end of career and if Jagr goes on then I think Mark Messier should be in as well.
That's why I kept it to players that changed the game. If Sid goes down and doesn't play more then a few more years we're looking at another Lindros. There so many great HOF players over the years. It's too hard to narrow it down to the title "Generational players"

It's been fun discussion

My list
Gretzky
Mario Lemieux
Bobby Orr
Gordie Howe
Patrick Roy
Rocket Richard
Bobby Hull
Doug Harvey

I agree and that's why I didn't have Sid or Jagr on my list "Generational players" yet. Jagr could be there because he's near the end of career and if Jagr goes on then I think Mark Messier should be in as well.
That's why I kept it to players that changed the game. If Sid goes down and doesn't play more then a few more years we're looking at another Lindros. There so many great HOF players over the years. It's too hard to narrow it down to the title "Generational players"

It's been fun discussion

My list
Gretzky
Mario Lemieux
Bobby Orr
Gordie Howe
Patrick Roy
Rocket Richard
Bobby Hull
Doug Harvey
- btbossman

Ryan Smyth

Thanks Spartarti!



(checks in the mail)
- Josh_Bailey

Anytime Josh. LOL

Ryan Smyth
- eichiefs9

Now you got it!

XxNYIxX

No need for setuguchi Nelson already Better than him.

Their are plenty of non generational players in the hall of fame... Who cares
- Dan Petriw

Im with you on this one.

Summer is the worst for hockey fans.
- eichiefs9

yes it is. this the time things that don't even matter are discussed to death, and where people get pissy in the heat.

up next, worst islanders turnover of the year. post your selection complete with video clip

yes it is. this the time things that don't even matter are discussed to death, and where people get pissy in the heat.

up next, worst islanders turnover of the year. post your selection complete with video clip
- Isles_since_6

the one against detroit where amac crashes into Poulin i believe

Fellas....I have 2 kids now. Both girls.

Scary, I know!!
- potvin05

Congrats.

the one against detroit where amac crashes into Poulin i believe
- Dan Petriw

The one where AMac crashes into Poulin?

The one where AMac crashes into Poulin?
- UIF

I remember that one

XxNYIxX

Thanks fellas!

I've been offline all day so sorry for the delayed response. Really crazy how life can humble you sometimes....but I've never been happier.

She needs a surgery on Monday...so, although I'm confident this little girl can already take on the world...say a prayer, wish some luck, do whatever little thing you can to help pull her through.

Thanks fellas!

I've been offline all day so sorry for the delayed response. Really crazy how life can humble you sometimes....but I've never been happier.

She needs a surgery on Monday...so, although I'm confident this little girl can already take on the world...say a prayer, wish some luck, do whatever little thing you can to help pull her through.


- potvin05

She is in my thoughts and prayers.

XxNYIxX