I think that's what I was saying - they look at players relative to the salary. To put it another way, if a GM is looking for PP help on the blue line for the playoffs they will take a look at Franson at that $
- Canada Cup
Interesting take on it , Id say he got what his market value is, somewhere in between these 2 lists
http://www.thescore.com/news/540391
Only group 2 restricted free agents can serve as "comparable players" in the salary arbitration process.
If the Maple Leafs are looking at a $2-million valuation of Franson, then they would seem to be alleging that the following players are comparable:
Vancouver Canucks D Chris Tanev (one-year, $2-million AAV)
Calgary Flames D T.J. Brodie (two-years, $2.15-million AAV)
Ottawa Senators D Patrick Wiercioch (three-years, $2-million AAV)
New York Islanders D Calvin de Haan (three-years, $1.966-million AAV)
Detroit Red Wings D Jakub Kindl (four-years, 2.4-million AAV).
There's a player or two on that list who a rational actor definitely wouldn't trade straight up for Franson (namely Brodie), but we're evaluating a case, not the players.
Taking those five comparable players and Franson, let's go from the season before their current contracts kicked in, and take a quick look at how their career games played, career point production, and average time on ice (in the season before their current deal kicked in) compared with Franson:
Defenseman Career GP Career Points TOI/G
Cody Franson 322 133 20:41
Patrick Wiercioch 50 21 15:41
Calvin de Haan 52 16 21:01
Chris Tanev 156 27 20:44
Jakub Kindl 147 30 18:33
T.J. Brodie 104 28 20:13
Based on Franson's service time and production, it seems probable that he's not a $2-million asset.
So how does his resume stack up with players that Franson's camp is likely alleging are comparable? We'll use the following five names:
Los Angeles Kings defender Slava Voynov (six-year, $4.166 million AAV)
Florida Panthers defender Dmitry Kulikov (three-year, $4.33 million AAV)
Nashville Predators defender Roman Josi (seven-year, $4 million AAV)
Washington Capitals defender John Carlson (six-year, $3.966 million AAV)
Anaheim Ducks defender Cam Fowler (five-year, $4 million AAV)
Here's the comparison table - using the same very simple criteria: career games played, career points, average ice-time; compiled from the season before they signed their current contract extension.
Defenseman Career GP Career Points TOI/G
Cody Franson 322 133 20:41
Slava Voynov 102 45 22:18
Roman Josi 100 34 23:31
Dmitry Kulikov 313 99 21:41
John Carlson 186 75 21:51
Cam Fowler 195 80 20:26